• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Eurogamer: NX = portable w/ carts, detachable controllers, Tegra, TV Out, no BC, Sept

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zoon

Member
Will this thing have battery issues if it has at least 2 batteries? Each controller needs one and they need another one if the screen will work alone.
 
I think the dock will be dumb, that just allows for the console to draw more power and the clocks are unlocked to allow more resolution. If the dock has another chip, the tech required to make the console and the dock work together and theprice of the dock itself would be astronomical.

Honestly that makes a ton of sense, throw more power in the handheld and just force it to limit itself when it isn't attached to the dock. If they go with that approach, I really feel like they'd market this thing as a console first, handheld second. Especially with the "inferior" specs of the handheld mode and the continued success of the 3DS.

The thread is approaching 150 pages. People have been talking about it. A lot.

Yikes, do you use that line at parties too?
 
You are looking at this from the wrong direction... Basically the logical way to create a device like this is to have active cooling in the device, but only use it when clocked high. Using a qHD screen like the Vita and a 5inch to 6inch screen should give a fair resolution to your games, while allowing the device to only worry about 500k pixels per frame, so you only need 1/4th the clock.

Lets say the X2 is a 384cuda core chip with a max standard clock of 1.6ghz (reasonable for Pascal) obviously this isn't something you could do in a handheld with any sort of battery life and without the fan being active, so you clock it at 1/4th that clock or 400mhz, this gives you 307gflops, which for 540p gaming with pascal, should net you between XB1 and PS4 performance. You then dock the device and allow the GPU to upclock to it's max standard clock of 1.6ghz, giving you 1.228TFLOPs, almost exactly what XB1 has, but pascal? you see a ~30% performance increase over GCN, so this would feel like an AMD GPU with 1.6tflops, hitting just below PS4.

This would be a device built with hybrid in mind, with X1 it becomes more tricky, you end up with a 128gflops handheld and a 512gflops console (when docked), still very powerful when compared to Vita, and maybe 2 to 3 times as powerful when compared to Wii U (assuming you are doing 1080p vs Wii U's more often than not 720p) it is lack luster and can only really do XB1 1080p ports at 720p. I feel X2 is the only choice for them, and the performance depends heavily on how many cuda cores X2 has, 384 is the magic number here, which is 50% more than X1, it's possible that Nintendo creates the perfect hybrid, but we will have to wait and see.
I really hope they go with down-clocking the more powerful chip.
 

Thraktor

Member
I keep going back to the thought... it just makes too much sense to me. Iwata said it's not a hybrid, and I can't imagine he'd lie about it.... and nearly all of the big patents we've seen lately are playing a role in this latest rumor, except for the SCDs...

I'm still convinced, this isn't a hybrid, this is our portable. The TV docking seems like something that could have been added late in development (maybe not post Iwata, but maybe so)... and we still have the fact that NX is supposed to be a platform of devices, not a single device... Meaning what we're seeing here is "device 1".

Thinking like that (series of devices, this rumor focusing on a mobile version, and the fact that we're seeing developers starting to come out as excited for it), I think we're seeing the base of the NX, with the true 'console' SCD coming out around Christmas.

The dock is meant to be a stop-gap for the flagging Wii U sales for those that want a console experience (and one that should still outdo the Wii U even if it can't meet Xbone levels) until the SCD is ready down the line... With the base system containing a lot of the hardware (controller, storage, cartridge reader), the SCD can be a staggered 'upgrade' for a sub-console cost, with a bundle with both also being available in time for November Christmas shopping.

*spitballing*

All that said, I still don't imagine the SCD will/would compete with the Neo or Scorpio, it's just not Nintendo's style.


(edit) Keep in mind... a full on console with a full on handheld at launch would inflate the price pretty greatly, something Nintendo has experience with that ended poorly... I expect whatever the first NX device to be, it's going to be "affordable" compared to the other consoles (see the original Wii) with the SCD being about the same price as the base unit to extend it... For that reason, I don't think the dock will contain any additional hardware or be any more than what the rumor already says it is, just a way to get TV out.

I suspect you may well be right, at least about this being just the handheld (with light "hybrid" functionality). There's nothing in the Eurogamer article which states, or even implies, that this is Nintendo's only upcoming piece of hardware, and it very much seems that it's a handheld first and foremost, and that the dock is simply a piece of plastic for charging and outputting HDMI and not much more. Given that, and given that Nintendo have commented repeatedly about future handhelds and future consoles being part of a "family of systems", I think there's a very strong possibility that there's a dedicated home console in the works too, but that its release is a little further out.

Even the hybrid functionality here may just be to give people the cheapest possible entry point into the "NX ecosystem", with MCV claiming that "it's going to be cheaper than even the vast majority expect", and with the "proper" console serving people who are looking for a more traditional home console with higher resolution support.

I'm not so sure about the SCD angle (I still think that such an approach would be confusing for consumers), but I could definitely see a stand-alone console popping up within a year or so of the portable.
 

Taker666

Member
I'm betting on $399 for the base model. I wish they'd sell for $250, but I'm convinced they'll try to market at premium hardware price no matter what.

I'd say $249 is the max they'd consider seeing as the handheld market is the obvious target for this device.

Frankly, they are in trouble if they go above $200.
 

LordofPwn

Member
That's what I want to know too.

You're supposed to be able to play BotW on that thing.

cause i've heard people say local multi player and i honestly believe people were misinterpreting information. but then i watched that digital foundry video and they seemed confident on the local multiplayer. i just don't understand how a controller with a stick and d-pad can be used against a controller with a stick and face buttons. outside of specifically tailored experiences it seems more likely that it would be 2 halves but i guess you never really know with Nintendo
 

Xion_Stellar

People should stop referencing data that makes me feel uncomfortable because games get ported to platforms I don't like

oti

Banned
Third party support is barely going to matter given that they've only got one system to support. All of Nintendo's development focused on one system plus the slightly better third party support they've got on their handhelds.
It's not going to be lacking software, other than from Western devs.

The point of 3rd party support is not just preventing droughts, it's also a steady revenue stream of licencing fees. My guess would be that Nintendo is ready to almost ditch that completely in favour of a single platform including some big exclusives. Like Bayonetta 2, like Beyond Good & Evil 2. Instead of getting into bidding wars with Sony and MS for exclusive content (which Iwata made clear they are just not interested in) they will focus on a few games here and there and put all their marketing power behind them. Then they will also provide incentives to traditional indie developers and mobile developers.

That's at least how I make sense of this. Traditional ports are pretty much a thing of the past for them.
 

keakster

Member
Not sure if this has been discussed, but where do people think the price point for games will come in?

Hand held games have come in around $40 forever, while console games have been floating between $60-$70. Are we going to see $50 games across the board? Or is Zelda and Mario going to be $60 and more typical hand held games still running $40?
 
it seems like Nintendo is positioning the NX to be where mobile gamers will "graduate" to, so to speak, so having all their mobile stuff work on NX seems like a no brainer as to make that transition easier.

"oh you like pokemon go and animal crossing mobile thingy? well here's their full fledged counterparts on NX! and hey, all your mobile stuff transfers over too!"

I would think that My Nintendo integration would suffice for that, at least from Nintendo's perspective. But I dunno.
 

KAL2006

Banned
New idea

The NX comes in 3 parts

The 6" 540p capacitive touch screen tablet. For light games, apps and Internet browsing.

A controller attachment for heavy games with full controls. The controller attachment is only one piece and not rumoured 2 piece. It's simply is the bottom half of a DS withiut the screen. It can be used to also used as a tablet cover similar to the surface keyboards. It also has an extra battery to play those heavy games on the tablet. It attaches at the bottom and has a similar style to the DS ergonomics.

Then final piece is the dock. The dock will not have its own processor. It will perhaps have a cooling method so the tablet can overclocks. When docked all games can be played at a higher resolution and better graphics. The controller attachment mentioned earlier will also be used as a simple Bluetooth controller in docked mode. Docked mode would be equivalent to Wii U at 1.5x the power.

Prices would be cheap to obtain mass market appeal
$200 - Tablet and Controller
$250 - Tablet and Controller and Dock

Dock sold separately at $70 so you save $20 getting the bundle. Also people who don't like using the controller attachment for docked mode have a option to buy a Pro Controller for $60
 

jroc74

Phone reception is more important to me than human rights
Not sure if this has been discussed, but where do people think the price point for games will come in?

Hand held games have come in around $40 forever, while console games have been floating between $60-$70. Are we going to see $50 games across the board? Or is Zelda and Mario going to be $60 and more typical hand held games still running $40?

This being Nintendo....I expect $60.

In a perfect world they would be priced closer to Vita, 3DS games.
 

Portugeezer

Member
Not sure if this has been discussed, but where do people think the price point for games will come in?

Hand held games have come in around $40 forever, while console games have been floating between $60-$70. Are we going to see $50 games across the board? Or is Zelda and Mario going to be $60 and more typical hand held games still running $40?

Probably will vary between $40 and $60... I mean, it wouldn't make sense for Zelda to launch at $40 on NX and $60 on Wii U, they'll both be $60. Something closer to a traditional handheld game will probably be $40.
 

Koren

Member
The 6" 540p capacitive touch screen tablet. For light games, apps and Internet browsing.

A controller attachment for heavy games with full controls. The controller attachment is only one piece and not rumoured 2 piece. It's simply is the bottom half of a DS withiut the screen.
Or, how to have a truly awful weight balance...
 
D

Deleted member 752119

Unconfirmed Member
Not sure if this has been discussed, but where do people think the price point for games will come in?

Hand held games have come in around $40 forever, while console games have been floating between $60-$70. Are we going to see $50 games across the board? Or is Zelda and Mario going to be $60 and more typical hand held games still running $40?

I think the bolded is more likely and has precedent with things like Captain Toad on Wii U, Ratchet and Clank on PS4 launching st $40.
 

Koren

Member
Assuming it's true (still not convinced after Iwata saying "not an hybrid"), I'd say that the battery are inside the controllers, not the screen part.

The controllers need the batteries if they have to work wirelessly.

Since the screen has no battery, the dock is simply required for the thing to be powered!
 

keakster

Member
Probably will vary between $40 and $60... I mean, it wouldn't make sense for Zelda to launch at $40 on NX and $60 on Wii U, they'll both be $60. Something closer to a traditional handheld game will probably be $40.

I think the bolded is more likely and has precedent with things like Captain Toad on Wii U, Ratchet and Clank on PS4 launching st $40.

I forgot about the Captain Toad release. With an assumed increased in releases, I hope that they keep that model and differentiate a Zelda/Mario experience with the higher price point, rather than making it across the board. Although they probably will charge a premium on the Pokemon games, pushing them up to $50 or $60
 
Even if it's not cheap, as long as it has good battery life, is appealing to indy developers, and has a store with all the classic games from each previous generation, i'm in!

But if i have to swap a cartridge in or out at any point, or it's missing something essential like not having enough buttons to play certain games, i'm out!

I've skipped all the gimmick generations Nintendo, now give me your ubiquitous apex, primarily mobile gaming device!
 
Under that scenario, all the processing power would be in the dock. The dock woukd just be a small console.

If they were packaged seperately its more likely that one would be the portable version only- no dock.

For your first comment, what makes you think that? I'm of the mind that it would be entirely possible for them to have a dock that gives the "handheld" of sorts a power boost. I don't think the dock having some supplemental power means the handheld has to be dumb. I'm not going to pretend that I know enough to say definitively either way.

I feel the opposite way about your second statement. I think this will be revealed and marketed as a "console" that you can also take with you on the go with sacrifices. Though many people are looking at this as a handheld for your TV, it's obvious that Nintendo doesn't plan on ditching the 3DS any time soon.
 
So, just to be clear, in addition to Eurogamer, the following outlets have backed up this report to varying degrees:

IGN
Kotaku
WSJ
MCV

No one should be doubting this report at this point.
 
So, just to be clear, in addition to Eurogamer, the following outlets have backed up this report to varying degrees:

IGN
Kotaku
WSJ
MCV

No one should be doubting this report at this point.

I appreciate you pointing this out! I wanted to make a similar post but didn't have time to comb each article and see who backed the report yet. I wonder how long it will be before other outlets report from their own sources. Maybe we'll get some new information sooner than we think.
 

Papacheeks

Banned
Third party support is barely going to matter given that they've only got one system to support. All of Nintendo's development focused on one system plus the slightly better third party support they've got on their handhelds.
It's not going to be lacking software, other than from Western devs.

And that is a problem for other regions outside Japan. They need western development support even if third party games themselves dont come over. They need games developed for specific regions so they will have a wide software library that doesn't cater two one region.
 

Calm Mind

Member

tumblr_nk99fhuymq1qhnoouo1_400.gif
 

keakster

Member
From the MCV article ...

You’d think the biggest trick here will be to ensure the mixed and confused messaging that surrounded the Wii U from day one is avoided.

EG also talked about this as something Nintendo is focusing on, leading me to disagree with the multiple SKU speculation. They are aiming for a low price point, but if they are really going for mass market, a multiple SKU release could be confusing. I could see a regular SKU and a "pro" SKU, similar to the 360 elite/arcade options.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom