Support NeoGAF

[ManaByte]

Clicks I suppose.

Sites like DF or IGN are legitimately trying to compare the technical aspects. ElAnalistaDeBits just wants YouTube views so if he can rile up console warriors to share his bullshit on Twitter as ammo in their plastic box wars, it'll get more eyes on his channel and more YouTube earnings.

 

[MasterCornholio]

Sites like DF or IGN are legitimately trying to compare the technical aspects. ElAnalistaDeBits just wants YouTube views so if he can rile up console warriors to share his bullshit on Twitter as ammo in their plastic box wars, it'll get more eyes on his channel and more YouTube earnings.

Oh I know it’s why I don’t ever use him. DF, NXgamer and VGtech are the best in my opinion.

 

[ManaByte]

Loading from dashboard @2:22 mark.
Not his fault the Series version doesn't skip logo/intro.

Saying he is using the XB1 version and saying he should be banned shows you didn't watch his whole video.

There's a reason, not a season as to why DF is comparing the PS5 to PC.

That's NOT the next-gen version (notice how he doesn't show the icon?). The next-gen version has a loading percentage that counts up to 100% right next to your username. The Xbox footage there doesn't have that.

 

[Loxus]

Oh I know it’s why I don’t ever use him. DF, NXgamer and VGtech are the best in my opinion.

I watch his videos and he just shows side by side comparisons.

I mean, since when did XB1 version of GTA 5 had RT?

 

[adamsapple]

You and ManaByte where saying ElAnalistaDeBits is not credible and should be banned. But yet showed a video proving ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed correct about dashboard to gameplay takes over a minute on XBSX.

And you think it's right to call me ignorant after that stunt you tried to pull.

Bruh you're literally asking me why i "conveniently" didn't put a comparison where one console is running unskipable videos and the other isn't, as a gacha? really ?

Do I need to add anything more to that ?

 

[93xfan]

"AF is still lower than PC and geometry LOD is similar to PS4."

Y the fuck tho?

LoD should’ve been improved. that’s a shame. Not a fan of R* these days

 

[Loxus]

Bruh you're literally asking me why i "conveniently" didn't put a comparison where one console is running unskipable videos and the other isn't, as a gacha? really ?

Do I need to add anything more to that ?

You like to always pick and choose what favors you. This is why I don't like discussing anything with you.

 

[ManaByte]

Bruh you're literally asking me why i "conveniently" didn't put a comparison where one console is running unskipable videos and the other isn't, as a gacha? really ?

Do I need to add anything more to that ?

 

[adamsapple]

You like to always pick and choose what favors you. This is why I don't like discussing anything with you.

I'm not the one who started posting the badly cropped and false loading time pictures in the first place.

Why do you always post something that doesn't align with some users agendas, mana?

 

[Bo_Hazem]

Why not compare maxed-out PC to XSX version for a change?

Their employer doesn't like the expected results.

 

[Loxus]

That's NOT the next-gen version (notice how he doesn't show the icon?). The next-gen version has a loading percentage that counts up to 100% right next to your username. The Xbox footage there doesn't have that.

@0:09 mark.
I guess this person is also not using the next gen version too right?

 

[Mr Moose]

Those are the Xbox One/PS4 versions.

 

[ManaByte]

Why do you always post something that doesn't align with some users agendas, mana?

 

[ManaByte]

@0:09 mark.
I guess this person is also not using the next gen version too right?

Dude I own both versions. From the title screen (not the animated logo and copyright notices) both load at about 30 seconds, or slightly under. Neither one takes a minute.

 

[Mr Moose]

That dude is a banned source for a reason.
Though his footage looks higher than 1080p so I don't know, I'll wait for someone else to do it (DF/VG).

 

[ManaByte]

That dude is a banned source for a reason.

He was, but people seem to keep posting his stuff.

 

[Gamerguy84]

PS5 loading has to be baked in obviously. If it can load HFW open world in a few seconds it could load this.

 

[adamsapple]

He was, but people seem to keep posting his stuff.

Can't blame anyone for that honestly, he's usually one of the first persons who puts out a comparison video for most of the new games that are coming out.

And everyone wants to be the first one to post something new on a forum.

 

[Loxus]

I'm not the one who started posting the badly cropped and false loading time pictures in the first place.

Why do you always post something that doesn't align with some users agendas, mana?

Dude you literally posted a video with Xbox load times over a minute in the same scenario.
WTF

and it's zoomed in to the loading icon to show it wasn't speedup on all devices.

 

[ManaByte]

PS5 loading has to be baked in obviously. If it can load HFW open world in a few seconds it could load this.

Nah based on how bad the original game loading was (and RDR2 for that matter) this loads much much faster.

 

[Mr Moose]

Why aren't they using Kraken? That shit is free.

Can't blame anyone for that honestly, he's usually one of the first persons who puts out a comparison video for most of the new games that are coming out.

And everyone wants to be the first one to post something new on a forum.

He's using an old version of trdrop so can't trust his fps results, and maybe loading times and other stuff he says.

 

[assurdum]

Wow now a channel as Elanalist notorious to be Xbox sided, suddenly cheating loading comparison in favour of the playstation. Some you people have really no shame.

 

[jroc74]

That's why that guy's videos were banned here at one point. That's running the Xbox BC version and trying to pass it off as the next-gen version. It's not over a minute load time on the XSX version.

Its not that, its this:

Loading from dashboard @2:22 mark.
Not his fault the Series version doesn't skip logo/intro.

Saying he is using the XB1 version and saying he should be banned shows you didn't watch his whole video.

There's a reason, not a season as to why DF is comparing the PS5 to PC and not XBSX to PC.

Yup, the thing is, skipping logos is something that was talked about for the PS5 before it even launched. Its a feature, or supposed to be one.

PS5 Will Automatically Skip Studio Logos At Boot After Viewing Them Once

PS5 has a hidden secret feature that allows skipping logos after viewing them once when playing a game. It retains these settings even on a new save file.

twistedvoxel.com

Granted thats supposed to happen after a normal boot showing the logos. And even then its hit or miss when it happens. But...this isnt the first 3rd party game to do this. IIRC RE Village also did this.

Its kinda wild one video calls it cheating....but then shows quick resume in the same video and that's fine. PS5 and Xbox Series do this differently.

A feature is a feature, it is what it is.

Now we see a million loading comparisons...lol.

The PS5 vs Xbox Series comparisons from DF and NXGamer is gonna be a doozy.

 

[rubhen925]

PS5 is better for the algorithm/SEO.

Yep sadly this is the case on YouTube. You don't see a lot of channels focusing on Xbox Series X content because it doesn't do too well. Switch and PS5 taking the lead

 

[Zathalus]

Poor DF, cant even post a video that has positive coverage of the PS5 without being called MS shills. Honestly I'm not even sure what would satisfy that crowd at this point.

Quite sad really.

 

[Bernd Lauert]

People now celebrating skipped logos as a win. Console warring is a hell of a drug

 

[ManaByte]

Its not that, its this:


Yup, the thing is, skipping logos is something that was talked about for the PS5 before it even launched. Its a feature, or supposed to be one.

PS5 Will Automatically Skip Studio Logos At Boot After Viewing Them Once

PS5 has a hidden secret feature that allows skipping logos after viewing them once when playing a game. It retains these settings even on a new save file.

twistedvoxel.com

Granted thats supposed to happen after a normal boot showing the logos. And even then its hit or miss when it happens. But...this isnt the first 3rd party game to do this. IIRC RE Village also did this.

Its kinda wild one video calls it cheating....but then shows quick resume in the same video and that's fine. PS5 and Xbox Series do this differently.

A feature is a feature, it is what it is.

Ok then, do a comparison between Quick Resume and loading the PS5 version. A feature is a feature, it is what is is.

But when you compare the two from a cold boot, when the PS5 doesn't skip the logos, the actual loading is identical. You're on the actual loading screen for about 30 seconds on both. There might be a 1 or 2 second difference between them.

 

[jroc74]

Why aren't they using Kraken? That shit is free.

He's using an old version of trdrop so can't trust his fps results, and maybe loading times and other stuff he says.

Now, I do agree with this.

IMO, that person hasn't been reliable since these consoles launched.

Even the game size, I assume its region related but on my PS5 its 86GB, I'm in the US.

I kept wondering why I saw ppl posting 92GB.

 

[Mr Moose]

People now celebrating skipped logos as a win. Console warring is a hell of a drug

I, personally, count loading in this game from 0% to 100%. Sure, the logo skip will get you in the game faster but the actual loading times aren't that.

 

[ManaByte]

I, personally, count loading in this game from 0% to 100%. Sure, the logo skip will get you in the game faster but the actual loading times aren't that.

And they're identical between the two systems. It's not 2x the loading on one console over the other like ElAnalistaDeBits is pushing for views and others are parroting here for reasons.

 

[adamsapple]

Dude you literally posted a video with Xbox load times over a minute in the same scenario.
WTF

and it's zoomed in to the loading icon to show it wasn't speedup on all devices.

Bruh I think you're having two different conversations in your mind lol.

I'm posting load time comparisons between the consoles where they're actually loading, not where an unskipable video is playing in one of them.

Elemenopee has been banned on GAF long before this video for a reason.

Its kinda wild one video calls it cheating....but then shows quick resume in the same video and that's fine. PS5 and Xbox Series do this differently.

A feature is a feature, it is what it is.

I think he labeled as such because it's not a viable direct one to one comparison.

PS5 doesn't have a quick resume alternate so it just says Not Available, there's nothing to compare with there.

 

[assurdum]

Poor DF, cant even post a video that has positive coverage of the PS5 without being called MS shills. Honestly I'm not even sure what would satisfy that crowd at this point.

Quite sad really.

Maybe not celebrate the higher native pixels counts, could satisfy such crowd and help them to avoid to be called MS shills. Just to say eh

 

[Mr Moose]

And they're identical between the two systems. It's not 2x the loading on one console over the other like ElAnalistaDeBits is pushing for views and others are parroting here for reasons.

Yeah the actual loading seems to be about 20 seconds.
They should've used Kraken to reduce the file size on PS5 (I think it's the largest of the two?), Rock* always fucking something up. Shitty broken CB in RDR2, laughable trilogy and the lack of decent x AF in this game

 

[jroc74]

Ok then, do a comparison between Quick Resume and loading the PS5 version. A feature is a feature, it is what is is.

But when you compare the two from a cold boot, when the PS5 doesn't skip the logos, the actual loading is identical. You're on the actual loading screen for about 30 seconds on both. There might be a 1 or 2 second difference between them.

Uh...I literally said a feature is a feature...it is what it is.

I wouldn't call quick resume cheating, but I also wouldn't call the PS5 skipping logos cheating either...

......a feature is a feature....it is what it is.......

Its not that serious....

Bruh I think you're having two different conversations in your mind lol.

I'm posting load time comparisons between the consoles where they're actually loading, not where an unskipable video is playing in one of them.

Elemenopee has been banned on GAF long before this video for a reason.





I think he labeled as such because it's not a viable direct one to one comparison.

PS5 doesn't have a quick resume alternate so it just says Not Available, there's nothing to compare with there.

Exactly.....so they could have also said that for the skipping logos...

I dont consider either one cheating.

 

[Lysandros]

You and ManaByte where saying ElAnalistaDeBits is not credible and should be banned. But yet showed a video proving ElAnalistaDeBits is indeed correct about dashboard to gameplay takes over a minute on XBSX.

And you think it's right to call me ignorant after that stunt you tried to pull.

As far as i know ElAnalistaDeBits is already banned on this site.

 

[ManaByte]

Yeah the actual loading seems to be about 20 seconds.
They should've used Kraken to reduce the file size on PS5 (I think it's the largest of the two?), Rock* always fucking something up. Shitty broken CB in RDR2, laughable trilogy and the lack of decent x AF in this game

Lets say 30 to be fair, but it might be a little less. It's about 90GB on PS5 and just over 80 on XSX.

 

[adamsapple]

Yeah the actual loading seems to be about 20 seconds.
They should've used Kraken to reduce the file size on PS5 (I think it's the largest of the two?), Rock* always fucking something up. Shitty broken CB in RDR2, laughable trilogy and the lack of decent x AF in this game

Yeah, in general its weird.

The Series S should *NOT* be as big as Series X version either. It should be smaller in size.

R* don't care.

 

[GHG]

How is this thread suddenly about Xbox despite that version not being discussed in the title or the OP?

It's a sickness.

 

[Mr Moose]

Yeah, in general its weird.

The Series S should *NOT* be as big as Series X version either. It should be smaller in size.

R* don't care.

I think it's because it uses the same textures, the only difference is the res (and RT maybe).

 

[ManaByte]

How is this thread suddenly about Xbox despite that version not being discussed in the title or the OP?

It's a sickness.

Maybe someone shouldn't have posted a bullshit gif showing the Xbox versions having 2x the loading times then.

 

[adamsapple]

I think it's because it uses the same textures, the only difference is the res (and RT maybe).

True, true.

Even though I already own 3 different SKUs of GTA V, I'm legitimately considering buying it again before that half price deal ends.

sigh

How is this thread suddenly about Xbox despite that version not being discussed in the title or the OP?

It's a sickness.

 

[ManaByte]

True, true.

Even though I already own 3 different SKUs of GTA V, I'm legitimately considering buying it again before that half price deal ends.

sigh

I haven't played it since the PS3 version, so I'm enjoying playing through it again and can vaguely remember some of the missions I'm replaying now.

 

[Mr Moose]

True, true.

Even though I already own 3 different SKUs of GTA V, I'm legitimately considering buying it again before that half price deal ends.

sigh

Only £9 or something, I will probably get it though fuck the online I hope I don't have to download that crap too.

I haven't played it since the PS3 version, so I'm enjoying playing through it again and can vaguely remember some of the missions I'm replaying now.

I bought it twice so far (PS3/PS4), it's sort of like Skyrim, I'll buy/play it again and again.

 

[ManaByte]

Only £9 or something, I will probably get it though fuck the online I hope I don't have to download that crap too.

Online is included in the 90/80GB download. Even if you only "buy" online you get the full client.

 

[ManaByte]

Only £9 or something, I will probably get it though fuck the online I hope I don't have to download that crap too.

I bought it twice so far (PS3/PS4), it's sort of like Skyrim, I'll buy/play it again and again.

I bought it on PS4/XBO too but mostly to check out Online. Didn't really play the SP on those. I'm replaying it now though at 60 RT.

 

[Mr Moose]

Online is included in the 90/80GB download. Even if you only "buy" online you get the full client.

Fuck. I guess it wouldn't make too much of a difference to the file size since it's the same map. I'll have to get myself an internal SSD soon.

 

[Exanthus]

DF are only reliable when's it's a PS5 only vid.

 

[rofif]

Yep sadly this is the case on YouTube. You don't see a lot of channels focusing on Xbox Series X content because it doesn't do too well. Switch and PS5 taking the lead

or it could be that... ps5 is jut more popular

 

[ManaByte]

DF are only reliable when's it's a PS5 only vid.

Nah they're always reliable.

 

[ethomaz]

DF are only reliable when's it's a PS5 only vid.

Well at least it was the first time Alex said PS5 is the better version…
Maybe it just a coincidence