I have a PS4 and Bloodborne is overhyped, imo.
Shit performance, even for back in the day, and very samey environments. Most of the game is either Yharnam, Yahar'gul (which looks exactly like Yharnam) or the Hypogean Gaol, (which also looks like Yharnam). Then some cathedrals which also look like everything previously mentioned.
Then you have that big ass mansion in the Hemwick Charnel Lane, which I was hoping was going to be explorable but nah, it's just a basement with the shittiest boss of the series.
The chalice dungeons were cool but imo they were a missed opportunity, since they all look the fucking same. Some cool unique bosses in there tho, that was nice.
The DLC was bonkers tho, pretty cool stuff in there.
Overall I'd rate Bloodborne the third best in the series, right below Elden Ring and Dark Souls. Sekiro is it's own thing so I'm not counting that one.
Dark Souls II and III are both inferior to the first one, and Demons Souls is cool but also a worse game, saved mostly by the atmosphere. Still an amazing game, specially considering how it's development cycle went.