I picked this game up for 20 bucks Canadian last week, thought I'd chime in with my thoughts.
I am not one to buy shovel ware. I would normally overlook this title had it not been for this thread. It is not a perfect game with perfect controls, but it has so much to do and for such a cheap price it is really hard to complain.
20 bucks guys, 20 bucks.
I am still exploring, finding new things to do, and having a blast. This game really puts every mini-game compilation to shame, including the Mario Party's. Cruising around on a jet ski, horse, roller blades, or ATV is a shit load of fun. There are a lot of crappy mini games. For example, I stopped at the ski resort to do the ice fishing mini game. It is crappy, and mindless, and once you figure it out it's incredibly easy....but I did it once and will never do it again. I like that. I like that I can stop, participate in a crappy little mini game, figure it out for what it's worth, and never participate again. Freedom baby!
20 bucks guys, 20 bucks.
Exploring is a ton of fun. It is cool because your mii's on your system will appear on the island and just follow you around. I have a dog too. I know I can furnish my house but I have yet to explore that option. I also have not even touched the multiplayer.
This game, in a lot of ways, put wii sports resort to shame. It gives you freedom! Something sports games have never done. This game, in a lot of ways, set a new bar for mini-sports-compilations-games.
20 bucks guys!
I can't recommend it enough. Great for casual friends, great for mindless exploration, and a fantastic value. Considering the price, I'd give this game a 9/10. So much to do and very relaxing.