-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
CatLady
Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Yeah, I voted for Zelda too. It was a good game but not my game of the year. It was nice to see HiFi Rush get so many nominations I hope it ends up winning something.
tommib
Member
GHG
Member
Amnesia.
It's like they've conveniently forgotten that along with the dozens of what will you shit while you shit out Starfield threads that clogged up this forum.
Flutta
Banned
You guys keep saying this over and over again like clockwork. It’s sounds to me that these ”warriors” live rent free in your minds.
mrmustard
Banned
Hifi Rush wasn't for me. I can see why people like it, but i never finished it.
incredible how these shills here think everyone else as dumb as they are,
they themselves turned the front page of the forum to a hypeboard leading to release
now allergic to any starfart talk all of a sudden lol.
Last edited:
DeaDPo0L84
Member
That's actually a really solid list, played most of those and would like to play the Nintendo ones, BG3 should take the crown though.
Banjo64
cumsessed
MR ARCADE FOREVER
Member
No Hogwarts Legacy is a joke.
Probably Jeff wanted to please the ResetEra basement judges and the woke gaming media.
Probably Jeff wanted to please the ResetEra basement judges and the woke gaming media.
Flutta
Banned
Markio128
Member
I wouldn’t mind any of those games winning GOTY tbh. The only one I don’t yet own is SMB: Wonder, but it will be mine soon. I do have a few issues with AW 2, but it’s still a well crafted, compelling game. SM 2 is just pure fun, and it’s the only game this year that I have smashed through (actually, I did smash through Red Matter 2 as well). I’ve still yet to finish TOTK, RE4 R or BG3, but I’ll get around to completing them at some point.
It’s been an incredible year overall, and I’ve probably got enough awesome games in my library to last me 6 months. I really need to stop buying games
It’s been an incredible year overall, and I’ve probably got enough awesome games in my library to last me 6 months. I really need to stop buying games
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
I've not played it yet. Only the prologue and it seemed good. I was waiting for more patches. I need to start it soon.
The list is terrible. Real good games got robbed.
I would personally put FF16, Hogwarts and Forspoken all above AW2. AW2 doesn't deserve it. There is almost no game there and it's just badly written adventure game with no adventure.... no matter. Barely any combat, barely any survival, barely any horror.
My personal goty would be Hogwarts Legacy or AC6.... ff16, re4 and forspoken close 2nd.
From their list, RE4 remake easily.
Banjo64
cumsessed
This simply can’t be real
I blame this guy. He didn’t play it enough for it to warrant GOTY.
40 gamerscore is like, played it for 10 mins territory and he was thrashing about blocking people over this game
Doom85
Member
Voted Baldur’s Gate 3 for pretty much every category it was available for.
Also, I shit on FF XVI a lot, but aside from music (though not best of year, BG 3 and Alan Wake 2 both beat it, probably a few others too), the other category I think it deserved a nomination for would be voice acting…..if it was Cid’s voice actor. Like, Clive’s is good, but not one of the best of the year to me.
Also, I shit on FF XVI a lot, but aside from music (though not best of year, BG 3 and Alan Wake 2 both beat it, probably a few others too), the other category I think it deserved a nomination for would be voice acting…..if it was Cid’s voice actor. Like, Clive’s is good, but not one of the best of the year to me.
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
Danjin44
The nicest person on this forum
Its western centric award show, Japanese Mecha game never had a chance.Armored Core 6 got robbed, and I will never forgive the Dorito pope!
Gavon West
Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
Ummmm......maybe I'm missing your point? " One of the most important RPG's ever made." "Spencer wants Starfield to be bigger than Skyrim" "Microsoft bought Bethesda to stop Starfield from becoming a Playstation exclusive" etc.... I dont get where he's saying its supposed to save Xbox here, broski...
Again, Starfield is a HUGE success. Its like a lot of you kats live in some alternate reality, and because you FEEL LIKE Starfield was a failure, it is. Bizarre behavior.......Hate to break it to you my dude, but F your feelings (no offense). its still selling and still being talked about MONTHS after its initial release. Thats pretty unprecedented when most games are only talked about for a week. The numbers dont lie. And frankly, for it to be a brand new IP, no attached lore or community, and to see the numbers and success its had all ready is a pretty clear message.
Punished Miku
Gold Member
In reality:
Pre-release narrative: I'm just expecting Fallout in space. I am absolutely expecting loading screens. Don't get too hyped up and just see if you like it.
Post-release narrative: It's GOTY so far, but I don't vote until late December.
digoutyoursoul
Member
Twat
Saber
Gold Member
The show didn't even started and the mentally disturbed fanboy already lost his mind? lol
Last edited:
Daneel Elijah
Gold Member
I promise you that I will laugh with you when/if that happen. But honestly I think that Xbox is good at not doing the same mistake twice, but to find another way to fail, if you see what I mean by that. They were too controlling with their studios? Full freedom now. Rrod of death? All consoles after that got a lot of headroom. Being with a overpriced console that have worse performance than the PS4? 2 consoles now. Don't get me wrong, all of those decisions do have problems of their own. But I think that a game like Redfall should not happen again. If/ when another of their games fail, it will be for another reason, like Crackdown 3 got a dispute about a core tech and got fucked as a result. At least I hope so. If Gamepass continue to force them to release games that are not ready then I can't see Gamepass soar to the 100 millions subscribers that Microsoft want to have.Based on nothing but hopes and dreams, Xbox will never let that happen again.
Banjo64
cumsessed
64bitmodels
Reverse groomer.
I voted mario wonder for goty but I'm sure bg3 will win. Both games are goated, though
Doom85
Member
Yeah, they hate Armored Core 6, giving it the final big trailer treatment last year, what a bunch of mecha-hating assholes Geoff and his team are.
It‘s not like 2023 was stacked or anything, and maybe some people just don’t think the game was on par with some others this year…..
Doom85
Member
In that case, FF XVI should be disqualified since there was barely any meaningful RPG in a game in a RPG series.
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
There was barely any rpg but I dno't give a shit how rpg it is.In that case, FF XVI should be disqualified since there was barely any meaningful RPG in a game in a RPG series.
It was excellent action and had ton of good gameplay and story
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
Genuinely great game. The one I still go back to and just load my save and roam around for a bit.
3liteDragon
Member
Solid list
skit_data
Member
Doom85
Member
But for Alan Wake 2, you specifically bemoaned the lack of survival and the lack of horror (as it is a survival horror game), so by that argument, FF XVI failed for not living up to its genre either. Got to play by your own rules now.
64bitmodels
Reverse groomer.
i didn't really play it. just because it sold well doesn't mean that it's super relevant. Didn't get a fraction of the attention and love AW2 or BG3 had
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
"Starfield is the most important RPG ever."
"Xbox bought Bethesda for $7.5 billion for Starfield"
But, yeah, Microsoft didn't hype Starfield
Oh, my bad. I must have missed the news about it being a huge success.
I'm happy to correct myself. Can you share how many copies the game has sold yet?
Kenpachii
Member
Bro the game is praised by everybody i know, even girls that never play games. I played it myself and its the best open world game out there this year. Should they win game of the year, no bg3 does. But not having any nomination in any category or even a mention of it is just laughable.
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
Well I don't agree. FF16 didn't had to be an rpg. It's about as linear as ff7 remake. FF is immune forthir critique because each game is unique.
But what was there was mostly excellent.
Now, AW2 is survival horror and while I liked parts of the story and atmosphere, there was almost no shooting, your ammo was abundant, pacing was bad, saga was bad and you are pretending to be a detective in mind place whule listening to tons of monologues.
That game didn't do a single thing as well as FF16 did story and combat... even if RPG was only for show in ff16
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
JFC Spider-Man actually got nominated? Really?
Baldur’s Gate’s got this in the sack. Between BG3 and a Nintendo game that according to many already won in 2017, it’s a done deal.
Baldur’s Gate’s got this in the sack. Between BG3 and a Nintendo game that according to many already won in 2017, it’s a done deal.
Gudji
Member
Redfall > Starfield confirmed by Senjutsu.This simply can’t be real
40 gamerscore is like, played it for 10 mins territory and he was thrashing about blocking people over this game
Doom85
Member
Each game prior in the franchise is a unique RPG. It’s the genre of the series. So failing to make anything RPG there matter in an installment is a fail.
Otherwise, the next FF game could be a basketball game by your argument.
FF VII Remake actually had leveling, weapons, customization, etc. matter, so it works as a RPG.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Exactly. My boy gaslighting others into believing nobody hyped Starfield, while he forgets he was posting this a few months before Starfield's release:
