Black_Stride
do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
Humanity on PS+.
Planet of Lana on Gamepass.
I think imma eat.......EVERYTHING!!!!!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Edge Magazine review scores: Zelda TOTK, Jedi Survivor, Horizon Burning Shores, Redfall
- Thread starter GigaBowser
- Start date
- News Hype
Planet of Lana on Gamepass.
I think imma eat.......EVERYTHING!!!!!
It doesn't have the same score. Horizon FW which is the base game has a higher score. If you are going to troll do it right.
Last edited:
Luigi Mario
Member
He meant the DLC though.It doesn't have the same score. Horizon FW which is the base game has a higher score. If you are going to troll do it right.
bender
What time is it?
I couldn't stand the combat and dropped it early on.
Luigi Mario
Member
You guys don't get it, it's actually in line with the Metacritic average.
Last edited:
Shifty1897
Member
Dang, I didn't know Edge was capable of giving 10's. Well deserved.
Kagoshima_Luke
Gold Member
Not sure why they gave Horizon a score.
Should have just used a gif:
Should have just used a gif:
mykedo0909
Member
6 ain't that bad. A 6 out of 10 game will be the only reason I'll pick up a ps5. Earth defense force, the best worst game of all time!
I know but it's a dlc and redfall is the main game. Obviously the dlc is gonna score lower than the base game.
That's funny, I thought this was the exact opposite. Edge seems to fawn more over innovative/high concept indie games with tight gameplay than other reviewers. IGN and Gamespot usually go with the Indie darling of the day I found. Like, if there's a GOTY round-up, I expect some indie/gameplay focused games to be in EDGE's round-up, while IGN/Gamespot I expect AAA games and well known indie darling types.
Anyway, that Humanity game looks trippy. Like a Lemmings meet Lode Runner meets IQube, meets...Pikmin?
Mozzarella
Member
LMAO, do Edgelords at Edge Magazine realize that the 10 scoring scale consist of number from 1-10??
All these scores are 5-10. This is a freaking joke, what is this casual nonsense, use the whole scale or move to 5 point scale!!
Also some turds are getting above average score, these people need to reflect on their critical process.
All these scores are 5-10. This is a freaking joke, what is this casual nonsense, use the whole scale or move to 5 point scale!!
Also some turds are getting above average score, these people need to reflect on their critical process.
StealthGoblin
Banned
Eeeeehh as a very big Zelda fan I hugely disagree with most of those scores.
I’m now firmly in the camp of ramping up the production values of Zelda games now as well.
GigaBowser
The bear of bad news
They grades it harder
onnextflix5
Member
Don’t agree with everything they say, horizon a mediocre game, that I can agree with, can’t believe they had two tries and still can’t figure out how to make a great game,
Last edited:
Kilau
Member
These aren’t just bad for Zelda games but just straight trash games imo, so that taints their scores some for me.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Must've forgot to this month. These are uncharacteristically high scores across the board from them.
Oh, and still no Hogwarts review,
ShadyAcshuns
Member
All looks quite correct.
Goalus
Member
Seems reasonable. Redfall admittedly has a few faults and imperfections.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
A few?
Going by Edge being so hard on games compared to the rest of the review industry, this should have been a 3 or a 4 by their own reputational standards.
VectorVictor
Member
Skyward Sword as a 10 completely erodes any validity their scores have. That game is perhaps the most craptacular Zelda game this side of a Phillips CD-i machine. Maybe a 7 at best.
Kilau
Member
Wait, have they made a statement on that or just ignoring it? Maybe they'll review the Switch version. Their scores good or bad mean nothing since they clearly have a bias.Must've forgot to this month. These are uncharacteristically high scores across the board from them.
Oh, and still no Hogwarts review,
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
No idea if they made a statement. I would thin someone on Gaf would have posted it.
I think they straight up ignored it completely. One of the largest game launches this year, and arguably all time.
Gamerguy84
Member
Edge is one of those sites I never gave time too. I didn't know they were literally Stevivor though. Never knew about the Days Gone review and giving redfall a pass.
Kilau
Member
To the bias bin with them.
They gave to Days Gone a 50 and Horizon a 70. Is horizon only a bit better be it 10 points or 1 point better than Redfall?
Last edited:
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
Its exactly the same reviewers as every other magazine. A fact that they deliberately hid for years by omitting the byline from reviews!
Edge is a marketing gimmick, nothing more.
GigaBowser
The bear of bad news
Never played Redfall but it looks kind of fun at leasts
Redfall graphics are ways below TOTK to me's and the artsyle made me puke but funfactor is the mostest importance
Imru’ al-Qays
Member
Do you have a source for this?
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
They had the only bug free, non jank, competent AI and game design copy.
Arsic
Loves his juicy stink trail scent
I played a fair amount of RedFall . Think I had 3 missions left before I dropped it ?
The AI is unredeemable like death loop. I ran into only 2 bugs.
The main issues with the game really are at a fundamental design level. So even if the game they got ran smooth and the AI posed some challenge, the rest is just very poor. The basis for the game should’ve been vampire hideouts because of the cool level design and challenge they provided. If that was the core and then the game was made around that to expand upon it, they could’ve had a great game.
A free to play or $20 vampire extraction shooter with co op, seasonal story, raids ? That could’ve been a beat game.
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
I thought this was pretty well known? Its a Future Media mag, and they all work the same way using the same pool of mostly UK-based freelancers.
I mean, haven't you ever wondered why they never name reviewers, only columnists? Or how noone ever moves on from Edge to write for themselves or somebody else and trades on the "prestige" of having written for such an illustrious publication?
Its like how under Tony Mott's editorial reign they desperately tried to establish bullshit terminology like "codeshop" that literally noone in the industry uses... Its just a gimmick used to create an impression of them being more inside/important than what they are.
Last edited:
Imru’ al-Qays
Member
Oh so you don't have any proof of this.
GigaBowser
The bear of bad news
Noooooo Horizon is purdy goodHorizon was pretty fucking bad but redfall levels?
Nocturno999
Member
Sounds like another Guerrilla game.
consoul
Member
The demo wasn't at 9 level, but the trailers do seem to have a lot of crazy shit going on. I hope the full game is a 9, but I'm gonna wait and see.
GigaBowser
The bear of bad news
Lotsa lower budgets games are masterpieces my friends
Kerotan
Member
It's free with PS extra this month.
RAIDEN1
Member
I personally think MGS-4 was fully deserving of an 8/10 ....it was the game that got me into the world of Playstation and I don't regret playing it and completing it, Metal Gear 5 on the other hand for me was not the standout of the series as some have portrayed it to be.....and outside of Peacewalker, MGS4 is the last good Metal Gear game..
Last edited: