• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

DF: Grand Theft Auto 5 'Next-Gen' Upgrades Analysis: PS5 vs PS4 vs Maxed-Out PC!

squarealex

Member
ElAnalistaDeBits is not a console war on favor Xbox or PS5... It's just bad...

He just rushing video to be the "first" (like Cycu1)... this is the garbage of comparison videogame version.

DF, VGTech and NXGamer is the only guys I watch
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
I don't get that video, it says ps4 on the ps5, so it is probably only the ps4 version ?
It is a year old video… yeap it only possible to be the the BC versions.

I thought he was joking… I mean AnalistaDeBits is not better than this video of old versions.
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
Well at least it was the first time Alex said PS5 is the better version…
Maybe it just a coincidence 🤔

Oh come the fuck on. DF said games like Outriders and RE Village were better on PS5. It's not the first time the system won a head to head there. But this isn't exactly a head to head between consoles.
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
Oh come the fuck on. DF said games like Outriders and RE Village were better on PS5. It's not the first time the system won a head to head there. But this isn't exactly a head to head between consoles.
Alex?

Edit - I won’t waste your time… it was Tom and John respectively… not Alex.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Maybe they didn’t get the Xbox copy in time… happens…

They literally said in the video that Tom is working on a separate console comparison video.

Oh come the fuck on. DF said games like Outriders and RE Village were better on PS5. It's not the first time the system won a head to head there. But this isn't exactly a head to head between consoles.

I think he's talking about this video specifically that Alex (the PC guy) is saying that the PS5 version is better than the PC.

Which admittedly he does say at the end, paraphrasing but he says that the RT Performance mode is his new favorite version of GTA 5. Something like that.

But RE8 ran better on XSX.


True, PS5 had faster loading times, but it's a difference of 3 seconds to 6 seconds, not a big difference.

But SX had better average frame rate.
 
Last edited:

SLB1904

Banned
Jan 23, 2021
It is.
giphy.gif
 

azertydu91

Hard to Kill
It is a year old video… yeap it only possible to be the the BC versions.

I thought he was joking… I mean AnalistaDeBits is not better than this video of old versions.
Jan 23, 2021
It is.
Oh I understand now, I had the tab open for a while and only saw that video, now looking at previous posts I get it.Thanks for the clarification guys.
Anyway back on topic I had hoped they would have worked harder on this next gen version, the long distance shadows looks way better though.
Sorry I was probably not careful enough reading the thread but my cat had just pissed on a wall socket and it was animal cruelty time ...(I'm joking don't worry), but thanks anyway.
 

Mr Moose

Member
Alex?

Edit - I won’t waste your time… it was Tom and John respectively… not Alex.
Alex is fine imo, sure his preference is PC but if you have a good PC then yeah it probably would be.
It's Tom and maybe the new guy (Oliver?) I don't 100% trust.
But RE8 ran better on XSX.
In the RT mode in some scenarios, but it also loaded 300% faster on PS5.
 
Alex is fine imo, sure his preference is PC but if you have a good PC then yeah it probably would be.
It's Tom and maybe the new guy (Oliver?) I don't 100% trust.

In the RT mode in some scenarios, but it also loaded 300% faster on PS5.
Lol 2 seconds versus 6. Big deal in a game that doesn't load again when you get into gameplay. But XSX won the framerate battle which most people would agree is more important.
 

Mr Moose

Member
Lol 2 seconds versus 6. Big deal in a game that doesn't load again when you get into gameplay. But XSX won the framerate battle which most people would agree is more important.
Sure, in RT mode, in the other mode they were pretty much locked I think(?). There was one area in the RT mode that made both drop, with PS5 dropping a little more, but they were mostly good.
300% is a big number!
 
Sure, in RT mode, in the other mode they were pretty much locked I think(?). There was one area in the RT mode that made both drop, with PS5 dropping a little more, but they were mostly good.
300% is a big number!
I really can't read people online anymore. Is that last sentence sarcasm?
 
Lol 2 seconds versus 6. Big deal in a game that doesn't load again when you get into gameplay. But XSX won the framerate battle which most people would agree is more important.

I’d say they were pretty much identical where framerate is concerned except for that one area. But even then the two were extremely close with the XSX only being ahead a tiny bit.

The biggest difference was in the load times. But I would consider that pretty insignificant due to how infrequent they are.
 
I’d say they were pretty much identical where framerate is concerned except for that one area. But even then the two were extremely close with the XSX only being ahead a tiny bit.

The biggest difference was in the load times. But I would consider that pretty insignificant due to how infrequent they are.
Yeah I agree, I shouldn't have started a RE8 debate. I was just trying to say the PS5 wasn't better.
 

ethomaz

Banned
The RT shadows are the biggest change in this version.

Sadly they didn’t put it in 4k30 mode… this mod eis useless now and a 4k30RT should be awesome even if dynamic around 1800p.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
The RT shadows are the biggest change in this version.

Sadly they didn’t put it in 4k30 mode… this mod eis useless now and a 4k30RT should be awesome even if dynamic around 1800p.

The RT Performance mode seems like the best mode and the easy go to IMO.

Even Alex thinks it's the best version, better than the PC Ultra experience, now.

Sure, in RT mode, in the other mode they were pretty much locked I think(?). There was one area in the RT mode that made both drop, with PS5 dropping a little more, but they were mostly good.
300% is a big number!

Well, yeah when you put it like that 300% seems large :D

But the actual metrics are 2~3 seconds to 5~6 seconds.
 
Last edited:
The RT Performance mode seems like the best mode and the easy go to IMO.

Even Alex thinks it's the best version, better than the PC Ultra experience, now.



Well, yeah when you put it like that 300% seems large :D

But the actual metrics are 2~3 seconds to 5~6 seconds.

Basically translates to a type writer versus a fade to black screen.
 

Lysandros

Member
Wait Open Surprise is treated like a reputable source now? The guy who posted this shameless lie in his Elden Ring XSX vs PS5 comparison video?
I4GMNiU.jpg

"Better graphics and higher resolution" Right, perfect. All after VGtech, NXgamer and DF stated/demonstrated the contrary... Have some standarts people.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Wait Open Surprise is treated like a reputable source now? The guy who posted this shameless lie in his Elden Ring XSX vs PS5 comparison video?
I4GMNiU.jpg

"Better graphics and higher resolution" Right, perfect. All after VGtech, NXgamer and DF stated/demonstrated the contrary... Have some standarts people.


The only thing we're using from them is the raw load time data captured in front of the camera, nothing else.
 

Kilau

Gold Member
Played long enough to get the plat trophy for a 3rd time. Wasn’t impressed with online mode graphics.
 

Killer8

Member
The RT shadows are the biggest change in this version.

Sadly they didn’t put it in 4k30 mode… this mod eis useless now and a 4k30RT should be awesome even if dynamic around 1800p.

Fidelity does have RT shadows. In fact they are slightly sharper due to the native 4K resolution they have to work with. Alex mentions this in the video.

Fidelity

fidelity10kop.png


Perf RT

perfrtjnk3w.png


You can find the comparison tool in the article: https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2022-grand-theft-auto-5-ps5-tech-review
 

assurdum

Banned
ElAnalistaDeBits is not a console war on favor Xbox or PS5... It's just bad...

He just rushing video to be the "first" (like Cycu1)... this is the garbage of comparison videogame version.

DF, VGTech and NXGamer is the only guys I watch
He regularly claimed exaggeratedly higher resolution on one X analysis than reality, sometimes also sold 1440p on both one X and Pro, 1800p in the MS console. More recently he spotted higher AF in some XSX games even where was the exact contrary compared the ps5. Also I remind all the disdain about the FPS in some Bethesda games via BC by the same Xbox users and how he rushed the release of a video where "proved" steady FPS (thanks his broken tools). If we want to look to those as naive mistakes ok, but I see a common pattern in his errors.
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
Ok here are direct loading captures from each version. Loading right from the main menu where you can select Online or Story. No skipping logos or Quick Resume here. These are cold boots. The loading times are identical. Loxus Loxus please point out wheee the Xbox version is a minute. It’s less than 30 seconds on both.

PS5 - 86.8GB


XSX - 87.8GB


The two versions are virtually identical.
 

NeoGiffer

Member



TL;DR:

- PS5 has a new per object motion blur that made this version smoother than previous releases.

- Much better image quality than it has before than to new TAA method, comparable to the PC using a much more expensive AA and sometimes even better than PC running in 4K. Ambient Occlusion has benn also improved even compared to the PC version maxed out. Shadows are also much better since it uses RT shadows never seen before. AF is still lower than PC and geometry LOD is similar to PS4.

- Three modes available: high performance mode, high performance RT and Fidelity mode. All modes seem to perform very well.


i-dont-care-jim-carrey.gif
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Ok here are direct loading captures from each version. Loading right from the main menu where you can select Online or Story. No skipping logos or Quick Resume here. These are cold boots. The loading times are identical. Loxus Loxus please point out wheee the Xbox version is a minute. It’s less than 30 seconds on both.

PS5 - 86.8GB


XSX - 87.8GB


The two versions are virtually identical.




More perception shattering evidence Mana, folks aren't gonna be pleased.


BleakObedientBoilweevil-size_restricted.gif
 
Last edited:

Azelover

Titanic was called the Ship of Dreams, and it was. It really was.
I never dreamed in my near 30 years of being a gamer, that the gap between generations would be so narrow.

I can barely tell the difference. I almost need to see them side by side, to notice anything.
 
Last edited:

Mr Moose

Member
I've been playing it everyday since release on series x and I couldn't tell you what the load times are since it supports quick resume I load up the game and I'm playing in about 5 seconds lol, looks and plays amazing too
5 seconds? OK gonna need some proof of that.
Doesent it run at 4k30 on the Xbox ONE X? Maybe not ultra settings but looks pretty damn good im sure they can get a respectable 4k60 on next gen
Never mind.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
5 seconds? OK gonna need some proof of that.

112e1jdn.png





Not 5 seconds per say, but in the grand scheme of avoiding the 30 seconds boot + 20~30 seconds load from menu.

It may as well be instantaneously resuming exactly where you left.

Quick Resume is fantastic. My favorite system level feature of the next gen (along with VRR).
 
Last edited:

Mr Moose

Member
112e1jdn.png





Not 5 seconds per say, but in the grand scheme of avoiding the 30 seconds boot + 20~30 seconds load from menu.

It may as well be instantaneously resuming exactly where you left.

Quick Resume is fantastic. My favorite system level feature of the next gen (along with VRR).
They think its 4k on Xbox One X...
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
Wait Open Surprise is treated like a reputable source now? The guy who posted this shameless lie in his Elden Ring XSX vs PS5 comparison video?
I4GMNiU.jpg

"Better graphics and higher resolution" Right, perfect. All after VGtech, NXgamer and DF stated/demonstrated the contrary... Have some standarts people.
Who?
At least the AnalistaDeBits I kind know it existed.
 

Bojji

Member
It was probably like that in PS4 version but this is a nice touch, fun way to use controller features:



Overall, dual sense is nicely used and gfx/performance seems ok.
 
Top Bottom