Support NeoGAF

[lifa-cobex]

For a game.....
It sucked.

 

[LordCBH]

Because it didn’t deserve to be.


I expect BG3 will win it.

 

[ungalo]

I'm not an Xbox fanboy i think my posts can prove it. I think only one nomination for Starfield smells like bullshit, or boycott to say it explicitly. I think about a debate i had on this forum with someone telling me awards are about industry politics, perhaps he was right.

Even more obvious than Starfield, Hogwarts Legacy 0 nomination, pretty baffling even though i don't care about the game. Those two games should have been nominated for best art design, and probably win the award, no doubt in my mind.

But i don't know why i even bother.

 

[Wooxsvan]

 

[Represent.]

Great acquisition

 

[Gavon West]

it wasn't nominated for anything?

It was nominated for something. I think best RPG

 

[Spukc]

bullshit list

What a lame list all dlc like games

• Alan Wake 2 sequel
• Baldur's Gate 3 divinity orginal sin 2
• Marvel's Spider-Man 2 dlc
• Super Mario Bros. Wonder best 2d mario
• The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom botw 2.0

Best Narrative:

• Alan Wake 2 feel refreshing
• Baldur's Gate 3 boring as fuck
• Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty cyberpunk finished also best game for high end pc's
• Final Fantasy XVI eeeh... boss battles are dope the rest is fucking boring
• Marvel's Spider-Man 2 like the previous games battles suck and are just an inch above assass creed games

Best Art Direction:

• Alan Wake 2 agreed
• Hi-Fi Rush such a fresh game loved it with the musical spin
• Lies of P play elden rings instead
• Super Mario Bros. Wonder best mario 2d game reminded me alot of misschief makers level gimmicks are amazing
• The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom if you didn't play breath of the wild.. skip this and play this game, shame this came later

Best Score and Music:

• Alan Wake 2, composer Petri Alanko it was alright
• Baldur's Gate 3, composer Borislav Slavov can't remember a thing
• Final Fantasy XVI, composer Masayoshi Soken boss battles are dope af
• Hi-Fi Rush, audio director Shuichi Kobori king
• The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, composed by Nintendo Sound Team like the first game what sound track? original? yes. boring also yes

Best Audio Design:

• Alan Wake 2 sounds ok so far
• Dead Space fucking masterclass
• Hi-Fi Rush my goty
• Marvel's Spider-Man 2 marvel sounds sick so does this game
• Resident Evil 4 no offense but this is the worst resident evil part yet

Best Performance:

• Ben Starr, Final Fantasy XVI sexy voice
• Cameron Monaghan, Star Wars: Jedi Survivor did not play
• Idris Elba, Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty lit as fuck
• Melanie Liburd, Alan Wake 2 aye
• Neil Newbon, Baldur's Gate 3 did not play enough
• Yuri Lowenthal, Marvel's Spider-Man 2 maybe i should look up some youtube video because i barely made it 1 hour in

Innovation in Accessibility:

• Diablo IV yeah great game to use my mummies credit card on
• Forza Motorsport only game i did not play but i'm sure that special controller from xbox shines
• Hi-Fi Rush no clue
• Marvel's Spider-Man 2 pretty woke good on you netflix did the same a couple of years ago
• Mortal Kombat 1 agreed it preys pretty well on retarded people spending cash on an thanksgiving fatality absolute bottom of the year
• Street Fighter 6 best fighting game of the year with sp content.. but fuck you let's award it accessibility

 

[FoxMcChief]

I can’t argue against the list of games nominated. I either didn’t play them, or agree they belong on the list.

If Final Fantasy 16 had been nominated for GotY, then I might think something was up.

 

[Saber]

Best Family game Sonic Superstar? Wtf? That game didn't show up in any list globally.

 

[demigod]

I blame this guy. He didn’t play it enough for it to warrant GOTY.

 

[tmlDan]

I platinumed AW2 last night and i still don't get why people like it.

it's the same old Alan Wake with poor gunplay, a weird upgrade system, an annoying evidence board, lack of enemy variety, simple bosses, I was so ready for it to finish but it kept going.

Only game I have a hard time understanding why its on the list

 

[StealthGoblin]

Yep, that's the list as I expected it.

Why the fuck did anyone expect Starfield to get the nod over any of those games?

 

[Dick Jones]

Madden wasn’t nominated either.

 

[Warnen]

Cause it sucked

 

[Thick Thighs Save Lives]

Maybe we can add a poll with all 6 GOTY nominees so we can vote here on GAF as well Draugoth ? Also, I think a mod should change the title since it's baiting fan reactions from both camps.
Mod of War Faust

 

[Gavon West]

Meanwhile, Starfield lives rent free in warrior minds.

And will do so well after the awards are done. Still a great game! I can hardly believe I've been playing it 99.5% exclusively for the past three months. Also need to get my hands on BG3 when it releases. Dying to play that one, too.

 

[Loomy]

I don't know if Geoff is on here, but god damn just make a simple text post. A table. Anything but this bullshit.

 

[Agent_4Seven]

Thank fuck for that. Game Awars is still nothing more but a giant commercial though, which has absolutely nothing to do with legit awards (and rewards for that matter) and only exist for one pupose only - to inflate someones ego to insane hights even if it's totally undeserved.

 

[VinnyMac]

Good the game was dog shit. Just because people wanted it to be the savior of xbox doesn't make it a good game

 

[Horseganador]

Spending almost 80 billion to buy companies and not obtaining a single goty candidate is regrettable.

 

[Adam_802]

Starfield living rent free still

Not nominated and still the center of attention in the thread

 

[Draugoth]

Maybe we can add a poll with all GOTY nominees so we can vote here on GAF as well Draugoth ? Also, I think a mod should change the title since it's baiting fan reactions from both camps.
Mod of War Faust

I will try adding a pool.

On changing the title, their call.

 

[OmegaSupreme]

What about engagement of the year?

 

[MasterDerico]

From that list, Alan Wake 2 i liked the most, but honestly this is the year of BG3.
(Spiderman 2 best narrative LMAO)

That's why i love VGA and watch just for the trailers!

 

[eNT1TY]

Makes sense, wasn't even game of the month on release...

 

[SJRB]

Why would it be, buddy?

 

[Dazraell]

Cause it's not a goty material, it's just simple as that

It's a good game, but honestly speaking, it's not even remotely close to quality of games like Alan Wake II, Baldur's Gate III, RE4 Remake or Tears of the Kingdom

 

[Gaiff]

• Baldur's Gate 3 divinity orginal sin 2

 

[Astral Dog]

I like Zelda but im not sure why TotK is on the best Music category(the trailer pieces are bangers but they went for ambience since the last game,and a lot is repeated from botw) or best art direction

 

[Saber]

I'm actually more surprised that Hogwarts is not in that list.
If it's about being rather mediocre in terms of RPG aspects or just because they still has this witch hunt hate culture against J.K I really dunno.

 

[Dick Jones]

I blame this guy. He didn’t play it enough for it to warrant GOTY.

To be fair 11% of Redfall achievements is hardcore gamer level.

Reminder to self to create fake account shilling Xbox and gain the score for ambassador. This winter is cold and I need some socks

 

[James Sawyer Ford]

I platinumed AW2 last night and i still don't get why people like it.

it's the same old Alan Wake with poor gunplay, a weird upgrade system, an annoying evidence board, lack of enemy variety, simple bosses, I was so ready for it to finish but it kept going.

Only game I have a hard time understanding why its on the list

That’s what I feared. I haven’t played it yet. Gameplay seemed light.

I guess visuals are really good, and it’s atmospheric, but this is a wait for GamePass game for me

Maybe they wanted to give a smaller studio some recognition. Honestly I think Hogwarts got snubbed, but I suspect they didn’t want to deal with the trans drama surrounding that game

 

[analog_future]

I actually really enjoyed Starfield, but this can be seen as nothing but a failure by Microsoft/Bethesda.

Can't hype a game up as the second coming and not even be nominated for GOTY on the biggest gaming stage in the world.

 

[Spukc]

hey it aint my baldurs gate 3

 

[kaizenkko]

Another year, another failure. Thats Xbox!

 

[Dick Jones]

What about engagement of the year?

Channing Tatum and Zoe Kravitz would be my guess

 

[RGB'D]

What an awesome thread. Are we just posting games individually that didn't get nominated?

 

[ahtlas7]

I'm actually more surprised that Hogwarts is not in that list.
If it's about being rather mediocre in terms of RPG aspects or just because they still has this witch hunt hate culture against J.K I really dunno.

Exactly. It’s seemingly not nominated for anything. Tragedy.

 

[tmlDan]

That’s what I feared. I haven’t played it yet. Gameplay seemed light.

I guess visuals are really good, and it’s atmospheric, but this is a wait for GamePass game for me

Maybe they wanted to give a smaller studio some recognition. Honestly I think Hogwarts got snubbed, but I suspect they didn’t want to deal with the trans drama surrounding that game

Yea, its beautiful and atmospheric and the story keeps you interested but everything around it is frustrating.

I'm not saying its shit or anything but not a GOTY when games this year were so good.

 

[LordCBH]

Even more obvious than Starfield, Hogwarts Legacy 0 nomination, pretty baffling

It’s not baffling when you think of the politics. There was a near 0% chance of it being nominated for anything even if it had a 100 metacritic score because “writer lady bad”.

 

[Buggy Loop]

What a lame list all dlc like gamesban him

• Alan Wake 2 sequel
• Baldur's Gate 3 divinity orginal sin 2
• Marvel's Spider-Man 2 dlc
• Super Mario Bros. Wonder best 2d mario
• The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom botw 2.0

...Bunch of ramblingbutthurt his favorite game is not GOTY nominee...

 

[sertopico]

Maybe they should invent a prize for it... Something like "best effort of the year".

 

[VeganElduderino]

great list ! its too hard to pick just one! is Baldure's gate 3 worth trying if I don't like turn based games?

 

[OmegaSupreme]

That’s what I feared. I haven’t played it yet. Gameplay seemed light.

I guess visuals are really good, and it’s atmospheric, but this is a wait for GamePass game for me

Maybe they wanted to give a smaller studio some recognition. Honestly I think Hogwarts got snubbed, but I suspect they didn’t want to deal with the trans drama surrounding that game

I'd buy it. I think the gameplay is perfectly fine. The atmosphere and story are what puts it in the top tier for me. There's nothing else quite like it. Besides other remedy games of course. These games never sell huge and I'd like more of them so I'd say give it a purchase. Maybe wait for a discount if you're on a budget but it gets my recommendation for what that's worth.

 

[ungalo]

It’s not baffling when you think of the politics. There was a near 0% chance of it being nominated for anything even if it had a 100 metacritic score because “writer lady bad”.

Yeah that's what i was saying. The boycott is obvious. It's top art design of the year.

 

[tommib]

Goddamn was I close.

 

[poppabk]

That's a pretty homogeneous list, it's almost the same 5 games in every category, makes the year look a lot more boring and anemic than it was.

 

[Heisenberg007]

Good GOTY list. BG3 to take the cake.

Starfield didn't deserve to be anywhere near it anyway.

 

[ManaByte]

Mario is GOTY. Anyone who spent any real time with it will realize that. It’s level of brilliance in gameplay nothing else this year matches.

 

[Alan Wake]

Happy to see so many nominations for Alan Wake II. Hope to see a spread this year and not a couple of games taking it all.