• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Rush is one of the worst, and one of the greatest rock bands in history

Status
Not open for further replies.
rush.jpg

AllMusic said:
Over the course of their decades-spanning career, Canadian power trio Rush emerged as one of hard rock's most highly regarded bands; although typically brushed aside by critics and rarely the recipients of mainstream pop radio airplay, Rush nonetheless won an impressive and devoted fan following while their virtuoso performance skills solidified their standing as musicians' musicians.

Rush formed in Toronto, Ontario in the autumn of 1968, initially comprised of guitarist Alex Lifeson (born Alexander Zivojinovich), vocalist/bassist Geddy Lee (born Gary Lee Weinrib), and drummer John Rutsey. In their primary incarnation, Rush drew a heavy influence from Cream, and honed their skills on the Toronto club circuit before issuing their debut single, a rendition of Buddy Holly's "Not Fade Away," in 1973. A self-titled LP followed in 1974, at which time Rutsey exited; he was replaced by drummer Neil Peart, who also assumed the role of the band's primary songwriter, composing the cerebral lyrics (influenced by works of science fiction and fantasy) that gradually became a hallmark of the group's aesthetic.

With Peart firmly ensconced, the band returned in 1975 with a pair of LPs, Fly by Night and Caress of Steel. Their next effort, 1976's 2112, proved their breakthrough release: a futuristic concept album based on the writings of Ayn Rand, it fused the elements of the trio's sound -- Lee's high-pitched vocals, Peart's epic drumming, and Lifeson's complex guitar work -- into a unified whole. Fans loved it -- 2112 was the first in a long line of gold and platinum releases -- while critics dismissed it as overblown and pretentious; either way, it established a formula from which the band rarely deviated throughout the duration of its career.

A Farewell to Kings followed in 1977 and reached the Top 40 in both the U.S. and Britain. After 1978's Hemispheres, Rush achieved even greater popularity with 1980's Permanent Waves, a record marked by the group's dramatic shift into shorter, less sprawling compositions; the single "The Spirit of Radio" even became a major hit. With 1981's Moving Pictures, they scored another hit of sorts with "Tom Sawyer," which garnered heavy exposure on album-oriented radio and became perhaps the trio's best-known song. As the 1980s continued, Rush grew into a phenomenally popular live draw as albums like 1982's Signals (which generated the smash "New World Man"), 1984's Grace Under Pressure, and 1985's Power Windows continued to sell millions of copies.

As the decade drew to a close, the trio cut back on its touring schedule while hardcore followers complained of a sameness afflicting slicker, synth-driven efforts like 1987's Hold Your Fire and 1989's Presto. At the dawn of the '90s, however, Rush returned to the heavier sound of their early records and placed a renewed emphasis on Lifeson's guitar heroics; consequently, both 1991's Roll the Bones and 1993's Counterparts reached the Top Three on the U.S. album charts. In 1996, the band issued Test for Echo and headed out on the road the following summer. Shortly thereafter, Peart lost his daughter in an automobile accident. Tragedy struck again in 1998 when Peart's wife succumbed to cancer.

Dire times in the Rush camp did not cause the band to quit. Lee took time out for a solo stint with 2000's My Favorite Headache; however, rumors of the band playing in the studio began to circulate. It would be five years until anything surfaced from the band. Fans were reassured in early 2002 by news that Rush were recording new songs in Toronto. The fruit of those sessions led to the release of Rush's 17th studio album, Vapor Trails, later that spring. By the end of the year a concert from the supporting tour was released on DVD as Rush in Rio.

In 2004 Rush embarked on their 30th anniversary tour, documented on the DVD R30, and in 2006 they returned to the studio to begin work on a new album. The resulting Snakes & Arrows was released in May 2007, followed by the CD/DVD set Snakes & Arrows Live in early 2008. Material from the latter was combined with footage from Rush in Rio and R30 for the CD/DVD compilation Working Men, which was released in 2009. A documentary on the band assembled by Toronto's Bangor Productions called Behind the Lighted Stage appeared in 2010, followed a year later by another Bangor video production, Time Machine 2011: Live in Cleveland. Rush's 19th full-length studio album, Clockwork Angels, is set to arrive in early 2012.

They have survived for four decades now, and have one of the most loyal followings of any band. They do not have much mainstream airplay, yet so many people know who they are. They are also one of the top selling music acts of all time.


Wikipedia said:
As a group, Rush possesses 24 gold records and 14 platinum (3 multi-platinum) records.[4] Rush's sales statistics place them third behind The Beatles and The Rolling Stones for the most consecutive gold or platinum studio albums by a rock band.[5] Rush also ranks 79th in U.S. album sales with 25 million units.[6] Although total worldwide album sales are not calculated by any single entity, as of 2004 several industry sources estimated Rush's total worldwide album sales at over 40 million units.


I am late to the party with them. I had heard much of their stuff through my life, but only started to listen to them with intensity in the last year and a half. I still hold that Geddy Lee has a horrible voice (well, when he is toning it down. I do love his wailing voice of early records), and that Neil Peart is one of the worst lyricists in rock history.

But the one thing that I don't think anyone can criticize the band for is their technical ability.

http://youtu.be/Sa0C5Uxpd3c

While some of their compositions are cheesy and completely overblown, I can't help but be in awe of their amazing playing and showmanship. I also deeply respect that they have done their own damn thing for their entire career and continue to do so. Geddy Lee is one of the most amazing bassists to listen to, and it is even more impressive to think that he is singing, playing bass, and synth all at the same time on many songs. And Neil Peart is probably the greatest living rock drummer (sorry, Keith Moon still wins for greatest of all time in my book).

The thing with Rush is that the more I listen to their stuff, the more I fall in love with it. Flaws and all. I recognize that they are a cheesy, over the top band, but I cannot help but get pulled in by their amazing playing skills. I hate that I love them now, and the love is getting stronger.

I know they are a divisive band, with it being either love or hate, but I am now strongly in the love camp.
 
I heard they're not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, which means they're probably hacks.

I dont have the time nor the patience to hunt down the list of amazing bands NOT in the hall of fame.

I know you are joking. Wonder how many will take the troll bait. I like it :)
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
They're one of the best, and not one of the worst.

There's nothing even wrong with Geddy's voice other than it's unusual sounding. It's a rock band, not X Factor.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Saw them in Toledo this past April. Best concert I have ever, ever been to, holy shit. Geddy's bass skills are amazing.

I can't say I'm really a big fan of any albums post-Hold Your Fire with the exception of the song "Roll the Bones"
 
They're one of the best, and not one of the worst.

There's nothing even wrong with Geddy's voice other than it's unusual sounding. It's a rock band, not X Factor.

Much of the time it is like nails on the chalkboard. I can take it because everything else with the band kicks serious ass, but his voice alone makes my wife want to scream when I listen to their music.
 

totowhoa

Banned
My favorite classic rock band. Fucking love their shit. You can rail on the lyrics for being corny sometimes, but the music is incredible, I love the vocals (but I understand how this could ruin it for others), and their sound is just fantastic. They're one of the only classic rock bands that have continued to maintain quality to this day with new releases IMO.
 
It's a joke post responding to the Hall of Fame thread; The Beastie Boys, Red Hot Chili Peppers, and Guns n' Roses are inducted this year. lol.

http://neogaf.net/forum/showthread.php?t=454786

I know. Hence the spoiler.

My favorite classic rock band. Fucking love their shit. You can rail on the lyrics for being corny sometimes, but the music is incredible, I love the vocals (but I understand how this could ruin it for others), and their sound is just fantastic. They're one of the only classic rock bands that have continued to maintain quality to this day with new releases IMO.

Truth. They still sound amazing today, unlike The Who and The Rolling Stones.
 

Today, not overall. Mick Jagger sounds like utter shit compared to his prime days. Watching a recent Rolling Stones performance is embarrassing. Not as embarrassing as a current Who performance (or half of The Who really), but still horrible compared to how they used to sound.

But in their prime, The Who and The Rolling Stones stomp over almost every rock music act ever.
 

Sharp

Member
They're one of the best, and not one of the worst.

There's nothing even wrong with Geddy's voice other than it's unusual sounding. It's a rock band, not X Factor.
Well, it's harsh and unpleasant and often out of key. But Rush without vocals is godlike.
 

-Eddman-

Member
I like to think of them as the Metallica of hard/progressive rock. Their fans love them with passion and their haters can't miss any opportunity to talk shit about anything they do.

I don't consider myself a big fan but I absolutely love 2112, Farewell to Kings and Moving Pictures. Haven't heard much of the rest but I thought Vapor Trails was meh.
 

Zizbuka

Banned
One of my 3 favorite bands ever. I don't know anything about their more recent stuff, but everything predating the Chronicles set is amazing.

Manhattan Project
The Trees
Subdivisions

Too many great songs to list.
 

GhaleonEB

Member
I at once find them hugely talented and really annoying to listen to, primarily because of the singer's voice. Their live videos are really impressive technically, but I just can't enjoy their music for that reason.
 
These guys are one of my all-time favorite groups. I got into them in my late teens (Test for Echo-era) and proceeded to buy up every album before and have bought every album since.

Have managed to get out to see them on tour several times, most recently when they played the United Center earlier this year. Moving Pictures live from front to back was amazing, and the 2 tracks they've released so far for the upcoming album sound pretty good. I listen to Counterparts so much that my wife knows most of the lyrics, yet she hates the band lol.
 
These guys are one of my all-time favorite groups. I got into them in my late teens (Test for Echo-era) and proceeded to buy up every album before and have bought every album since.

Have managed to get out to see them on tour several times, most recently when they played the United Center earlier this year. Moving Pictures live from front to back was amazing, and the 2 tracks they've released so far for the upcoming album sound pretty good. I listen to Counterparts so much that my wife knows most of the lyrics, yet she hates the band lol.

Early 30s here and just starting to really get into them. I will convert my wife! Been listening to 2112 for the past few days.
 

totowhoa

Banned
Listening to recent Rush now. I love that I can put in pretty much any album across so many decades of evolution and always know that I'm going to have a number of fantastic tracks to hear. So many bands lose their audience after the third or fourth album.


I will convert my wife! Been listening to 2112 for the past few days.

haha, my wife will never convert. She finds their music too intense for her (insane vocals and insane lyrics are the primary issue here).

To be honest, I actually love the lyrics generally. There are some songs that are a little corny for me, but there's just something about the lyrical style and quirky vocals. It just works for me.
 

DiscoJer

Member
Wait, what, not much mainstream airplay?

They're pretty much a staple on classic rock stations where I live.

KSHE 95 is Real Rock Radio
Now celebrating 44 years of rocking St. Louis, KSHE is the oldest FM rock station in the country. Core artists include Led Zeppelin, Aerosmith, AC DC, Van Halen, Pink Floyd, Ozzy Osbourne and Rush

They play them 8 times a day.

And they get hated on because they are progressive rock, which is currently cool to hate (unless it's progressive metal, for some reason, which does actually suck) because somehow punk and its descendants are oh so much more relative and organic and crap like that (even though its ultimate form was Green Day)
 

esquire

Has waited diligently to think of something to say before making this post
I remember some guy (whom shall hereinafter be reffered to as Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass) once telling me that Rush was the best thing in music since JS Bach. I could never take that band seriously since Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass told me that. Incidentally Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass is what I imagine all Rush fans are like and by association, probably look like. Covered in Cheeto dust, sweaty and fat.
 

-Eddman-

Member
And they get hated on because they are progressive rock, which is currently cool to hate (unless it's progressive metal, for some reason, which does actually suck) because somehow punk and its descendants are oh so much more relative and organic and crap like that (even though its ultimate form was Green Day)

Americans in particular acquired some kind of irrational hate towards anything Progressive or Heavy Metal after the 80's. Of course not everyone but the pop culture often makes references to how ridicule/tacky is to do anything prog/classic heavy related these days. And yes, somehow the punk influenced bands are always seen as "cool rebels".
 

Medalion

Banned
I remember some guy (whom shall hereinafter be reffered to as Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass) once telling me that Rush was the best thing in music since JS Bach. I could never take that band seriously since Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass told me that. Incidentally Cheeto-stain, sweaty, fat ass is what I imagine all Rush fans are like and by association, probably look like. Covered in Cheeto dust, sweaty and fat.
Speaking of Rush and Cheetos...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eubi9YI2dKE
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom