ProgenitorCastle
Banned
Hey GAF, what games do you know of that got negative feedback, but that negative feedback makes sense for other games instead of the game being criticized? What I mean by this is, for example, I was bored so I was reading up about Clock Tower 3 from Wikipedia, and here's some negative feedback about it:
Game Revolution's AA White wrote that "Clock Tower 3 is ultimately one of those games whose cinemas are more interesting than the actual gameplay and from a gamer's standpoint, that's never a good thing".
As an avid classic survival horror fan, I enjoy the gameplay of the game so I disagree with the above, but I feel like the criticism would be valid for today's cinematic games from most of Sony's 1st party output. Funny how that above quote missed the mark on the actual game being talked about, yet was ahead of it's time regarding how true it would be for later games.
So what say you, GAF? Any games you are aware of that got negative feedback, but that negative feedback made more sense for other games rather than the actual game being criticized?
Game Revolution's AA White wrote that "Clock Tower 3 is ultimately one of those games whose cinemas are more interesting than the actual gameplay and from a gamer's standpoint, that's never a good thing".
As an avid classic survival horror fan, I enjoy the gameplay of the game so I disagree with the above, but I feel like the criticism would be valid for today's cinematic games from most of Sony's 1st party output. Funny how that above quote missed the mark on the actual game being talked about, yet was ahead of it's time regarding how true it would be for later games.
So what say you, GAF? Any games you are aware of that got negative feedback, but that negative feedback made more sense for other games rather than the actual game being criticized?