-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
[Digital Foundry] COD Black Ops Cold War: PS5 vs Xbox Series X - Ray Tracing, 120Hz Mode Tests + Series S Analysis!
- Thread starter JareBear: Remastered
- Start date
waquzy
Member
Nah, GTA IV wasMafia 2 was the GOAT
MastaKiiLA
Member
Yeah. I kept my comments neutral, as I'm not a fan of the franchise, and don't care to rankle any nerves. I'm more eager to see what Sony's studios deliver this gen, personally. They're sure to leverage any advantages the PS5 has in their games. I can't wait.
I don't mind giving the nod to the XSX when I think it's due. While I like that the PS5 is flexing at 120Hz, I just have no use for that mode, and I'm not sure how practical it will end up being. But still a nice feather in the cap. VGT didn't show the same cutscenes that DF did, where the PS5 fell behind in RT mode, so I'm curious to know if that's something that is persistent for cutscenes, or just the 2 scenarios that DF was able to spot. Both machines handle the game well, so everyone should conceivably be happy.
iJudged
Banned
That's it? Sweet.... Thnx
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
VGT did and mentioned that those scenes drop frame rates randomly. Sometimes, PS5 drops the frames. Sometimes, it's a locked 60. So there's obviously some bug.
Mr. PlayStation here said that he was able to resolve this issue by turning off the gameplay 4K recording feature. Once he turned it off, it was a locked 60. Confirmation from other members who have the game would be great.
Those PS5 frame drops are definitely random bugs
Yes the lead platform they spent months hand tweaking for maximum performance has "random" bugs. It is more likely the neglected versions PC and series x have performance bugs. The easiest console ever my grandma could do it with months of extra special attention is totally the buggy version lol. Any fix is more special hand tuning only Sony gets.
MastaKiiLA
Member
I think there are a few bugs in the video. That light is there in the XSX version, and then disappears when the bulb itself comes into frame. You can see the reflection of the light, as well as the glare, come into frame from offscreen, but as soon as the bulb enters the frame, the light goes out. I think it's a bug. More than enough of those in both launch lineups.
Hmmm ...
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
edit holy shit im dumb...took forever to figure out upload picture
brb gotta call and say sorry to my parents.
Last edited:
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Lol you do realize that the game didn't have any drops in these scenes at all until a later patch messed up the code, right?
It shipped just fine. The issue came after the patch.
Null Persp
Member
That shadow is in 1 frame then is gone lol, those screenshots are the worst cherry picking I've seen in the last days.
Those set-pieces will never be 100% identical, they have different shadow, different explosions etc.
Only things that is strange and is missing is the muzzle but it's a very minor thing.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Double checked frame by frame. You're correct. That bulb also flickers on and off in the PS5 version. Weird bugs!
LivingD3AD
Member
Look at the explosion in the left side, wow PS5 version miles better lmao
edit holy shit im dumb...took forever to figure out upload picture
brb gotta call and say sorry to my parents.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Look at the explosion in the left side, wow PS5 version miles better lmao
Yeah you can actually feel the heat when you look at the PS5 explosion
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
no im saying its a different explosion so these missing xbox xplosion posts are not valid.Look at the explosion in the left side, wow PS5 version miles better lmao
Evilms
Banned
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
and here is xbox gun fire which is oddly missing in df video.
its just a wonky game it seems
its just a wonky game it seems
Mr Moose
Member
It's Call of Duty, they always have bugs. Their fixes bring new bugs. It's the CoD way.
edit holy shit im dumb...took forever to figure out upload picture
brb gotta call and say sorry to my parents.
People aren't serious with this stuff, are they?
(Like, you are joking, right?)
Last edited:
Mr. PlayStation
Member
I can't say for sure that solves it, but that is what i did. I think i did this before the software stability update came out. Let me boot up cold war again on PS5 and try these very same levels DF has pointed out for frame rate dips. That one mission with the dust flying off in the night(set piece moment), that one you can actually visibly notice and feel the frame rate dip to 40s. Will try out this too, wish I had software tools to analyze frame rates
oldergamer
Member
Man this thread is nuts to watch. So many incorrect things mentioned.
- Performance on PS5 was likely after the firmware update. comparing it to the results of COD tests from BEFORE that firmware may not be valid anymore.
- the XBOX S model has Ray tracing available, DF admitted to missing it (or a bug)
- Performance issues are NOT only in cutscenes. The DF video showed performance drops during gameplay
- Anecdotal accounts of frame drops rarely happening, just proved that most of these small frame rate changes are NOT noticeable unless there is a big drop
- VRR does account for something and should not be ignored if one platform can't use it at the moment
- Some elements like grass or smoke or explosions, or fire have random elements in them. They likely can't be directly compared as one may be rendering more than the other
- Taking single frame screenshots to prove one console has a higher frame rate, or "wins" doesn't prove anything.
- People are over reacting to games early this gen
- DF is not biased towards Xbox or Playstation
- NX gamer is not biased towards Xbox or Playstation
- The only people truely biased are those that are all up in arms in this forum or twitter accusing others of bias
- All that has been proven is, they all have bugs, they all may not have optimal performance, they all don't push the hardware enough (especially if they are hitting 120fps), and the small differences mean literally nothing
- Performance on PS5 was likely after the firmware update. comparing it to the results of COD tests from BEFORE that firmware may not be valid anymore.
- the XBOX S model has Ray tracing available, DF admitted to missing it (or a bug)
- Performance issues are NOT only in cutscenes. The DF video showed performance drops during gameplay
- Anecdotal accounts of frame drops rarely happening, just proved that most of these small frame rate changes are NOT noticeable unless there is a big drop
- VRR does account for something and should not be ignored if one platform can't use it at the moment
- Some elements like grass or smoke or explosions, or fire have random elements in them. They likely can't be directly compared as one may be rendering more than the other
- Taking single frame screenshots to prove one console has a higher frame rate, or "wins" doesn't prove anything.
- People are over reacting to games early this gen
- DF is not biased towards Xbox or Playstation
- NX gamer is not biased towards Xbox or Playstation
- The only people truely biased are those that are all up in arms in this forum or twitter accusing others of bias
- All that has been proven is, they all have bugs, they all may not have optimal performance, they all don't push the hardware enough (especially if they are hitting 120fps), and the small differences mean literally nothing
Last edited:
ChuckeRearmed
Member
Gunfire is bigger on XSX. XSX won!and here is xbox gun fire which is oddly missing in df video.
its just a wonky game it seems
Last edited:
Its crazy how Sony fans have literally combed footage for missing light bulbs and muzzle flashes judt to discredit the Xbox version being superior. Would be funny if it wasn't so sad. Even went as far as to call DF shills.and here is xbox gun fire which is oddly missing in df video.
its just a wonky game it seems
Leave the analysis to the professionals aye guys?
ChuckeRearmed
Member
But it seems DF should work harder - too much oversight these days. I really want them to dig deeper in texture difference, shadows etc.
funking giblet
Member
You do realised that things like, flames, explosions, particles are all random right? RIGHT?
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
I dont think the xbox version is superior. I just dont people spreading false information and circle jerking around it like its a fact. Your all as bad as anti vax, healing crystal flat earthers.
Mr Moose
Member
Damn, I was thinking about buying this game today, might hold off or skip it completely.
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
I dont understand. It was to show a person who posted missing stuff on the left side on xbox that the explosion is different and there is missing stuff on the right side on ps5. That the pictures cant be used to push an agenda of missing effects on xbox.It's Call of Duty, they always have bugs. Their fixes bring new bugs. It's the CoD way.
People aren't serious with this stuff, are they?
Mr Moose
Member
Yeah it's silly, fire, I would hope, is "dynamic", it'll be slightly different.
What everyone, including DF, should be talking about is #BirdGate, that's the real issue.
I remember #GrassGate on GTAV lol.
reinking
Gold Member
Let's not make it an "us vs them" thing. Plenty of dumb to go around in this thread from both sides for a game that is a wash on both consoles. It is incredible how far some are willing to go to protect their corporate overlords.
Riky
$MSFT
If you've played the game or actually watched the video you'll know they aren't cut scenes. Cut scenes you have no control, the stages with the plane and remote control car and the stage you're running through the building are playable.
Aceofspades
Banned
People clinging for the tiniest of differences , PS5/XSX are running the game nearly identical.
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
Ive said it before. There are a lot more stupid made up posts in this thread from sony fans. Just look at the amount of screenshots. The ones that show PS in a favorable light outnumber the favorable xbox ones by quite a bit. The xbox side is just as dumb but at least there are half as many dumb posts because half as many fans.
MDSLKTR
Member
Thats all that matters in the end and it's 120hz on the SX
Mr Moose
Member
Yeah people should be celebrating the game doesn't run like shit.
I prefer IW's character models and most of their campaigns (BO3 campaign was dog shit and 4 was MIA), but BO2 was one of the best CoDs.
VincentMatts
Member
But it does. I get non stop crashes on XSX. I literally cannot play one MP game since the last patch. Game is a turd.
Mr Moose
Member
I don't think RT is working on the Series S, is it? Might just be higher res shadows(?)Series S Ray Tracing:
Damn
I was going to buy it today.
Last edited:
mansoor1980
Gold Member
those gameplay FPS drops on RT mode on ps5 is a bug? wat
Evilms
Banned
these frame drops happen randomly, vg tech had noticed it before them.
VincentMatts
Member
I don't think RT is working on the Series S, is it? Might just be higher res shadows(?)
Damn
Dont. I wish i didnt at this point.
The only RT in this game is RTed Shadows. That's Ray Tracing. Pretty impressive for 1440p 60fps.I don't think RT is working on the Series S, is it? Might just be higher res shadows(?)
Damn
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
This is what the discussion should be about. Not near identical performance.
mansoor1980
Gold Member
need analysis after patch.......... just to be sure
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Yup. VGTech told about those frame drops a week ago. Sometimes they happen. Sometimes it's just a locked 60 FPS on PS5.
BigLee74
Member
Don't let me put you off. Your mileage may vary.
The SP campaign was fun, I'll give it that.
I don't know what console you have, but maybe RT on MP runs better on the PS5?
And lots of new maps will come in time, I'm sure.