theSlacker
Member
Naughty Dog are great at polished, heavily scripted and cinematic, extremely linear games with bad/mediocre gameplay. They've given no indication that they'd be a better choice than any other developer for a Legacy of Kain project.
From what I've gathered on the subject, LoK needs to be more freeform, tell more of its story through dialogue, allow some exploration, environments needs to have lots of character and story, etc.
Kinda missing the reason why people would want Naughty Dog to make the game. The writer who had her hands in just about every good part of the games works for them. Not to mention that your first sentence could replace "Naughty Dog are" with "The LoK games were", and it would still be as true minus BO1.
Edit: Guess I should mention that I realize that there is no chance for ND to ever be able to do this, just explaining why people would want it.