-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Cyberpunk 2077 - Review Thread
- Thread starter JORMBO
- Start date
As another poster there, it has gone overboard.
HighFlyingBird
Member
Windom Earle
Member
We don't bite
Freeman76
Member
Erm, nobody has tried the day one patch yet have they? The reviews I saw didnt have access to it.
The game has amazing reviews so far man, they don't need to be updated, the most important score will be the Steam user score which is geniunely the most reliable way to rate a game
Kuranghi
Member
I don't expect "perfect lighting" ofc It looks like graphics are missing to me, its not just a few items, so many things in the scene look lifeless and flat in a way that other open world games without RTX don't imo. I'll just wait for more comparisons I think, thanks for sharing though, no ire meant towards you.
Windom Earle
Member
Hype completely unchanged. Give me that sweet sweet raytracing.
Gamespot review is yikes lmao.
Gamespot review is yikes lmao.
Cherry Sonoshee
Banned
I love the shitty posts about not wanting "politics" in thier games or other thinly vield shit posts.
In a game based on the cyperpunk genre. It's pretty funny.
GymWolf
Gold Member
This can't be real.
Batiman
Banned
You think should just ignore it’s flaws with the assumption it’ll get fixed? Why not pressure devs to ship the game unbroken. They can adjust the score later if they want.
Airbus Jr
Banned
Huh ? What? Is this for real?
Only negative review allowed there? Because they hate the game for transphobia?
Holy fuck these peoples are batshit crazy
Last edited:
HighFlyingBird
Member
Believe
MiguelItUp
Member
I'm not surprised at all. Polygon and Kotaku LOVE that stuff. They constantly go off on these weird tangents that hardly have anything to do with the game anymore. Or anything with games period. It's pretty embarrassing to me.
None of these reviewers have had access to THAT patch. They received another patch. But that particular patch is not available until launch. The fixes it will have are nothing but an assumption at this point.
They have told reviewers to use their stock footage in videos and won't allow them to use their own until launch and when that patch is available. So, I'm hoping it's because the patch will fix a lot of it, but we'll see.
Last edited:
Why do they make the politics the main aspect of the review then? I'm okay with the 78 from PCGamer because they gave valid reasons, places like Polygon and Gamespot reviewer who gave Anthem 6/10 and Days Gone 5/10
centracore
Member
Well, I'm sold - the only question that remains is whether I should get it on PC (i7 8700K / RTX 2080) or PS5..
diablos991
Can’t stump the diablos
I'm tempted to lock 30 fps on my PC to get that raytraced goodness.
Maybe I'll lock 45 fps since I have a gsync monitor.
Maybe I'll lock 45 fps since I have a gsync monitor.
Punished Miku
Member
Honestly sounds like no one should be giving it more than an 8. Its not a perfect 10 game in the best of circumstances. Probably a 9. But with that many bugs I'd take minimum 1 more point off that as well.
8 would be the top score I'd consider legitimate from what I'm reading.
8 would be the top score I'd consider legitimate from what I'm reading.
CloudNull
Banned
Oh shit I forgot they used to do that. I wish they would go back to that.
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Don't worry about it. By the time you hit forty, everything is fucking HILARIOUS.
TheContact
Member
This was probably posted but it's $50 on Amazon rn (ps4)
Amazon.com: Cyberpunk 2077 - PlayStation 4: Whv Games: Video Games
Amazon.com: Cyberpunk 2077 - PlayStation 4: Whv Games: Video Games
www.amazon.com
Kuranghi
Member
I envy you and your:
I won't have RTX as a choice so hope I can do 1440p60 on my GTX 1080 but I am worried because YongYea has said he couldn't keep locked 60 at 1440p on his RTX 3080
Last edited:
hemo memo
Gold Member
Yeah I moved from there when that place turned into a dictator land and posting freely or writing your opinion is like walking into a minefield.
AutumnLeaves
Member
Seriously, it's quite sad how there is no mention of performance on consoles and PC (with one minor mention).
Marcus Aurelius
Banned
Last edited by a moderator:
B-universe
Banned
Secretive?
Conspiracy?
Don't say silly things.
It's their job. That's what they are paid to do. The job of an executive is to manage, not to develop the actual game. And scores should definitely reflect the amount of bugs. A severely buggy game hardly deserves a 10/10. Evidently, I expect CDPR to address the bugs in time, like they did with TW3.
But I'm sure CDPR execs are having a blast reading about the copious amount of experience-sabotaging glitches . The Covid party starts tonight at 10, Warsaw time.
As for your buffoonish remarks about the left ruining my life, I'm sorry you had a bad lunch and acid reflux has clouded your judgement. I am specifically addressing Gamespot and Polygon reviews, like I said, both of which mainstream outlets, both of which explicitly citing real-world politics as factors in their scores.
If I remember correctly, Gamespot 10/10 was instrumental in TW3 rising to prominence on forums.
It's not a conspiracy. It's their legitimate right. Gamespot, Polygon or Kotaku have the right to review the game according to their worldview. Their site. Their review. Their criteria. Their score.
And I have the right to pass judgement on the reasons they themselves have cited for the mentioned scores.
Hope your burn eventually goes away.
Try some warm milk with a cinnamon stick.
Will do you wonders.
Last edited:
For avoidance of doubt.
No reviewer has played the version of the game that we will play on day 1
The version we will play will include the day 1 patch , that nobody has played yet, and has been the reason for 2 delays.
The version of the game that reviewers have played is the game at a standard that CDPR didn’t see fit to release to the general public.
There will be improvements, you do not delay a game twice if you can get away with not doing.
91% without those Improvements is monstrous.
No reviewer has played the version of the game that we will play on day 1
The version we will play will include the day 1 patch , that nobody has played yet, and has been the reason for 2 delays.
The version of the game that reviewers have played is the game at a standard that CDPR didn’t see fit to release to the general public.
There will be improvements, you do not delay a game twice if you can get away with not doing.
91% without those Improvements is monstrous.
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
I think CDPR should’ve consulted with Feminist Frequency much like Bioware did for Anthem. Game might’ve actually been a success then.
Seriously though, it warms my heart to see that the most hyped game of the year is devoid of the woke pandering garbage that plagues everything nowadays. You just know the dopes over at the other place are burning up inside.
Seriously though, it warms my heart to see that the most hyped game of the year is devoid of the woke pandering garbage that plagues everything nowadays. You just know the dopes over at the other place are burning up inside.
THEAP99
Banned
Mochilador
Member
Any mention of the Xbox version?
MiguelItUp
Member
Ah yeah! I almost forgot about that, Gamepro did that as well. It was something I definitely appreciated as I got older. I always loved "round table reviews" where a team review the same title, and discuss it. Cause then you get more than just one opinion, so it kind of spreads out to more folks.
Thaedolus
Gold Member
The Giant Bomb conversation between Jeff Gerstmann and Bakalar is pretty good right now, though they're almost done.
supernova8
Banned
Kinda sounds like it's a decent game but possibly not quite living up to the hype. Then again it's been hyped to high heaven, it was never going to
rofif
Banned
ouchFeast your eyes on this Raytraced screenshot from PC Games Hardware:
diablos991
Can’t stump the diablos
Buy on PC now, then double dip on console when the patches hit next year.
THEAP99
Banned
captainnapalm
Member
If this is getting a 91, you should add at least three to four points for the fact that it's largely being reviewed by "progressive" sjw morons. Add a couple more points for the bugs that will get fixed.
Coolwhhip
Neophyte
Thankfully Reeeeeesertra isn't the world though.