Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. I dislike it, but don't know if I'd call it bad. Probably mediocre.
The editing is really off, like jumping from event to event with no sense of cohesion off. The actors are hamming it up and nearly everyone is shouting. Why are they all shouting? I dunno, but I think it's something Mike Newell insisted on. Seems like the kind of fellow who's very boisterous and feels that those wise powerful characters should be the same (though I could be wrong). Maybe it's just for Drama. Anyway, you don't have to be a fan of the books to know that the characters are inconsistent when looking at the of the previous films. Dumbledore got recast but his character remained consistent from the first two. Here, he's unrecognisable. Also Emma Watson just stopped trying from this film onward. She was on autopilot.
Regarding the pacing, I have to say that the third act is rushed as hell. We just dive in head first from a completely unrelated scene and then it just keeps going without slowing down. Ralph Fiennes is literally speed reading his lines at some point in the graveyard scene and it just makes me think Newell was pulling a Lucas and going "Faster, more intense, lads".
Visuals were alright. Hungarian Horntail CGI holds up quite well. Prisoner of Azkaban was the nicer looking film. The score was good too but nowhere near Williams' level obviously. Wish Patrick Doyle would've stayed on for Order of the Phoenix and Half-Blood Prince.
Seriously, the hammy acting really was something else in this film.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix marks the beginning of Yates' reign and, boy, it's pretty pedestrian (his direction, that is). I feel like the only thing that he brings to these films are the incredibly dull visuals, accompanied by his trademark blue tinted colour grading. I get that the story gets rather bleak but not like this, for crying out loud.
Anyway, this is the shortest film of the series (for the longest book!) and it feels like it. Maybe it's just because I've read the book a few times, but the films leaves me wanting to see more. More characters, more interaction, more magic etc. I feel that the executive meddling (which cut down the runtime, if I'm correct) messed things up a little bit. The editing was OK, but again I feel like it tried to shove in too many key plot points whilst trying to fit into the shorter runtime. I suppose Yates didn't want all that footage to go to waste and decided to fit some in no matter how short or relevant.
The film's OK. I can rewatch it. It's not forgettable but it's not remarkable either. At least it had its characters done well, which I can't say for the previous film.