-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
[DF] Grand Theft Auto Vice City + San Andreas Definitive Editions - PS5 vs Xbox Series X/S Tested!
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
So who wins this epic duel? I can't even be assed watching lol. Too busy on halo.
ethomaz
Banned
It is bad in all consoles.
The difference is that Series X has a performance mode with lowered settings while PS5 has the same settings as Quality Mode with unlocked framerate… that makes Series X have advantage in framerate in performance mode.
But again even the 30fps Quality Mode has bad frame pacing.
The difference is that Series X has a performance mode with lowered settings while PS5 has the same settings as Quality Mode with unlocked framerate… that makes Series X have advantage in framerate in performance mode.
But again even the 30fps Quality Mode has bad frame pacing.
Last edited:
mansoor1980
Gold Member
whoever wins , we all lose
balls of snow
Member
GHG
Member
Off the top of my head - Halo infinite multiplayer, battlefield, skyrim anniversary edition.
They already did a video on covering how shit the port is.
John Wick
Member
These games should have been remade ground up like what Capcom did with RE. I can't believe a company like Rockstar couldn't fund a decent remake. Shambles
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Cherrypepsi
Member
friendly reminder that this is what a few modders did.
It's based on GTA5 and has no missions and cinematics, but still...
how the "Definitive Edition" passed Rockstars quality control is beyond me
saintjules
Member
GHG
Member
Fair enough in that case, I thought the first video covered all the games already.
Romulus
Member
How does that even run at 30fps in any mode on XSX? Seems 60fps would be standard even in quality. It wouldn't shock me if some average developer could get this running at 60fps in quality mode on ps4 pro or X1X
MeatSafeMurderer
Member
I'll have you know I'm king shit of turd mountain.
We'll have no imposters here.
ethomaz
Banned
Both consoles runs the Quality Mode with a very bad 30fps implementation (heavy frame pacing issues).
The Performance mode just unlock the framerate in PS5 but fail to reach 60fps while on Series X it uses a lower graphics settings/resolution but while having higher framerate than PS5 still fails to delivery 60fps.
It is really a mess.
And somebody asked to not blame the developer lol
StreetsofBeige
Gold Member
Patch came out yesterday. Maybe it fixed things up.
support.rockstargames.com
Print
General – All Platforms
Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – The Definitive Edition Title Update Notes 1.02 (PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Switch) - Rockstar Games Customer Support
General – All PlatformsFixed multiple localization issuesFixed multiple instances of missing or misaligned collisionFixed multiple instances of holes in the mapFixed multiple instances of incorrect or misplaced texturesFixed multiple instances of the camera clipping through objectsFixed multiple...
support.rockstargames.com
Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – The Definitive Edition Title Update Notes 1.02 (PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
Created November 20, 2021Updated November 20, 2021General – All Platforms
- Fixed multiple localization issues
- Fixed multiple instances of missing or misaligned collision
- Fixed multiple instances of holes in the map
- Fixed multiple instances of incorrect or misplaced textures
- Fixed multiple instances of the camera clipping through objects
- Fixed multiple instances of incorrect subtitles being displayed
- Fixed multiple instances of incorrect help text being displayed
- Fixed multiple instances of misplaced objects
- Fixed multiple instances of issues with character models in cutscenes
- Fixed multiple instances of audio lines being skipped, delayed, or repeated
- Fixed issues with blurry camera cuts and transitions during Grand Theft Aero cutscene
- Fixed an issue where Pay ‘N’ Spray doors were closed preventing the player from being able to enter
- Fixed an issue where game stalls and props pop into the Gone Fishing cutscene
- Fixed an issue where the player would fail the mission The Thieves with a message “A thief’s dead” after the cutscene plays
- Fixed an issue with failing the mission Last Requests due to Asuka falling out of the boat
- Fixed an issue with a missing GPS route when driving Curly Bob in a Taxi during the mission Cutting The Grass
- Fixed an issue where the damage meter is not displaying correctly in the mission Escort Service
- Fixed an issue with a hole in the map that allowed players to access Staunton Island early
- Fixed an issue with Claude floating in the cutscene for the mission Big ‘n’ Veiny
- Fixed an issue where character models were not animating during the cutscene for the mission Luigi’s Girls
- Fixed an issue where character models were not animation during the cutscene for the mission Give me Liberty
- Fixed an issue where the player can boost their running speed by quickly swapping through weapons
- Fixed an issue where the game would crash when entering a vehicle after completing Triad War (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue where the achievement “Disposing of the Evidence” does not unlock after completing the Dead Skunk in the Trunk Mission (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue where players were unable to rotate the camera up or down while driving at high speeds
- Fixed an issue with Firetruck lights flashing inconsistent colors
- Fixed an issue with GPS route display during the mission Autocide
- Fixed an issue where Pay ‘N’ Spray doors were closed preventing the player from being able to enter
- Fixed an issue with multiple GPS routes appearing during the missions Gun Runner and Psycho Killer
- Fixed an issue with the Hit Rate UI not displaying correctly during the mission Gun Runner
- Fixed an issue with peds incorrectly appearing in the cutscene for the mission The Chase
- Fixed an issue with Tommy Vercetti’s character model going into a T-Pose during the cutscene for In the Beginning
- Fixed an issue with changes to language settings not being retained after a reboot (Nintendo Switch)
- Fixed an issue where the game would crash when switching from TV mode to table mode during the loading screen
- Fixed an issue where the prompt “Error: Out of video memory trying to allocate a texture! Make sure your video card has the minimum required memory, try lowering the resolution” appears while exploring the North Point Mall (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue with the camera popping during the cutscene for the mission All Hands on Deck (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue with rain visual effects
- Fixed an issue with the camera spinning around quickly when finishing or failing Blood Bowl
- Fixed an issue where the camera is incorrectly positioned when returning to gameplay after finding Sweet in the mission Reuniting the Families
- Fixed an issue where a bridge in Flint County is invisible
- Fixed an issue where players can equip weapons while swimming which can cause issues with the weapons clipping through the character’s body
- Fixed an issue where incorrect help text was displayed for swimming
- Fixed an issue where the results screen was appearing at the start of Bike School – Jump and Stoppie
- Fixed an issue with grey pedestrians appearing around the Willowfield and Playa del Seville area
- Fixed an issue with a pedestrian looking partially translucent in the Just Business cutscene
- Fixed an issue with the legal text not being displayed correctly
- Fixed an issue with Enforcer lights not flashing
- Fixed an issue with players not being able to kill Paul and Maccer before triggering the cutscene for the mission Don Peyote
- Fixed an issue where the mid-mission cutscene would start then fade to black before restarting again during the mission Sayonara Salvatore
- Fixed an issue where the game would restart from the beginning when selecting to retry from the last checkpoint on the Mission High Stakes, Low Rider
- Fixed an issue with an invincible enemy during the mission Los Desperados
- Fixed an issue with incorrect inverted controls when swimming underwater when setting them to either on or off
- Fixed an issue with the aiming sensitivity for the Pistol Ammu-Nation Challenge
- Fixed an issue where progress is blocked due to Sweet being killed prematurely during the mission The Green Sabre
- Fixed an issue where the help text does not disappear which ends up blocking the muscle stat from showing it increasing at any Gym
- Fixed an issue with the incorrect time being displayed when collecting rings during the BMX or NRG-500 Challenges
- Fixed an issue with the camera warping during the In the Beginning cutscene
- Fixed an issue where some character models were not animating during some cutscenes
- Fixed an issue with the player getting stuck behind the Cluckin’ Bell counter (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue where Police Officers can be seen floating before a police car spawns during the Reuniting the Families cutscene (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
- Fixed an issue with pedestrian weapon accuracy (Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One)
Switch version is in such bad shape that it might be more straightforward to port the original (PS2/Xbox/PC) than try to patch it. Switch is already missing most of the Unreal 4 visual flourishes, and even if the bugs are sorted it would probably still be sub-720p and have a poor frame rate.
Last edited:
Dave_at_Home
Member
I just can't believe they couldn't do anything with the Renderware engine. Unreal engine destroys the classic look of the originals. I can't even bring myself to continue playing San Andreas. Makes me sad. I'll try again after a few patches.
Rocco Schiavone
Member
The could have done the Remasters based on GTA5. But they went with the cheapest way possible. Let a third class studio do the work with an AI upscaler.
What could Go wrong? Here you see It.
The even removed fine Details from the game like newspapers on the streets. Flying birds in the distance or Cloude showing the middle finger to honking drivers.
Last edited:
Iced Arcade
Member
Will say that update fixed a lot. I mean it still looks like shit but it's better.
squarealex
Member
I found this video very bad and very rushed...
I prefer John Analyse and not some random Youtuber;
I prefer John Analyse and not some random Youtuber;
Bonfires Down
Member
600p, sub 30 fps, awful frame pacing, stuttering, awful visual on Switch. Ok then.
fatmarco
Member
So it's not actually Vice City, it's a mod for another game? So it's not actually comparable to what this trilogy is?
We should be comparing to what modders have done to actual Vice City, 3 and San Andreas.
Cherrypepsi
Member
I brought it up because the whole city is there, rebuilt on a full scale - just like the definitive edition in unreal engine 4
It has less issues and bugs and this is rockstars own engine, but importing anything into Unreal Editor is way easier and cheaper I believe.