Support NeoGAF

[Slothbeing1209]

S- Tier: Arcane
A- Tier : Tlou, Cyberpunk
B- Tier: Sonic, Detective Pikachu
Everything else is trash tier.
Honorable mention: Not video game adaptation but I really like Ready Player One.
Haven't watched: Castlevania, Dota,..

 

[Laieon]

S-Tier: Arcane, TLOU
A-Tier: Detective Pikachu
B-Tier: Sonic 1 & 2
Bad-Adaptation-But-Fun-Movie-Tier: Resident Evil (2002)

Everything else is bad, forgettable, or I haven't watched it.

 

[kicker]

The Hammer & Bolter W40K animated series is decent if you're interested in Warhammer, each episode is self contained but there's some cool episodes

I completely forgot that was out already. Had the trailer boommarked on youtube, will check out

Bumping the thread because tje mario movie selling well just made me realize how mind-blowing it is that detective pikachu is probably the best videogame movie adaptation released so far in terms of overall quality

 

[GenericUser]

>sonic in c tier
I hate this list

 

[LakeOf9]

TLOU is the only real good one
Shout out to Witcher and Castlevania

 

[MasterDerico]

Silent Hill, Sonic 1, Sonic 2 and Mortal Kombat (first one) was the best for me.
Dead or Alive is not that bad as people say...


Ps:Im not rating animations, 2D or 3D.

 

[HerjansEagleFeeder]

No matter what your list looks like, if it hasn't the Warcraft movie in the lowest of all possible tiers, I'm not gonna take you serious and question your sanity.

 

[kicker]

The Hammer & Bolter W40K animated series is decent if you're interested in Warhammer, each episode is self contained but there's some cool episodes

I checked it out. I usually don't care zbout things like visuals, but the tiny animation budget made this a terrible viewing experience for me
Story-wise though, I agree the tone and mini-plots were appropriate for 40k

 

[Icymanipulator]

Cyberpunk and Arcane S tier for sure.