• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Twitter says Super Mario Bros movie is mediocre, boring, uncreative - the Live action movie was better

Killer8

Member
He won.

You Got This Lets Go GIF by Sonic The Hedgehog
 
To be fair....illumination has always been a mediocre studio in terms of writing and direction and humor. I was hoping maybe the nintendo collab would help, but looks like their mediocrity came through regardless.

I wished pixar or the team who did zootopia would get mario. But nope...illumination. for most parents, people, especially kids, these studios blend together. But for nerd like me we know illumination is the worst of the bunch specifically
 
Last edited:

Nvzman

Member
From the studio that brought you humanity’s most annoying creation, The Minions. What did these people even expect?

It’s a kid/family movie first (and nothing wrong with that).
I'll be honest, I was about to say "well there was a time when you could have family movies that were actually written well and worked for both adults and kids (see: Pixar from 95-07 and Shrek 1 + 2)", but we did literally just get Puss in Boots 2.

Being a kids movie doesn't excuse it being ass.
 

Codes 208

Member
I have no idea who most of these people are, but i presume a lot of them are the same people who bitched that Godzilla KotM had no real plot outside of the monsters

Like no shit, it was a love letter to the fans and what the fans wanted (giant monsters fighting), and everything ive seen so far suggests that this is too
 
Last edited:

shiru

Banned
From the studio that brought you humanity’s most annoying creation, The Minions. What did these people even expect?

It’s a kid/family movie first (and nothing wrong with that).
The Lion King was also a kids/family movie. Let's not excuse mediocrity. As if being a family movie means you should expect trash. What the fuck?

When adults complain a movie for kids is for kids. I’m sure my kids will have a blast.
Some of us grew up with Mario and would have preferred if the movie didn't suck.
 
Last edited:

kanjobazooie

Mouse Ball Fetishist
The Lion King was also a kids/family movie. Let's not excuse mediocrity. As if being a family movie means you should expect trash. What the fuck?
The Lion King was not made by Illumination.

And I never said "kids movie = trash"
 
Last edited:

kunonabi

Member
The terrible ‚humor‘ in all the trailers I‘ve seen told me everything I needed to know about this movie.



„Incel Bowser“? What the actual fuck?
I mean they seemingly made Luigi the damsel in distress instead of Peach so not a shock
 

kanjobazooie

Mouse Ball Fetishist
Not sure what your point is. IIlumination makes bad movies, thus they should be given a pass? or something?
That's not my point.

Illumination makes average movies that kids love, so it's expected that Mario would also be an average movie that kids will love. That's all.
 

No, he didn't. The Mario Bros movie is actually loved by general audiences that actually saw the movie, from what I gathered around the internet. Hardly any bad impression of it. It's just the movie critics that don't like the movie.

And in terms of worldwide box office, it looks like it will surpass either Sonic film as the highest grossing Video game movie of all time. It's expected to rake in $225 million globally when it opens.

https://deadline.com/2023/04/super-mario-bros-air-box-office-opening-ben-affleck-amazon-1235316883/
 

20cent

Banned
It only needs easter eggs and wink-wink references every 3 min to please idiots, the same kind that can only talk about movies with box-office $ score angle.
 

Joramun

Member
To be fair....illumination has always been a mediocre studio in terms of writing and direction and humor. I was hoping maybe the nintendo collab would help, but looks like their mediocrity came through regardless.

I wished pixar or the team who did zootopia would get mario. But nope...illumination. for most parents, people, especially kids, these studios blend together. But for nerd like me we know illumination is the worst of the bunch specifically
Zootopia was so bloody good. Even for an older cnt like me. Sonic was pretty good too actually.
 
Top Bottom