Label people and ignore any nuance in arguments, this is war by definition. Or in some cases pretending to ignore or not see it.
Not sure why you are circling the wagons over this. All companies are on charm offensives, all companies spread bs, the argument covered was clear “talking about removing barriers to gamers accessing games while isolating multiplatform titles to GamePass” + “talking about exclusivity deals being bad for the industry while signing them up and being very unclear about details (see issues around TR exclusivity)”.
Now you can keep ignoring this and just call it warring, but you are the one drawing sides and circling the wagon, not me… fine, but own it.
People are not warring just because they need to validate your nuances. You will be labeled if you call out people for being less productive just because they view all platforms as same.
You want to take an issue with something Sony says and does, go ahead… unless we misquote things (such as the believe in generations quote) for the sake of arguments, we may disagree but respectfully. Well, on my part at least perhaps given your post there.
Funny that you mention that Jim Ryan. Now I rarely mention about their platform or in post those threads(but this is a bungie thread so I am here) but I will do you a favor this time. Why are you now calling people out on "misquoting things".
“As we’ve said many times, with PlayStation 5 it’s a brand new generation, and we believe in generations. So we want to evolve every part of the experience. ” “In many cases, we can’t take everybody with us from previous consoles into [a next generation experience],” Lempel tells Keighley...
www.neogaf.com
They were quoted exactly as everyone perceived there quote when they made that statement. So were you the only one who decoded his statement? Even many people from your side said they fell for it, because they literally championed it.
Yes, but Sony doesn't want you to play PS4 games on your PS5...they believe in console generations remember?
Console generations and (enhanced) BC are orthogonal concepts... of course you knew it and decided to troll anyways
...
Worse they were compared with the Matt Booty quote, even though they literally supported Xbox One upto two years of his statement with all first party projects. I wonder why you are the one accusing them of "campaigning" and even bringing up the Jim Ryan quote. You can't accuse people of misquoting just because their actions didn't match how they allowed their message to be perceived. Funny that you accuse people of misquoting but
“talking about removing barriers to gamers accessing games while isolating multiplatform titles to GamePass”
I wonder how this is not misquoting in your part. So me the exact quote where they said they will bring there games to all platforms? Even though they literally meant xCloud. Funny that this quote from Phil Spencer was never perceived as bringing their games to all home consoles or Xbox becoming a third party publisher in any way by any one. Everyone understood it meant xCloud on Phones and publishing everything day 1 on PC. Yet you treat this as "spreading BS".
“talking about exclusivity deals being bad for the industry while signing them up and being very unclear about details (see issues around TR exclusivity)”
Yeah, Phil has not done any content exclusivity that locks certain portion of the game for one group forever or until they are irrelevant like COD, Destiny or Avengers. No one in the Destiny community liked that and three months after breaking up with Activision they removed that(and
it was not something that Bungie liked either). Bungie still maintains that there won't be any platform exclusive content.