• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

ELDEN RING | Reviews Mega Thread

Fredrik

Member
”And the winner of the Game Of The Year award goes to…”

Poor Guerrilla, Bethesda, Sony Santa Monica, Nintendo(?) 🥲


This was so much higher than I expected! Wasn’t sure if I should buy this but this is just crazy, I’m not sitting on the fence here. Where is it the best? I have all platforms and an open wallet.
 

Banjo64

cumsessed
Nah 65" is a good size. My wife has never complained.
Ayy lmao :messenger_tears_of_joy:
tenor.gif
 

Swift_Star

Banned
Well done to FromSoft. If this really does deliver as positive an experience as the reviews suggest, then wow.

Though I must say the 97/100 feels weirdly artificial to me. I can't help but feel as though some of the scores are just the journos trying to keep their cred.

I am very excited to play!
Why does it feel artificial?
 

AV

We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
”And the winner of the Game Of The Year award goes to…”

Poor Guerrilla, Bethesda, Sony Santa Monica, Nintendo(?) 🥲

For real, BOTW2 might still release this year. We all knew the 2022 lineup was gonna be bananas, but...
 

Stuart360

Member
I feel i must of just got lucky with Dark Souls 3 and Sekiro as they ran at a locked 60fps on my PC, and both games seemingly had performance problems for some PC gamers, like this game it seems.
Hopefully i get lucky with Eldern Ring too lol.
Not sure why PC and XSX/PS5 should be having problems anyway with a game that looks around Dark Souls 3 level but open world anyway.
 

MiguelItUp

Member
RPS says PC version is fine. And they are PC people. Weird.

It's no surprise that some PC players are pickier than others. I guess that could be said with anyone out there in general. That being said, with PC there are SO many different combinations of specs that some folks are bound to experience some bizarre stuff that the majority may not.

All I know is that ACG and SkillUp didn't have issues that negatively impacted the game whatsoever. SkillUp mentioned having FPS drops, but when he lowered his res it was basically buttery smooth the entire time. But to say there performance was "so poor" is really odd to me.
 
Last edited:

Tg89

Member
It's not the specific score I'm focused on.

It's that games media entire structure is to prop up FOMO games (games that make the bulk of their profits in the first week) from publishers that draw traffic.

Elden Ring may be a GotY quality game. I'm not going to find out until about 1 - 6 months after release when information from more balanced sources starts overtaking the conversation.

Right now, 130 Greg Millers are yelling "buy this game!" and the superfans are eating it up.

Again, Elden Ring may indeed be an amazing game.
yeah, i get what you mean.

for me, I have no problem buying it because of FROMs pedigree. They consistently put out GOTG level games. the fact that they've supposedly infused that gameplay with arguably the best open world design/formula (botw) makes it easy for me to believe the reviews.
 

Buggy Loop

Member
RPS says PC version is fine. And they are PC people. Weird.


I mean some peoples have « PC » but in what kind of conditions? With the equivalent of a cat in dust inside? With fucking data mining apps all over the place? With background mining as a zombie PC that they don’t even know about? 🤷‍♂️

I’m pretty confident it will run well on mine, we’ll see.
 

Aja

Neo Member
From games are overhyped because of the fantastic art design and interesting Lore. I've yet to have literally anyone tell me whats special from a gameplay, A.I or story perspective. So you are not alone.

So "God works in mysterious ways" basically.
I don't really get the "God" part or "mystery" part but......sure?

I just mean it's different to actually go skydiving or to watch someone skydive on TV. It's different to watch a movie review or to actually see the movie for you're self. If that has to do with God and/or mystery. So be it.
 

Orbital2060

Member
Looking forward to reading about peoples playthroughs in the OT thread, always great fun.

Good look everyone - and praise the Sun 🌞
 

kingpotato

Ask me about my Stream Deck
Yes, but they never fixed frame pacing issues for example. They also left Sekiro and PS4Pro version of DS3 in broken state with unlocked/stuttery framerate until PS5 BC fixed this years later by brute force...
I'm not disagreeing, but I personally feel the frame pacing issues were only truly severe on Bloodborne. I also didn't feel Sekiro and DS3 were "broken" when I played through them on ps4pro, though I'm not denying they had performance issues.

All I'm saying is there's good reason to believe performance will be improved soon after launch and that the games will be enjoyable on all current gen platforms.
 
Dark Souls 3 and Sekiro ran very well on PC..I played Sekiro on launch day on PC and I can't remember it ever getting a patch during my playthrough. still ran like a dream at 1440p60 max settings on a GTX1070 and a Ryzen 2600
Ya, Sekiro did run well. I recently did a playthrough of DS3 just a few days ago and it ran super well other than me having to hex-edit in Ultrawide Support. I really hope it runs great on PC. I just want to experience the adventure.
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly


Probably what they flagged in their early beta video, that you can play the PS4 Pro version of the game on a PS5 at locked 1440p 60fps with the middle road settings. No such luck on Xbox where smart delivery prevents this.

Ahhh shit balls! Series x version is broken.

Because I've bought the ps5 disk can I download the ps4 version to play on ps5 or would I have needed the ps4 version?
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
If I was Microsoft I would have sent all the ninjas to from soft to assist with the xbox version. Failure on their part if they haven't.
 
Last edited:

Roxkis_ii

Member
I'm not big into souls games but holy smokes. This is the highest rated game I've seen so far.

Congrats to the souls fans, it sounds like you guys are in for a treat.
 

ethomaz

Banned
Just seen an early comparison vid and whilst the PS5 version hovers around the high 50’s to 60 fps in performance mode, the Series X seems to hover quite a bit in the 40’s. Obviously, it’s an open world game, but it’ll be interesting to see what DF make of it all.
I watched the IGN video review, which was apparently the PC version, and that didn’t look particularly smooth tbh.
From never creat smooth games… and they never fix their framerate issues either.
 

Stuart360

Member
For people that want to look at an early comparison of all versions -



PS5 version runs the best in the 55-60fps range most of the time.
None of the modes are locked though, including the 30fps quality modes, which is pretty weird and shit really.. And even the best version in PS5 can be anywhere from 50-60fps. Series S hovers around 50fps, and XSX version sems to be in the 40-50fps range, and actually performs worse than the S version.

I dont really think any of the console versions are very good in any mode. I just hope my Dark Souls 3 and Sekiro luck keeps going and i can get a locked 60fps on my PC.

Not very impressive though from From, yet again.
The PS5 version is the one to get out of the consoles though.
 

01011001

Banned
For people that want to look at an early comparison of all versions -



PS5 version runs the best in the 55-60fps range most of the time.
None of the modes are locked though, including the 30fps quality modes, which is pretty weird and shit really.. And even the best version in PS5 can be anywhere from 50-60fps. Series S hovers around 50fps, and XSX version sems to be in the 40-50fps range, and actually performs worse than the S version.

I dont really think any of the console versions are very good in any mode. I just hope my Dark Souls 3 and Sekiro luck keeps going and i can get a locked 60fps on my PC.

Not very impressive though from From, yet again.
The PS5 version is the one to get out of the consoles though.


yeah this is just awful... I really hope the PC version is good 🤞
 

Thief1987

Member
Well done to FromSoft. If this really does deliver as positive an experience as the reviews suggest, then wow.

Though I must say the 97/100 feels weirdly artificial to me. I can't help but feel as though some of the scores are just the journos trying to keep their cred.

I am very excited to play!
It looks like another case when press overhypes themselves long before the reviews so they are just giving perfect scores by inertia. Similar to BOTW and RDR2, where in reality both games are far from their MC aggregate.
 
Last edited:

kingpotato

Ask me about my Stream Deck
Not to diminish hyped but just saw this on the discord ... Oof

Confirmed performance values for elden ring so far:

Xbox one s- 25-30fps
Xbox one x- 30fps but uncapped.

Ps4-30fps
Ps4 pro- 30fps

Series s- quality mode 30fps uncapped
Performance 45-50fps…

Series x- quality 35-40fps
Performance- 45-50fps

Ps5- Quality 45fps
Performance 55-60fps slight improvement over CNT.
 
Top Bottom