• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

*UNMARKED SPOILERS ALL BOOKS* Game of Thrones |OT| - Season 6 Offseason Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Puppen

Banned
I'm sure they've been fighting HBO tooth and nail on how much longer they want the show to keep going, and that's affected the writing, and what they cut or keep in, resulting in kind of a mess. Keep in mind, what the fuck does HBO even HAVE when this show's over?

They're betting big on Westworld, can't think of any other blockbuster shows in the pipeline.
 

MaGlock

Member
Other side of the coin is if they went with how the books go do you really trust it from a dialogue standpoint if they don't have the words from George himself to adapt?
 
They're betting big on Westworld, can't think of any other blockbuster shows in the pipeline.

Yeah second season of Rome suffered from it for sure (although I still enjoyed it). Of course that was also due to the show being cut short.

It'll leave a big vacuum for sure, they really need Westworld to be a hit (especially with True Detective's season 2 leaving the show's future in doubt and Vinyl being a spectacular ratings bomba).

And correct me if I'm wrong, Westworld's been a developmental nightmare, no?
 
Slightly updated description for episode 1 from AT&T UVerse:

The fate of the 998th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch is determined; ambushed by the Dothraki khalasar, Daenerys has an unexpected encounter with a strong man; a recovering Cersei is reunited with her daughter Myrcella.
 

Pluto

Member
And no, you can't disavow something and still work on it. She can criticize it, but once she calls real people "talentless hacks", she should not receive money from said people.
She isn't receiving money from them. She translates the show into swedish so she is probably paid by HBO Nordic which does not produce the show and is run by different people.
You also don't have to like something to translate it and it's just 10 episodes per year, it's not like this job is the reason she has a roof over her head and food on her plate.


He's a completely pointless character, the physical embodiment of "why D&D".

Important book characters were cut or killed left and right, and somehow he survived? Why?
So that Jon can slynt him after he returns?
 

Nodnol

Member
I've had an awful thought...

What if, come the end, Sansa gets stabbed, and falls into a coma. The maesters tell Jon she will be ok, then suddenly Jon is forced to kill her to put her out of her misery after she suffers from an aneurism leaving her brain dead.

Jon leaves his life and becomes a lumberjack.

In all seriousness, it's a slightly worrying that between GRRM, D&D and HBO suits, no one quite knows how they end this thing, when and where the show should end. Imagine undoing all the hard work....
 

Speevy

Banned
I've had an awful thought...

What if, come the end, Sansa gets stabbed, and falls into a coma. The maesters tell Jon she will be ok, then suddenly Jon is forced to kill her to put her out of her misery after she suffers from an aneurism leaving her brain dead.

Jon leaves his life and becomes a lumberjack.

In all seriousness, it's a slightly worrying that between GRRM, D&D and HBO suits, no one quite knows how they end this thing, when and where the show should end. Imagine undoing all the hard work....

When does Gilly's baby fall off the treadmill and become Tormund Giantsbane?
 

Dysun

Member
I've had an awful thought...

What if, come the end, Sansa gets stabbed, and falls into a coma. The maesters tell Jon she will be ok, then suddenly Jon is forced to kill her to put her out of her misery after she suffers from an aneurism leaving her brain dead.

Jon leaves his life and becomes a lumberjack.

In all seriousness, it's a slightly worrying that between GRRM, D&D and HBO suits, no one quite knows how they end this thing, when and where the show should end. Imagine undoing all the hard work....

Season 6 is when the sister usually starts catching romantic feelings for her brother, should be a good time then
 

SteveWD40

Member
The fate of the 998th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch is determined; ambushed by the Dothraki khalasar, Daenerys has an unexpected encounter with a strong man; a recovering Cersei is reunited with her daughter Myrcella.

Heavily suggesting he is in fact resurrected by episodes end, which was suggested to be a fake rumour
 
- Via Watchers, Emilia Clarke on Conan last night
- The Shortlist interview with Iwan Rheon
- Jonathan Pryce interview with Newsweek




When will the Season 6 OT go live? And who's doing it? Cornballer or Steely, I assume?
Steely is on it. It'll go up Sunday at the earliest.
Wow, only 13 more.
It wouldn't surprise me to see them slightly truncated and have the series end with two 8 episode seasons or something like that. I imagine this might also be a negotiation tactic on their part. The amount that goes into the show at this point is staggering, and as the scale increases, it's more difficult for them to put out 10 episodes on an annual basis.
Benioff said:
We shot 680 hours of dailies, which translates to 3.7 million feet of film. We shot in five different countries – Northern Ireland, Spain, Croatia, Iceland, and Canada. We employed 900 crewmembers in Belfast; 400 in Spain. We issued 140 script revisions. We two shot units a day for 22 weeks straight, three units a day for 10 weeks straight, four units for two weeks straight.




And correct me if I'm wrong, Westworld's been a developmental nightmare, no?
Yup. It's similar to a lot of HBO's recent dramas (see: Lewis & Clark, True Detective, Vinyl, etc...). I can understand some of the complaints about the writing on GoT, but on the overall production side D&D continue to keep the show on course. They're running a massive production and as far as I know they're hitting their deadlines and budgets year after year. Of course, with the ratings the way they are and the anemic alternatives from HBO's drama department, HBO brass aren't likely to complain about production issues if they have them.
 

Iksenpets

Banned
- Via Watchers, Emilia Clarke on Conan last night
- The Shortlist interview with Iwan Rheon
- Jonathan Pryce interview with Newsweek




Steely is on it. It'll go up Sunday at the earliest.
It wouldn't surprise me to see them slightly truncated and have the series end with two 8 episode seasons or something like that. I imagine this might also be a negotiation tactic on their part. The amount that goes into the show at this point is staggering, and as the scale increases, it's more difficult for them to put out 10 episodes on an annual basis.




Yup. It's similar to a lot of HBO's recent dramas (see: Lewis & Clark, True Detective, Vinyl, etc...). I can understand some of the complaints about the writing on GoT, but on the overall production side D&D continue to keep the show on course. They're running a massive production and as far as I know they're hitting their deadlines and budgets year after year. Of course, with the ratings the way they are and the anemic alternatives from HBO's drama department, HBO brass aren't likely to complain about production issues if they have them.

I didn't think of the negotiating angle, but yeah since season 8 isn't formally contracted for yet, they probably have to play as reluctant to do it as they can to get HBO to be as generous as possible. And since the last seasons really will be action and battle heavy, they probably really do need fewer episodes so they can do the multiple weeks-long shoots for battle scenes, but I agree something like 8 and 8 is way more likely than the 7 and 6 they're proposing here.
 
I didn't think of the negotiating angle, but yeah since season 8 isn't formally contracted for yet, they probably have to play as reluctant to do it as they can to get HBO to be as generous as possible. And since the last seasons really will be action and battle heavy, they probably really do need fewer episodes so they can do the multiple weeks-long shoots for battle scenes, but I agree something like 8 and 8 is way more likely than the 7 and 6 they're proposing here.
Yeah I doubt the numbers are finalized by any means (Benioff said as much in the interview), but it sounds like a win-win for D&D and HBO. They get to basically name the amount of episodes they want left and likely get some more production flexibility than they currently have with less episodes to produce in a year. HBO still gets the show on their air for two more years.
 
- EW: Game of Thrones team say no spin-offs, yet, here's why
But as of right now, all sides say there is nothing in the works … yet.

“No,” HBO programming president Michael Lombardo tells EW. “If that were to happen it would have to come from [Benioff and Weiss] really feeling something, or [author George R.R. Martin] really feeling that it was the right thing to do. Not knowing how this particular story ends, I don’t know. There are plenty of characters, secondary characters, [that] you could build a world around. We’re always going to be drawn to a strong creative vision. But we are not going to do that unless we feel their passion.”
Martin certainly has reams of world-building source material amid his published works that could potentially be mined – from the era of Old Valyria, to the story of Robert’s Rebellion, to Martin’s Hedge Knight spin-off novellas.

But when asked recently about the topic, the showrunners say producing Thrones is so all-consuming that a spin-off is not something they have seriously considered. “No, we don’t talk about that stuff,” Weiss tells EW. “The job at hand is too enormous and challenging to be further diffusing ourselves by thinking about spin-offs, and theme park rides, and ice ballets … but if anybody has a good pitch for a good Game of Thrones ice ballet, let us know.”
 

Ozium

Member
Imagine a game of thrones spinoff spun entirely from the minds of D&D

S5-E5-Olly.gif
 

NeoGiff

Member
- EW is doing a GoT podcast this year with Hibberd and Franich

The first episode is up. Hibberd talks in vague terms about the premiere and the red carpet stuff.

Is that Franich guy serious? He claims he's been a fan of the books for over ten years, but then puts forward the ridiculous theory that this season's big battle (as teased in the trailers) will be Boltons vs. Lannisters.

I get the feeling that this podcast is more in the vein of what EW has recently become, which is clickbait and appealing to the masses rather than genuine speculation and reaction (which is inevitable since Hibberd is involved).
 

Gigglepoo

Member
Does anyone else listen to Cast of Kings podcast? It's with a book reader (Joanne Robinson) and a show-only watcher (Dave Chen). Listening today, I was surprised to hear that Dave is still dubious about Jon's resurrection. That's why I wondered if it was the book readers pushing that narrative or the show watchers as well.

Either way, I listen to too many ASoIaF and GoT podcasts already. I have no interest in an Entertainment Weekly one. Blerg.

I listen to A Cast of Kings, A Storm of Spoilers, And Watch the Thrones and then Radio Westeros and History of Westeros. I tried Unspoiled: A Song of Ice and Fire but the guy is just too annoying. Couldn't stand him.
 

Iksenpets

Banned
Is that Franich guy serious? He claims he's been a fan of the books for over ten years, but then puts forward the ridiculous theory that this season's big battle (as teased in the trailers) will be Boltons vs. Lannisters.

I get the feeling that this podcast is more in the vein of what EW has recently become, which is clickbait and appealing to the masses rather than genuine speculation and reaction (which is inevitable since Hibberd is involved).

I mean, after Ramsay rekills Jon and takes Sansa back as his wife, he'll be out of enemies to dominate up North. He'll pretty much have to march south and kill all the Lannisters to keep himself entertained. Then season 7 can be about Ramsay killing Dany. It's gonna be pretty cool when he knocks out Drogon with a single punch.
 

Apt101

Member
I mean, after Ramsay rekills Jon and takes Sansa back as his wife, he'll be out of enemies to dominate up North. He'll pretty much have to march south and kill all the Lannisters to keep himself entertained. Then season 7 can be about Ramsay killing Dany. It's gonna be pretty cool when he knocks out Drogon with a single punch.

His knife-like hands can shatter white walkers, and his piercing cries can topple The Wall.
 
So in anticipation of the new season, I have been rewatching seasons 3 and 4. I still think they are both generally excellent, but there are two things I don't really understand. Well, two that are bothering me right now. I'm a show watcher, book skimmer (and that's only where I picked up the books where season 3 stops, when I just had to find out what happens next), btw.

1) Why do the Lannisters let Stannis sit at Dragonstone unmolested after beating him at the Blackwater? They have more men and far more boats, and he's really quite close to KL.

2) At Joffrey's wedding feast, why did they need to use Sansa to sneak in the poison? Aren't the guards more likely to search Sansa than Lady Olenna?
 
So in anticipation of the new season, I have been rewatching seasons 3 and 4. I still think they are both generally excellent, but there are two things I don't really understand. Well, two that are bothering me right now. I'm a show watcher, book skimmer (and that's only where I picked up the books where season 3 stops, when I just had to find out what happens next), btw.

1) Why do the Lannisters let Stannis sit at Dragonstone unmolested after beating him at the Blackwater? They have more men and far more boats, and he's really quite close to KL.
The Lannisters don't have a fleet. Stannis had control of the Royal Navy and while that has mostly been destroyed, the Lannisters would have to build ships to take Dragonstone (which is what Cersei does in the books).
2) At Joffrey's wedding feast, why did they need to use Sansa to sneak in the poison? Aren't the guards more likely to search Sansa than Lady Olenna?
Sansa was used to implicate Tyrion in the poisoning. And it also makes it so that Sansa has no choice but to play along with Littlefinger because she's wanted for regicide.
 
I'll buy 1, but for 2, they can implicate Sansa just as easily without actually putting the poison in the necklace.

I realize it's a small detail compared to, say, the NW letting a child give Jon the final stab, but it's bothered me for a long time.
 

Iksenpets

Banned
I'll buy 1, but for 2, they can implicate Sansa just as easily without actually putting the poison in the necklace.

I realize it's a small detail compared to, say, the NW letting a child give Jon the final stab, but it's bothered me for a long time.

I think it's also just to separate themselves from the poisoning by multiple degrees. Littlefinger has an agent give it to Dontos who gives it to Sansa. That way if Sansa is caught and questioned, she would have to flip on Dontos, who would have to flip on Littlefinger's guy, who would have to flip on Littlefinger himself before it got back to anyone important. And this way Olenna is only in danger during the few minutes between snatching the poison off of Sansa and making the kill, rather than having some Tyrell agent hold the poison before the wedding and be at risk that whole time.

On the Stannis thing, it's also important that they couldn't pull men off of the war with Robb to go engage in a long and costly siege on Stannis just to deliver a finishing blow to a guy who is no longer an immediate threat. And by the time things are done with Robb, there's a relatively short period for them to have pulled their guys out of the Riverlands, gotten them onto boats, and sailed to Dragonstone before Stannis left.

The show messes with the chronology a bit in ways this make this all fit a little less well. In the books Stannis heads to the Wall almost immediately after the Red Wedding, as soon as Davos shows him the letter from the Watch, instead of spending a while gathering men and getting bank loans like he does in the show. And in the books, as soon as she's able, Cersei does launch a missions to retake both Dragonstone and Storm's End from the handful of men Stannis has left behind there, and even then both of those turn into long, protracted sieges because they're well-defended castles.
 

Sean C

Member
I'll buy 1, but for 2, they can implicate Sansa just as easily without actually putting the poison in the necklace.

I realize it's a small detail compared to, say, the NW letting a child give Jon the final stab, but it's bothered me for a long time.
There's a lot more detail in the books as to why the poison was on Sansa's person, which the show didn't include.
 

Speevy

Banned
37. Like father, like daughter: Keisha Castle-Hughes was very influenced Pedro Pascal’s performance as her on-screen dad, Oberyn Martell. “So much of my performance, especially, was based on him,” Castle-Hughes told HBO.com. “It was really important that the movement was similar, because Obara is the most like Oberyn. She's trained her entire life with him to use the spear like he does.”

tumblr_nn9yhxyLkX1tv9ctro2_400.gif

snakes.gif

tumblr_noj6uxavg31qfb5cjo1_500.gif



3871292-6266420118-N5v3F.gif


game-of-thrones-greatest-weapons_8sj3.gif


3870953-2620272966-tumbl.gif



Maybe he should have taught her how to hold it.
 

Apt101

Member
http://31.media.tumblr.com/ba17d4be162a390b6b1c83923efba7a9/tumblr_nn9yhxyL
[img]http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11/117031/3871292-6266420118-N5v3F.gif

game-of-thrones-greatest-weapons_8sj3.gif


3870953-2620272966-tumbl.gif



Maybe he should have taught her how to hold it.

You can clearly see it's a stunt double until it shows him finishing a flourish. But yea, even with what little of him is real is far better than the sandsnake. She just looks goofy, even at full speed some of the time.
 

Speevy

Banned
What are the rules concerning wight revivals?

Is it like saliva?

Can they reanimate every dead person?

Is it an area effect with a limited range?
 

Turin

Banned
I guess it would depend on how far reaching the Night King's senses are. Apparently he was raising corpses near the Wall even while he was at Ice Mordor.

This is assuming he's the only one that can do it.
 

Speevy

Banned
Well I was thinking back on previous episodes and it seems like everyone's worried about the dead coming back no matter how they died or how long they've been died, but fire destroys the wights pretty well.

Dragon glass and valyrian steel destroys the whitewalkers.

Assuming new whitewalkers aren't being made by the hundreds, killing the Night's King or all of them will probably lead to one of those gigantic magic shockwaves you see in movies where all the wights fall down dead.
 

Speevy

Banned
Since there are no definitive spoilers floating around on this, where do you guys see Theon ending up at the end of the season?
 

WaffleTaco

Wants to outlaw technological innovation.
Since there are no definitive spoilers floating around on this, where do you guys see Theon ending up at the end of the season?

Wasn't there rumors or leaks regarding:
Him joining up with the Ironborns again?

I'm guessing he ends up dead in the Season Finale...by Jon Snow and if not by him than regarding the leak/rumor
His Uncle/Sister or Sam
 

Speevy

Banned
I would think Sansa feels she is square with Theon, which is something that would preclude Jon killing him.

He is definitely going to wherever his sister is, but I have to wonder who the hell the Greyjoys are even fighting.
]
 

Sean C

Member
Since there are no definitive spoilers floating around on this, where do you guys see Theon ending up at the end of the season?
Theon is going with Yara to Volantis (we an see her there from the trailers), and probably thence to Slaver's Bay.
 
Theon is going with Yara to Volantis (we an see her there from the trailers), and probably thence to Slaver's Bay.

Is a visit to Volantis confirmed? Seems weird for the Iron Born to go across the Narrow Sea when Dany already had the ships Viccy is taking to her in the books, which in turn is why we all assumed he had been cut from the show.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom