So much hard work has gone into the guide, however I think they've bitten off a little more than they can chew here.
For reference I have all their previous guides.
I've only had a brief flick through, but I've already come across two errors sending you to reference other pages where information doesn't seem to exist, so I assume there are many more.
It's also kind of annoying that they don't clearly state what ISN'T in the guide, they mainly just state that this is book is about The Lands Between -- But that's pretty vague.
What they mean is, this doesn't have enemies, weapons etc. But, you don't get told this upfront, more as you explore the book and find out what's missing.
For instance, Talismans are in the second book, and even though they might be on the maps in this volume, they're not in the index so it's useless trying to use this volume to find them.
There are also odd choices, like there is a minor chapter on builds -- but they say that they're going to expand on this in the second book -- So it's essentially split.
I can't really blame them though as a work like this seems kind of doomed, much like Elden Ring didn't get properly balanced until months after it's release, this seems to have suffered a similar fate.
It's presented excellently but the sheer amount of information has made things a bit murky. Much like the game it's self.
It's very interesting read, page by page and is impeccably presented, but you'll spend a lot of time scratching your head. Probably too much.
