• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

TGA Game Trailers YouTube Likes/Dislikes Ratio

Men_in_Boxes

Snake Oil Salesman
Lmao imagine disliking a trailer because you didnt like the main character in it.

Before knowing anything about how any of it plays.

Pathetic
First they came for the Fairgame$
and I did not speak out
Because I am not into Heist games.

Then they came for the Concord
and I did not speak out
Because I am not into Hero Shooters.

Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me.
 

VulcanRaven

Member
ND has doubled down on TLOU2's worst instincts and is clearly out of touch with society.

I'm glad they are making art, but they should be making popular art if they want to sell this shit.

It's a shame, because their popular art is so good, but they refuse to make it because they are too fucking woke.

Disappointed Gordon Ramsay GIF by BBC


Suckle their jimmies all you want, but the gameplay was never the reason TLOU was good. It's a story game. THIS is a story game. The MC and how they look then, become quite important. They should have just given us a character creator instead of this.
So its woke because of a bald woman main character? Very little can be said about the story after this trailer.

The Last of Us has very good gameplay and Part 2 is among my favorites in that department.
 
Last edited:

Nasigil

Member
Lmao imagine disliking a trailer because you didnt like the main character in it.

Before knowing anything about how any of it plays.

Pathetic

Its all CG trailers too, which says nothing about the game.

Also not sure this is thread worthy but I dont want to thread whine
People pressed dislike button on a video because they don't like what they saw in the video.

Shocking concept to you, I know.
 
It's interesting that ND knows how much the fans were put off by or outright hated Abby and their solution (seemingly) for their next game is to double down on that type of caricature for another MC, i.e. cocky, girl boss, with attitude.

Also it's just becoming plain tiring to some people that nearly every Western game now features a strong women as the MC. You can can practically predict every new Western game will have that as the MC and be right 90% of the time.
It's not just that it's a female protagonist, it's a female protagonists that's almost always unattractive, yet completely insufferable.
 

Goalus

Member
AFAIK these dislike viewers only measure the reactions of people that have the app and the only people interested in this data are people who are more likely to be downvote brigaders anyway. Given that the data is likely to be hugely skewed, it seems largely useless other than as a metric for dudes who want to feel like they’re doing something while doing absolutely nothing.
As far as I know, only dislikes from Sony haters are counted, and likes from Sony fans are not counted, so this could explain the numbers.
 

Mortisfacio

Member
Character and DEI aside, I'm just not excited for more retro 80s aesthetics. Netflix made success with Stranger Things and Cobra Kai calling back on the 80s. Guardian's of the Galaxy went heavy music wise into the 80s. Do we need more 80s callbacks in the modern era? It just all feels so "safe" and generic.
 

Clear

CliffyB's Cock Holster
Yeah its an interesting one. I know its a completely different genre, but you'd think someone at PS might be at least a tiny bit nervous with the reaction after Concord's quick demise.

In all fairness if the character's written well and is appealing, it'll work just fine. The issue in my mind is that they are leaning towards to what is a negative stereotype for a significant portion of the audience, a stereotype I stress that was really hammered into viewer's minds by the preceding hours of the show, and is something that needs to dealt with.

The reality is that a videogame protagonist practically speaking has to at the very least be competent at stuff, because its the player's "vehicle" throughout the experience and ham-stringing them is not going to sit well! So, flaws need to be carefully crafted in to make them relatable, and human. The problem comes when woke creatives are so enthralled to their own dogma that they refuse to do this because that would impact the message they wish to send by their "representation" choices. This is why we have these ridiculous, unlikeable Mary Sue types in modern media; the only permissible character flaw permitted by their dogma is to make them abrasive and obnoxious.
 

IDKFA

I am Become Bilbo Baggins
Oh God, so the ignorant children out there that don't like anything not starring a white male are all knowing. God I hate gamers more & more everyday

If that were the case then Stellar Blade wouldn't have been such a hit. I didn't see anybody hating that game because the protagonist was a woman.

I could list a ton more recent games that didn't get any hate for the protagonist being female and were successful.
 
To be fair TLOU 2 is woke as shit. And we still bought it
So I wouldn't say it's premature reaction. Can't wait for the gameplay reveal
 

mckmas8808

Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Yet somehow Onimusha is doing perfectly fine. Here is a shocker, a lot of folks just didnt like that reveal due to entirely yet another predictable ND bald girl boss MC.

Maybe everyone is wrong and the game will turn out amazing, but that first trailer was what it was.
But a bald space marine man is cool? Okay gotcha!
 

mckmas8808

Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Their reaction should be to realize that the diverse girlboss lead is now more played-out and yawn-inducingly cliche than the gruff white male stereotype they are pushing back against, and its actively agitating a solid chunk of their primary market.

So you didn't hear the music in the trailer? The 80s/space vibes did nothing for you? The art with clickable buttons but a future vibe went un-noticed for you?
 
Just from the Intergalatic trailer im a little surprised at the lack of identity this game has. It's like a mash up of Alien (old school tech and not-Ripley), Marvel (GoTG quips and fem Nick Fury).
 

Hookshot

Member
I don't have the YouTube addon but don't want to feel left out

Intergalactic = 👎👎👎

Add a 👎 each time someone else uploads it please.
 

Gambit2483

Member
To be fair TLOU 2 is woke as shit. And we still bought it
So I wouldn't say it's premature reaction. Can't wait for the gameplay reveal
Lets be honest, People bought it on the goodwill and popularity of the first game, including the thought that Joel would be back and Better than ever and Ellie wouldn't have grown into a stunted ugly bulld**e.

Insomniac pulled a similar stunt with Spider-Man 2 (narrative wise).
 

Kotaro

Member
To be fair TLOU 2 is woke as shit. And we still bought it
So I wouldn't say it's premature reaction. Can't wait for the gameplay reveal

TLOU2 came out in 2020, totally different socio-political climate than today, just look at the US election results
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom