• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

DF: Grand Theft Auto 5 'Next-Gen' Upgrades Analysis: PS5 vs PS4 vs Maxed-Out PC!

S0ULZB0URNE

Member
Another one for the champ.

HbU5ttz.gif
 

ethomaz

Banned
thanks for the write up!
I didn't catch alex describing resolution.
If both performance and performance RT are 1440p60.. then what's the point of performance mode ?:p
And any idea if performance RT mode is flat 1440p or using some checkrboarding or something to upscale to fake 4k ?
I checked again.


"Three rendering modes are on offer: fidelity at 4K30, performance at 1440p60 and performance RT, also at 1440p60."

Yeap he says 1440p60 for both.
He says the preferred mode to play is Performance RT.
Seems like the Performance mode has better graphical settings than Performance RT but miss the RT shadows that makes all the difference and fix a lot of issues (even on PC with Nvidia PCSS shadows).
 
Last edited:

AlexxKidd

Member
That's why that guy's videos were banned here at one point. That's running the Xbox BC version and trying to pass it off as the next-gen version. It's not over a minute load time on the XSX version.
Clearly there's something wrong here, other comparisons show either almost the same or slightly in favor of SX loading times.

Did Digital Foundry do a XSX/PS5 comparison or only PS5/PC one?
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
You're asking me what a different source has to do with load time comparisons from different sources?

I'm asking you why you're asking me which versions DF compared when I replied to your previous post about the long load times, when another source has lesser load times on all consoles.

DF hasn't done a PS5 vs Xbox comparison yet.
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
Did Digital Foundry do a XSX/PS5 comparison or only PS5/PC one?

DF didn't do a XSX comparison.

That YouTuber is deliberately lying to paint the XSX in a bad light by showing the XBO version's load times. It's not a minute long and a dead giveaway is that the next gen (both XSX and PS5) load screens show a percentage loaded on the status bar. That is missing on his "XSX/XSS" footage. He's lying and needs to be banned here again.
 

AlexxKidd

Member
I'm asking you why you're asking me which versions DF compared when I replied to your previous post about the long load times, when another source has lesser load times on all consoles.

Because one source said something, and another source said something else. I was asking if Digital Foundry did one to get yet another (trusted) source to break the tie. Is it really that hard for you to understand?

DF hasn't done a PS5 vs Xbox comparison yet.

Is all you had to say.

DF didn't do a XSX comparison.

That YouTuber is deliberately lying to paint the XSX in a bad light by showing the XBO version's load times. It's not a minute long and a dead giveaway is that the next gen (both XSX and PS5) load screens show a percentage loaded on the status bar. That is missing on his "XSX/XSS" footage. He's lying and needs to be banned here again.

Well that seems like something that would be pretty easily found out and pretty dumb of him. It's one thing to bullshit textures and pixels that need to be covered with a fine tooth comb, it's another to bullshit load times, something my mom could do a comparison between.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Because one source said something, and another source said something else. I was asking if Digital Foundry did one to get yet another (trusted) source to break the tie. Is it really that hard for you to understand?

Is all you had to say.

Dude your post was hard to decipher, it came off like you were accusing me of something lol, my bad.

Anyway, I'm posting a third source below, a video which is just dedicated to comparing load times.

Hopefully that's the tie breaker you're looking for.



The YouTuber who tried to pass off the Xbox One version as the X|S version is the one who's full of shit.

I'm beginning to see why elemenopee was banned here lol, any comparison video I can find it's almost either identical or in favor or SX. With a almost 40 second lead switching from Story mode to Online.

The one thing PS5 does do better is that it skips the developer logos so first time boot from dash is faster, but then you have quick resume on Xbox to compensate for that.








4-copyjmkl6.png


1-copy8qk88.png


2-copy8bj3y.png


3-copyu4jlb.png






Riky Riky was right again.
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
I'm beginning to see why elemenopee was banned here lol, any comparison video I can find it's almost either identical or in favor or SX.

ElAnalistaDeBits is the one who used the Xbox One version for the loading time comparison. He edited it out of his comparison video after people called him out on lying about that, but people in this thread still are posting the GIF of comparing the PS5 version to the Xbox One version to trying to prove the XSX version has 1 minute long loading times, when it doesn't.
 

Riky

$MSFT
Dude your post was hard to decipher, it came off like you were accusing me of something lol, my bad.

Anyway, I'm posting a third source below, a video which is just dedicated to comparing load times.

Hopefully that's the tie breaker you're looking for.





I'm beginning to see why elemenopee was banned here lol, any comparison video I can find it's almost either identical or in favor or SX. With a almost 40 second lead switching from Story mode to Online.

The one thing PS5 does do better is that it skips the developer logos so first time boot from dash is faster, but then you have quick resume on Xbox to compensate for that.








4-copyjmkl6.png


1-copy8qk88.png


2-copy8bj3y.png


3-copyu4jlb.png






Riky Riky was right again.


It's a recurring theme.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
ElAnalistaDeBits is the one who used the Xbox One version for the loading time comparison. He edited it out of his comparison video after people called him out on lying about that, but people in this thread still are posting the GIF of comparing the PS5 version to the Xbox One version to trying to prove the XSX version has 1 minute long loading times, when it doesn't.

Yep, dedicated loading comparison videos show they're either identical or SX has a slight edge in almost all scenarios.

Plus this game is 92 GB, higher size on the PS5 than the Series consoles. I don't think they fully used the PS5 SSD compression/decompression.

So it makes sense SX has slightly faster loads, but that guys videos are just being proven wrong time and time again, maybe a blanket ban on even referencing his videos on GAF should be next ?
 
Last edited:

Hayabusa83

Banned
Do the PS5 and Series X render at native 4k in the fidelity modes or is it a dynamic resolution? Quite frankly games running at 30 FPS even in fidelity mode is a joke for this generation.
 

Loxus

Member
We all know PS5 can have 2-5 sec loads, so that is kind of disappointing.

What would be funny though, is if Digital Foundry came out and showed longer load times on the Series Consoles.

I wonder who going to say ban Digital Foundry.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
We all know PS5 can have 2-5 sec loads, so that is kind of disappointing.

What would be funny though, is if Digital Foundry came out and showed longer load times on the Series Consoles.

I wonder who going to say ban Digital Foundry.

no one, they arent a banned source which uses last gen loads to show as current gen..
 

ManaByte

Member
We all know PS5 can have 2-5 sec loads, so that is kind of disappointing.

What would be funny though, is if Digital Foundry came out and showed longer load times on the Series Consoles.

I wonder who going to say ban Digital Foundry.

I have the game on both PS5 and XSX. The load times are about the same. The XSX loads are not 1 minute like that ElAnalistaDeBits bullshit gif is pushing.
 
I played a few hours on PS5 and it's definitely a nice upgrade even compared to unmodded PC.

I forgot how trash the default controls were but I changed to the FPS controls and played with the deadzones and acceleration a bit and it's fine on free aim.

The dual sense triggers are laughably bad IMO and I'm not sure how anyone could prefer them but different strokes for different folks I guess.
 

Loxus

Member
Dude your post was hard to decipher, it came off like you were accusing me of something lol, my bad.

Anyway, I'm posting a third source below, a video which is just dedicated to comparing load times.

Hopefully that's the tie breaker you're looking for.





I'm beginning to see why elemenopee was banned here lol, any comparison video I can find it's almost either identical or in favor or SX. With a almost 40 second lead switching from Story mode to Online.

The one thing PS5 does do better is that it skips the developer logos so first time boot from dash is faster, but then you have quick resume on Xbox to compensate for that.








4-copyjmkl6.png


1-copy8qk88.png


2-copy8bj3y.png


3-copyu4jlb.png






Riky Riky was right again.

You do know the first load time in that video had the PS5 at 33sec and XBSX over a min right?

The video you used literally shows that ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed using the next gen version and is correct.

From system menu to gameplay takes over a min on series consoles.

But I like how you conveniently left out that load time from your screen shots.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
You do know the first load time in that video had the PS5 at 33sec and XBSX over a min right?

The video you used literally shows that ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed using the next gen version and is correct.

From system menu to gameplay takes over a min on series consoles.

But I like how you conveniently left out that load time from your screen shots.

Yeah because that first logo one literally has the developer logos being skipped on PS5 and played back on Xbox. The video even points it out.

And that's not what the other video had. It showed sheer load times exceeding one min
On Xbox.

Please tell me you're not that ignorant :messenger_tears_of_joy:
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
You do know the first load time in that video had the PS5 at 33sec and XBSX over a min right?

The video you used literally shows that ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed using the next gen version and is correct.

From system menu to gameplay takes over a min on series consoles.

But I like how you conveniently left out that load time from your screen shots.

No it does not. ElAnalistaDeBits was using the Xbox One version. The next-gen version has a loading progress % after your user name. The Xbox clips in his video (WHICH HE EDITED OUT AFTER BEING CALLED OUT) was missing that because he was using the Xbox One version. Stop pushing absolute bullshit lies to console war.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Weird DF aren't doing a direct PS5 vs Xbox comparison

Must be their budget for the video ran out and they couldn't afford both versions

The video spells out in the first few mins there will be a second video on it soon.

I swear some of y'all don't even watch the content before positing.
 

Loxus

Member
Yeah because that one literally has the developer logos being skipped on PS5 and played back on Xbox. The video even points it out.

And that's not what the other video had. It showed sheer load times exceeding one min
On Xbox.

Please tell me you're not that ignorant :messenger_tears_of_joy:
You and ManaByte ManaByte where saying ElAnalistaDeBits is not credible and should be banned. But yet showed a video proving ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed correct about dashboard to gameplay takes over a minute on XBSX.

And you think it's right to call me ignorant after that stunt you tried to pull.
Michael Jordan Reaction GIF
 

ManaByte

Member
You and ManaByte ManaByte where saying ElAnalistaDeBits is not credible and should be banned. But yet showed a video proving ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed correct about dashboard to gameplay takes over a minute on XBSX.

And you think it's right to call me ignorant after that stunt you tried to pull.
Michael Jordan Reaction GIF

He was using the Xbox One version.

Answer this: Do you own both versions? I do. They both load the same. The XSX version is not 1 minute.

And there is no ElAnalistaDeBits video where he loads the X|S version of GTAV from the dashboard.

And his videos used to be banned here. Using the Xbox One version and trying to pass it off as the next-gen one is flat out console war lying bullshit and his videos should be banned again due to that.
 
Last edited:
DF didn't do a XSX comparison.

That YouTuber is deliberately lying to paint the XSX in a bad light by showing the XBO version's load times. It's not a minute long and a dead giveaway is that the next gen (both XSX and PS5) load screens show a percentage loaded on the status bar. That is missing on his "XSX/XSS" footage. He's lying and needs to be banned here again.
ElAnalistaDeBits is the one who used the Xbox One version for the loading time comparison. He edited it out of his comparison video after people called him out on lying about that, but people in this thread still are posting the GIF of comparing the PS5 version to the Xbox One version to trying to prove the XSX version has 1 minute long loading times, when it doesn't.

What the fuck is wrong with that person?
First he lies in the beginning of the gen in favor of the SeX to make the dispute more fair because the PS5 was winning too much, now he is lying in favor of the PS5? For what purpose?

Please MODs, never allow that channel to be mentioned here ever again.
 

ManaByte

Member
What the fuck is wrong with that person?
First he lies in the beginning of the gen in favor of the SeX to make the dispute more fair because the PS5 was winning too much, now he is lying in favor of the PS5? For what purpose?

Please MODs, never allow that channel to be mentioned here ever again.

Hell when I get home tonight I'll record two clips from the XSX and PS5 of loading from the title screen and post them here. They're both the same with maybe a 1 or 2 second difference between them.
 
What the fuck is wrong with that person?
First he lies in the beginning of the gen in favor of the SeX to make the dispute more fair because the PS5 was winning too much, now he is lying in favor of the PS5? For what purpose?

Please MODs, never allow that channel to be mentioned here ever again.

Clicks I suppose.
 
Top Bottom