• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

IGN: Top 10 Best Soulslikes

IbizaPocholo

NeoGAFs Kent Brockman


The legacy of the Souls series is not defined just by its own games, but also by the sub-genre that spun off because of its existence. Covering anime, sci-fi, fantasy, indie, AAA, 2D, 3D, and beyond, here are our picks for the top 10 Best Soulslikes.
 
10. Lords of the Failin'
9.Code Lame
8. Dark Sighers 3
7. Mortal Shill
6. Cash-in
5. RemNOT FROM the Ashes
4. The Splooge
3. Salty Sanctuary
2. Star Souls Jedi: Fallin' over
1. No

There can be only one Souls.

And it's Dark. And Demon's. And Bloodborne, actually. Elden Ring too, maybe. It's complicated.
 
Last edited:

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
I mean is there more Souls-like games outside of From? I am not really sure about that....
 

Troozi

Member
I haven't played that many games on the list, but I really enjoyed Mortal Shell although it was a bit short.
The Surge was really fun - I actually preferred the first one, in one of the areas I remember getting a dead space vibe.
I remember playing the original Nioh and getting about half way through and stopping, I remember not enjoying changing stances. I really need to give Nioh 2 a go at some point.
 

Yoshi

Headmaster of Console Warrior Jugendstrafanstalt
If Star Wars was a Souls like, I'd probably say it is the best. But one point towards that is that the fighting is less clunky than in a Souls and can be made mostly irrelevant anyway by setting it to easy.
 
10. Lords of the Failin'
9.Code Lame
8. Dark Sighers 3
7. Mortal Shill
6. Cash-in
5. RemNOT FROM the Ashes
4. The Splooge
3. Salty Sanctuary
2. Star Souls Jedi: Fallin' over
1. No

There can be only one Souls.

And it's Dark. And Demon's. And Bloodborne, actually. Elden Ring too, maybe. It's complicated.

Amount of work that went into this post is just staggering.
 

skit_data

Member
I found Mortal Shell to come quite close combatwise, although its missing a lot of aspects such as builds. The tone is similar but not executed in the way the Souls-series does it. Still quite impressive for such a small team.
 

SALMORE

Member
3bu5mnb.jpg
 

BbMajor7th

Member
Not a bad list - nice to see NIoh 2 getting a bit more fanfare just lately. Felt like the game was a huge step-up from Nioh - also has probably the single best character creator I've ever come across.
 

sircaw

Banned
Not a bad list - nice to see NIoh 2 getting a bit more fanfare just lately. Felt like the game was a huge step-up from Nioh - also has probably the single best character creator I've ever come across.

hey there, not played 2, but played the first one, can you tell me what in your opinion is a huge step up from the first one.

All I remember about the first one, was the combat was amazing, maybe better than bloodborne in my eyes, yes i said it.

but for the rest of it, humm, can you give me three areas where it has had a massive change.
 

SinDelta

Member
Nioh 2 is pretty amazing. First one is pretty good but 2 is one of the rare sequels that actually vastly improves on everything.
 
Last edited:

FrankWza

Member
Jedi fallen order isn’t a souls like game. It has like 5 different game types mixed into 1. They should have made it more like a from game though. Sekiro with lightsabers
 

BbMajor7th

Member
hey there, not played 2, but played the first one, can you tell me what in your opinion is a huge step up from the first one.

All I remember about the first one, was the combat was amazing, maybe better than bloodborne in my eyes, yes i said it.

but for the rest of it, humm, can you give me three areas where it has had a massive change.

More interesting and varied level design - it's not the easiest thing to spell out, but the first game lacked the kind of smart occlusion that makes Souls level design so masterful. I remember entering the second part of the first level in Nioh, and you could see from the shrine the route you needed to take to get back to open the short cut, so I just ran it, got it open and did the rest of the level from there - kind of on me, but not great level design. Nioh 2's levels are better structured for that kind of organic discovery bringing you out in unexpected places and employ a great deal more verticality. There's also more optional things built in - in the first level there's an optional mini-boss that will open an early short-cut if you can beat him - the second level has several hidden areas and paths with additional loot and return loops.

The revamped skill trees for each weapon are much easier to understand at a glance (granted, they were awful in Nioh) and you've got nearly double the weapons of Nioh's base game. Soul Cores, Yokai Shift, Yokai Skills, the Yokai skill tree and their interplay with your Guardian Spirit(s) add a far more meaningful dimension to your build than Nioh's Living Weapon (which was very set-it-and-forget-it for me).

Really good character creator that you can revisit as often as you like - it's a small thing, but being able to add fresh scares and tattoos to my character during the course of play was a nice role-play experience.

Benevolent Graves bring some much needed balance. It's a hard game and I love hard games, but sometimes, when you're hitting a wall or re-running an area to farm, it's nice to have a little support on-side.

On top of that, there's a huge selection of armour, way more varied enemies and encounters throughout and a new burst counter move which is excellent risk-reward design.
 

sircaw

Banned
More interesting and varied level design - it's not the easiest thing to spell out, but the first game lacked the kind of smart occlusion that makes Souls level design so masterful. I remember entering the second part of the first level in Nioh, and you could see from the shrine the route you needed to take to get back to open the short cut, so I just ran it, got it open and did the rest of the level from there - kind of on me, but not great level design. Nioh 2's levels are better structured for that kind of organic discovery bringing you out in unexpected places and employ a great deal more verticality. There's also more optional things built in - in the first level there's an optional mini-boss that will open an early short-cut if you can beat him - the second level has several hidden areas and paths with additional loot and return loops.

The revamped skill trees for each weapon are much easier to understand at a glance (granted, they were awful in Nioh) and you've got nearly double the weapons of Nioh's base game. Soul Cores, Yokai Shift, Yokai Skills, the Yokai skill tree and their interplay with your Guardian Spirit(s) add a far more meaningful dimension to your build than Nioh's Living Weapon (which was very set-it-and-forget-it for me).

Really good character creator that you can revisit as often as you like - it's a small thing, but being able to add fresh scares and tattoos to my character during the course of play was a nice role-play experience.

Benevolent Graves bring some much needed balance. It's a hard game and I love hard games, but sometimes, when you're hitting a wall or re-running an area to farm, it's nice to have a little support on-side.

On top of that, there's a huge selection of armour, way more varied enemies and encounters throughout and a new burst counter move which is excellent risk-reward design.

This is a big bit for me, i found 1 overly confusing, especially the skill trees, happy this will be better for me to understand..

Thanks for the reply, it was informative.
 

Spaceman292

Banned
This is a big bit for me, i found 1 overly confusing, especially the skill trees, happy this will be better for me to understand..

Thanks for the reply, it was informative.
The game's brilliant but I'm not sure that it's easy to understand.
 

iHaunter

Member
Nioh 2 is pretty amazing. First one is pretty good but 2 is one of the rare sequels that actually vastly improves on everything.
I tried Nioh, but I really hated the Mission style of that game so I returned it the next day.

Is Nioh 2 still like that?
 

Fbh

Member
I need a Hellpoint dev to confirm why Hellpoint isn't on the list.

On topic though, from the Souls inspired game Nioh is the only one I've truly enjoyed.
All the other ones fall short IMO, they all feel like Souls but with way worse combat, worse loot, worse level design and worse art direction.
 

nkarafo

Member
Wait, i didn't even know there are enough "Soulslikes" to fill a top 10.

Did they list every games they could find?
 

AgentP

Thinks mods influence posters politics. Promoted to QAnon Editor.
HTF is Fallen Order souls like? It was a 3rd person button masher with a soulless ginger.
 

MiguelItUp

Member
You know a game is successful when it creates a "genre" for new games that are clearly influenced and inspired by it. I was worried we would see a ton more and it would become oversaturated. Looking at the list I forgot how many there truly are.
 

martino

Member
i see too much title not taking enough mechanics or using enough other mechanics to be called souls like for me here.
 

Lux R7

Member
I'll bite. What are your thoughts on Hellpoint? Never seemed to be a game I had to play.

I enjoyed it. The controls are fine, exploration is rewarding (you can jump, so there is some verticality in it), boss fights are fair and the general souls-like combat feel was there. It is no From game of course but i did appreciate it.
 
Not going to watch the video because of how cringe the term "Soulslike" is, a list would have done just fine but I'm sure there's not enough ad revenue in that.

And I'm sure that none of the games in the video come even close to being as good as any of the "Souls" games.
 
HTF is Fallen Order souls like? It was a 3rd person button masher with a soulless ginger.
Disagree it had a lot of souls like features, from the "bonfire" system, to the enemies re spawning, the highish difficulty, and the style of combat that focuses more on parrying.

If you play it like a button masher you're gonna find the game difficult, but I did play it on the second highest difficulty. Albeit it was a hollow shell of a souls game, I really didn't enjoy the combat that much, I thought the lightsaber combat upgrades were extremely boring and uninteresting. The force powers were cool but it needed more. I really enjoyed getting the stim regen force bar upgrade and combo'ing it with the max force push, cheesed my way through the last boss this way.

The story was ass tho, graphics were embarrassing in some places, and performance was shoddy. I had bosses spawn in a T position, frame drops, shitty textures etc...
 
Last edited:

Arachnid

Member
Disagreed with the list, but it's not horrible. LotF shouldn't even be on the list when there are more deserving games. The Surge 2 is my personal best (HUGE improvement over 1) though I haven't played Nioh 2 yet. I wasn't a fan of the first. Fallen Order was alright. Definitely not second place. Otherwise, not bad.
 
Last edited:

sublimit

Banned
Code Vein was great and deserves more recognition for doing a lot of unique stuff within the Souls formula.

I really hope Namco gives them a bigger budget for the sequel though.
 
Top Bottom