DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Sell the lowest common denominator more publishers. That will "fix" things.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
iamvin22
Industry Verified
I believe she was put in a position so they can get rid of her. Like really, what could she do to change anything?!?
Killjoy-NL
Member
Start an Xbox OF.
?? I have only pointed out the OP's funny situation in which he uses Welfare as the source of all his XS sales estimates but then decides to ignore Welfare's LTD figures and invents a different one...
That said, I have no hope for anything, the figures are what they are and surely MS would like them to be better at the beginning of the generation. The fact is that these figures have already been assumed when they themselves predict sales similar to XBO.
Rather, I see the hope of some here that the possibility that XS will not surpass XBO and that will lead MS to end the console business and become a 3rd party, doom and ruins...
You are not discovering penicillin... It is clear that MS would have liked to have better sales figures for XS at the beginning of the generation but it is clear that they have already assumed that this will not be the case and hence they have estimated figures similar to XBO .
From here, it is clear that this generation wants to make money on the software part and their commitment to PC on day one of launch is a double-edged sword that harms any sales potential of XS.
Some of you want to think that selling ~45-55 million XS consoles is linked to the fact that the generation of MS gaming division will be a total failure when it doesn't have to be that way. In fact, the fact that the XBO generation was more profitable than the X360 should be significant to some that should already know that the success of the Xbox gaming business is not intrinsically linked to the Xbox console.
Fake
Member
Switch selling like crazy for outdated hw
Making good games. Shocking, I know.
Sushi_Combo
Member
I see Microsoft are continuing of being the underdogs of the generation.
MarkMe2525
Member
Lower than I would have guessed at the start of the gen. This is also in line with what many expected when MS starting treating PC as equal to their consoles. If one does have a decent PC, not many reasons to get another box. I just hope they don't completely exit the console market. PlayStation needs competition in the console space.
demigod
is back I see. This is his kinda thread so it's to be expected. Question though, wouldn't it be wise to change up the emoji based on the content of the post. The laughing emoji doesn't really fit and get across your point (which is to troll) when nothing controversial is said. If I were you, I would have dropped the empathy one. It fits better.
demigod
is back I see. This is his kinda thread so it's to be expected. Question though, wouldn't it be wise to change up the emoji based on the content of the post. The laughing emoji doesn't really fit and get across your point (which is to troll) when nothing controversial is said. If I were you, I would have dropped the empathy one. It fits better.
Last edited:
YeulEmeralda
Member
Sony output in games has been fairly lacklustre this gen in my opinion. But they sell lots of consoles.
veterangamerUK
Member
Yeah it’s come to the point sadly where they don’t even have to try and still sell gangbusters
MasterCornholio
Member
Seems like at this point all people need is a console that plays games from them. But I agree that having good 1st party games makes it even better for them.
Gambit2483
Member
It amazes me how the platform that can barely push 5 million units in 9 months was just handed one of the single most profitable and valuable IP in the industry....huh
Let there be competition
bitbydeath
Gold Member
She’s a puppet, so nothing.
But if she had the power she would need to stop releasing Xbox exclusives on day one for PC and GamePass.
Everyone saw this coming, except for the fans that can’t/won’t ever say a bad word about Xbox. They’re all going down with that ship.
Mibu no ookami
Member
I've been telling people for months, so it's a relief to see people finally picking up the pieces here.
Microsoft is in a dire situation and all the obfuscation that they can conjure won't change that.
I can't imagine anyone will be looking to buy an XS next year. I've admonished people who think the PS5 will sell 12 million in Q3FY23, but I do think that it could sell 9+ million. That's devastating to Microsoft from a mindshare perspective. For the second holiday season in a row, anyone who wants a PS5 will be able to get one and they have another banger of a title to go hand in hand with the console.
I really don't think people understand what that means, especially as much of this will be concentrated in the West. What it means is that anyone who asks "What gaming system should I buy?" is going to have the same answer... A PS5... it's what everyone's friends got for Christmas. Buy An Xbox and not have the kid be able to play Spider-Man when that's what everyone is playing now?
That's how the N64, Saturn, Gamecube, Dreamcast, and OG Xbox got roasted. And to be frank N64, GameCube, and even OG Xbox had bigger titles to keep them in the mindshare than XBS does now. This only gets worse when the PS5 Pro comes out to no competition.
GamePass is poisoning the Xbox brand. We're going to see how Microsoft handles that poison. If they stop doing Day 1 on PC and/or Day 1 on GamePass. The reason why GamePass isn't growing fast enough is because the Xbox consoles aren't selling fast enough.
Microsoft is in a dire situation and all the obfuscation that they can conjure won't change that.
I can't imagine anyone will be looking to buy an XS next year. I've admonished people who think the PS5 will sell 12 million in Q3FY23, but I do think that it could sell 9+ million. That's devastating to Microsoft from a mindshare perspective. For the second holiday season in a row, anyone who wants a PS5 will be able to get one and they have another banger of a title to go hand in hand with the console.
I really don't think people understand what that means, especially as much of this will be concentrated in the West. What it means is that anyone who asks "What gaming system should I buy?" is going to have the same answer... A PS5... it's what everyone's friends got for Christmas. Buy An Xbox and not have the kid be able to play Spider-Man when that's what everyone is playing now?
That's how the N64, Saturn, Gamecube, Dreamcast, and OG Xbox got roasted. And to be frank N64, GameCube, and even OG Xbox had bigger titles to keep them in the mindshare than XBS does now. This only gets worse when the PS5 Pro comes out to no competition.
GamePass is poisoning the Xbox brand. We're going to see how Microsoft handles that poison. If they stop doing Day 1 on PC and/or Day 1 on GamePass. The reason why GamePass isn't growing fast enough is because the Xbox consoles aren't selling fast enough.
TheGodfather07
Member
Let there be competition nadella said. After 80b spent on publishers, they're worse off than they were last generation. Should have known when to quit instead of wasting money on a sinking ship. You ain't saving it.
Mibu no ookami
Member
Also, people don't ask what games Sony makes and what games Microsoft makes on a console. The vast majority of consumers have no idea. It's why Sony rebranded so many times and finally landed on PlayStation Studios as a moniker because they want to build that reputation like Nintendo.
People care about what console their friends have because they don't know that cross-platform play works on most games now, but also because they want to play the same games and there are SOME exclusives. If you're a FF or Square Enix fan would you get a PS5 or Xbox? If you like Japanese games at all? Which console? If you wanted to play baseball before, you HAD to have a PlayStation. The most core baseball fans associated baseball with PlayStation. Sony is selling units to xbox fans and generating revenue from gamepass (or at least MLB is) but they're still getting the association.
Games come out for almost every platform now, but Sony has done enough to differentiate itself as the place to play and that is communicated to everyone.
I remember getting a Game Gear as a kid and I can tell you that was the wrong choice. When you're on a school bus and want to borrow someone else's game during a field trip, you're SOL.
People care about what console their friends have because they don't know that cross-platform play works on most games now, but also because they want to play the same games and there are SOME exclusives. If you're a FF or Square Enix fan would you get a PS5 or Xbox? If you like Japanese games at all? Which console? If you wanted to play baseball before, you HAD to have a PlayStation. The most core baseball fans associated baseball with PlayStation. Sony is selling units to xbox fans and generating revenue from gamepass (or at least MLB is) but they're still getting the association.
Games come out for almost every platform now, but Sony has done enough to differentiate itself as the place to play and that is communicated to everyone.
I remember getting a Game Gear as a kid and I can tell you that was the wrong choice. When you're on a school bus and want to borrow someone else's game during a field trip, you're SOL.
FalsettoVibe
Member
This. The longer this type of thing goes on, they harder it is to pull people out of Sony and Nintendo ecosystems.
Phil even said it himself. They lost the worst generation to loose last gen because digital ecosystems were being built.
Last edited:
ThisIsMyDog
Member
1. Put all your games on better platform (PC)
2. Your console is selling like shit.
3. Shocked pikachu face i guess.
2. Your console is selling like shit.
3. Shocked pikachu face i guess.
Mibu no ookami
Member
There is a reason Sony is trying to aggressively increase their numbers right now. The more units they put between the PS5 and XBS the more difficult and expensive it will be for Microsoft to get exclusive deals. Either companies will refuse because they don't want their games to end up like X1 exclusive games or they'll cost an absolute fortune to the point where it doesn't make financial sense for Microsoft to make the deals.
The biggest thing Microsoft could do would be to get 3 months exclusivity for GTA6 and we'll see if they're able to do that. The game will probably launch right before the holidays which would up the cost of doing that too.
Imagine you have next year 70 million units that your game isn't going to touch... That's a tough pill to swallow.
The biggest thing Microsoft could do would be to get 3 months exclusivity for GTA6 and we'll see if they're able to do that. The game will probably launch right before the holidays which would up the cost of doing that too.
Imagine you have next year 70 million units that your game isn't going to touch... That's a tough pill to swallow.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Yet, he failed upwards.
LordOcidax
Member
Switch is going to beat Nintendo expectations easily this year… Selling above 15 million the year before their successor launch is just mind blowing.
TheThreadsThatBindUs
Member
Spencer and Matt Booty.
The latter delivered essentially no quality mass-appeal FP games for 1.5 gens and gets promoted. Shows why Xbox has a management problem. They clearly aren't running an organization where they promote people on the basis of merit.
Mibu no ookami
Member
Microsoft is doubling down because they don't see a way out. They took a big swing to disrupt the industry and they missed.
When the time comes for the axe to fall though, it'll fall hard.
The Xbox brand has been so utterly poisoned by GamePass and Day 1 PC that I think we're at the point where they can't recover.
They obviously have to make a play at some exclusivity for GTA6, so we'll see if they get it, but aside from that this generation is over. Done. Finished. Finito.
It also doesn't really make sense to put out another console. At that point, you have Microsoft Shutter Xbox as a brand and essentially put ABK in charge of everything including the Xbox IP like Halo, Forza, and Fable. All of which will end up on Switch 2 and PS5 or PS6.
Nintendo needs to ask itself if it should put out a Switch 2 Pro that is a pure home console if Xbox collapses. It makes sense for there to be a strong challenger to PlayStation as not every Xbox user will want to jump to PlayStation, just as we saw with the Dreamcast.
Mibu no ookami
Member
They're getting promoted because they're at the end of their rope. There is no one else to run the ship and they aren't bringing in anyone external to right the ship at this point.
It's sink or swim.
reinking
Gold Member
I bet there are some people at Xbox that are surprised by them. I agree though, I am an old school PC gamer that has played many MS PC games in my time and will continue to do so. The issue I see for Xbox/MS in this scenario is that they will have less control over the PC market. If they had succeeded (the way they wanted) in the console space they would have had a lot more influence and ability to manipulate the market. In that regard, they have failed. I wonder how many generations of traditional consoles they have left? One? Two?
TheThreadsThatBindUs
Member
And this is where they went wrong.
When they bought Zenimax, they should have dissolved the existing Xbox Game Studios publishing business and put all the existing MS Xbox game studios under Zenimax.
LordOcidax
Member
If Sony in the best position right now, why they are restructuring?
Mibu no ookami
Member
Zenimax has troubles of its own, plus no experience running a platform. Todd Howard is on his way out and I bet he sets up a new studio before teh end of the decade.
In the same vein, you can't put Bobby Kotick in charge either.
They made their choice to focus on GamePass and Day 1 PC but neither model is a healthy model and the combination is absolutely poison. No one is going to come in and fix that.
Let's say you bring in a new CEO and they say GamePass is canceled and PC Day 1 is over. You'll have a run on the bank and a lot of people will simply leave Xbox and more importantly perhaps, very few people will have the trust to buy anything Xbox at that point.
So you say, let's just stop Day 1 PC... but that directly impacts the growth of GamePass and maybe even GamePass subscribership... meaning you immediately lose maybe 15-25 percent of GamePass users... You've essentially killed GamePass anyway...
Microsoft is in a no-win situation. So the best choice is to let the people who brought you to the dance finish the dance out. I think they have one maybe two years left before it's no longer feasible.
Mibu no ookami
Member
They aren't really restructuring. Jim Ryan is leaving and his replacement will need to be chosen. That's not a restructuring.
iamvin22
Industry Verified
Agreed. Still can't believe greenburg is still around.
DeepSpace5D
Member
Sheesh…I mean, at that current pace, it would take Xbox like 3.5-4 years to match what PS5 is selling this year alone? That’s pretty much the rest of this gen of consoles. And don’t console sales usually slow down more towards the end of their lifecycles?
FalsettoVibe
Member
Explain how this comment makes any sense in relation to what I said. Hell, explain in general.
Last edited:
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Phil climbed higher despite failing in the previous gen.
kruis
Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
MS has two problems: not just a much lower number of consoles sold, but also a customer base that (because of gamepass) buys relatively few games compared to PS5/Switch owners. If MS wants to get an exclusive GTA 6 deal it's going to cost them a lot. And I don't think Rockstar would want to piss off its largest customer base when launching their game of the decade.
FalsettoVibe
Member
That explanation still does not validate your comment. Phil himself said they(Xbox) failed (past tense) last gen. There is no such thing as "failing upwards" in this case. They failed. There was no falling upwards last gen for them.
I see where you're trying to go with this. (All of the moves MS has made), but that currently means jack. You saying PHIL climbed higher is weird since I was not talking about Phil's career, nor was I talking about the present.
Now if 5 years from now MS is in a totally different/better position and at that point we look at the past 15 years as whole, then your comment might hold weight.
Last edited:
Snowdonhoffen
Member
Investor9872
Member
NSW 9.91 m. Pretty good for an 8-year old system! Goes to show that quality 1st-party games will move hardware.
Last edited:
Mibu no ookami
Member
After Halo, Forza, and Starfield... I don't see anything that is going to propel hardware sales, especially next year.
There is going to be a rapid decline in sales as a result.
Avowed and Hellblade... aren't going to cut it. I think next year will probably be the last year of notable sales for the Xbox unless something drastic happens, massive price cut and/or GTA6 exclusivity, even timed.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
I know you weren’t talking about it, I did.
As a additional comment on them failing, yet Phil got promoted.
FalsettoVibe
Member
Then why even quote me? Jesus....lol
Me: "Xbox failed last gen"
You: "But my boy Phil got promoted"
Last edited:
DeepSpace5D
Member
Is something like GTA6 exclusivity a realistic possibilty though after recently spending so much on Actiblizz? Obviously MS has the money for that easily but are they really going to give carte blanch funding to xbox like that?