• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Expanse |S2| You guys look like shit - Wednesdays on Syfy

K

Korey

Member
I've been trying to get into this show but I'm having trouble following and it's not super compelling so far.

Some of the scenes and dialogue are confusing and I have no idea what's going on other than some broad strokes.

Does it get better or should I stop?

I'm on season 1 episode 6.
 
Moff

Moff

Member
Jackpot said:
Yes. When they hit the protogen station and the head scientist tells them what it was meant to do. Please don't inject spoiler-phobia into a thread.
Click to expand...

he really didn't though, he said it was headed for earth specifically and said he wanted to use the protomolecule against an enemy who took the first shot

I am also not surprised there are next to no comments about the new episode in this thread, felt very filler
 
N

nOoblet16

Member
Korey said:
I've been trying to get into this show but I'm having trouble following and it's not super compelling so far.

Some of the scenes and dialogue are confusing and I have no idea what's going on other than some broad strokes.

Does it get better or should I stop?

I'm on season 1 episode 6.
Click to expand...
The first season has a lot of mystery/suspense to it...So it's understandable to not know what's going on. What confusing dialogues are you referring to btw?

I like the show because it is very unique in its setting, visuals and the conspiracy elements. And honestly also because it's the only space opera right now...a genre that has been absent since Stargate Universe was called off.
 
S

suzu

Member
Moff said:
I am also not surprised there are next to no comments about the new episode in this thread, felt very filler
Click to expand...

They seem to be dragging stuff out. Also the show continues to depict Bobbie as a naive hothead. Meh.
 
K

Korey

Member
nOoblet16 said:
The first season has a lot of mystery/suspense to it...So it's understandable to not know what's going on. What confusing dialogues are you referring to btw?

I like the show because it is very unique in its setting, visuals and the conspiracy elements. And honestly also because it's the only space opera right now...a genre that has been absent since Stargate Universe was called off.
Click to expand...
Just a lot of the Julie Mao stuff.. Opa and the data broker that's dead but is someone else? the anubis and ship she was on intercepting them or something.

And the cops partner from earth and how he's learning something from that girl.

In the last episode they showed that bad guy blowing up a vessel full of women and kids. Guess that was to show that the guy is bad.

Anyways it just seems like a show not put together well. Maybe I should have expected this because it's just a syfy show. I tried it because I heard some good things, has a decent imdb rating, and this thread seems to pop up a lot. But it doesn't seem to be that good so far.
 
S

StopMakingSense

Member
Korey said:
Just a lot of the Julie Mao stuff.. Opa and the data broker that's dead but is someone else? the anubis and ship she was on intercepting them or something.

And the cops partner from earth and how he's learning something from that girl.

In the last episode they showed that bad guy blowing up a vessel full of women and kids. Guess that was to show that the guy is bad.

Anyways it just seems like a show not put together well. Maybe I should have expected this because it's just a syfy show. I tried it because I heard some good things, has a decent imdb rating, and this thread seems to pop up a lot. But it doesn't seem to be that good so far.
Click to expand...

1) Just pieces of the puzzle getting put together. I did find it slightly confusing the first time I watched it at this very specific part.

2) This is all about him as an Earther trying to understand the developed Belter Culture and language.

3) Man, thats a long story, and it's an important touchstone for understanding Fred Johnson. It's still being developed halfway through season 2.
 
A

aku:jiki

Member
suzu said:
They seem to be dragging stuff out. Also the show continues to depict Bobbie as a naive hothead. Meh.
Click to expand...
Yeah, New Bobbie kind of sucks so far. Don't love the actress either, though I think she performed decently this time.

And speaking of character inconsistensies, I really didn't like that Amos pushed the starving mom and scared her kid. That didn't feel right and having him do something he doesn't like doing only to show that he actually regrets doing it is a hamfisted way to present characterization. It's not like he's 12 and just now finding this out about himself.
 
N

nOoblet16

Member
So someone explain this to me, Avasarala has pretty much the highest political position in the government that is obtainable without being elected, which means she doesn't really have to answer to the people or her supporters or whatever giving her real power. But Errinwright is still her boss and anything she does would look like it was done with Errinwright's approval (who has to answer to others), yet she seems to have power over him and tells him what to do and not.

Why is that?
 
F

Fafnir

Member
So Miller's belter sidekick was the kid that got thrown out the airlock by his uncle in season 1? I always wondered what happened to that kid.
 
J

jerry113

Banned
Jarred Harris (Dawes) of The Crown fame is the best actor on this show.

He's very charismatic and I would probably follow him into battle too.
 
D

danm999

Member
nOoblet16 said:
So someone explain this to me, Avasarala has pretty much the highest political position in the government that is obtainable without being elected, which means she doesn't really have to answer to the people or her supporters or whatever giving her real power. But Errinwright is still her boss and anything she does would look like it was done with Errinwright's approval (who has to answer to others), yet she seems to have power over him and tells him what to do and not.

Why is that?
Click to expand...

She basically went around Errinwright on the Eros Incident and now the Secretary General seems to trust her judgement more than his.
 
S

Sir Doom

Member
I missed yesterday's episode. Is it Direct Tv now or SYFY scheduling sometimes the show starts at 7pm or 8pm

not bad episode. Was expecting full flashback of what happened previous episode
 
J

Jackpot

Banned
DevilDog said:
Godammit stop defending this already. Thankfully it's spoiled tagged now.
Click to expand...

Those 2 quotes from 1 episode =

"It was sent to hijack life on our planet for its own ends.....eons ago."

ergo, not humans. Simple reasoning. Deliberately not quoting what I posted doesn't change anything.
 
Moff

Moff

Member
Jackpot said:
Those 2 quotes from 1 episode =

"It was sent to hijack life on our planet for its own ends.....eons ago."

ergo, not humans. Simple reasoning. Deliberately not quoting what I posted doesn't change anything.
Click to expand...
Come on dude, you said that
the proto-molecule was sent to hijack single-cell lifeforms, not sentient beings.

That simply never happened in the show.
Take the L and move on.
 
M

Morts

Member
Is there a reason they didn't get that Mormon ship back after it didn't hit Eros? I'd think if they could intercept the missiles the could intercept that.

It'll be interesting to see where Bobbie's story goes on Earth.
 
Backlogger

Backlogger

Member
Morts said:
Is there a reason they didn't get that Mormon ship back after it didn't hit Eros? I'd think if they could intercept the missiles the could intercept that.

It'll be interesting to see where Bobbie's story goes on Earth.
Click to expand...

Bobby is my favorite character that isn't part of the main "crew". When it comes to character building I feel at least from the book perspective that maybe outside of Miller they did the best job with her character. Hopefully it translates well into the show.
 
D

Dubbedinenglish

Banned
Morts said:
Is there a reason they didn't get that Mormon ship back after it didn't hit Eros? I'd think if they could intercept the missiles the could intercept that.

It'll be interesting to see where Bobbie's story goes on Earth.
Click to expand...

Would they have enough fuel and the speed/mass of the Navoo would make it hard to do an abrupt stop. Nukes were small enough to slow and catch but I'd think you'd need some large orbits to bring around the Navoo.
 
P

Palmer_v1

Member
Dubbedinenglish said:
Would they have enough fuel and the speed/mass of the Navoo would make it hard to do an abrupt stop. Nukes were small enough to slow and catch but I'd think you'd need some large orbits to bring around the Navoo.
Click to expand...

The Nauvoo isnt really designed for major course corrections, which is why they had to use a bunch of little ships to even point it towards Eros to begin with.. It's whole trick is that it spends half a journey accelerating at full burn, then flips itself around midway, and does a full burn to decelerate for the entire second half.

That said, I'm not sure what it's fueling status was, but it could theoretically be flipped around and eventually return.
 
F

Freeza Under The Shower

Member
Morts said:
Is there a reason they didn't get that Mormon ship back after it didn't hit Eros? I'd think if they could intercept the missiles the could intercept that.

It'll be interesting to see where Bobbie's story goes on Earth.
Click to expand...

Well, it's trajectory was towards the sun, so theoretically that's where the Navoo should still be going right now. It's kind of weird that they didn't mention briefly what happened to it at the ending montage of episode 6.

However, I do love that it was immediately missing from Tycho station in the opening of episode 7 and 8. Seriously, that opening with its "passing of time" deserves more love.
 
J

Jackpot

Banned
Moff said:
Come on dude, you said that
the proto-molecule was sent to hijack single-cell lifeforms, not sentient beings.

That simply never happened in the show.
Take the L and move on.
Click to expand...

Which was the only life around when Saturn captured Phoebe. Unless you're demanding the show spoon-feed you which is just bad writing. The opening episode from S2 explicitly states that the protomolecule was sent eons ago to hijack life on Earth. You can't argue with direct quotes from the show. It's child's play to work out.
 
DevilDog

DevilDog

Member
So in book terms, where are we at so far? As of ep.7.

Jackpot said:
Which was the only life around when Saturn captured Phoebe. Unless you're demanding the show spoon-feed you which is just bad writing. The opening episode from S2 explicitly states that the protomolecule was sent eons ago to hijack life on Earth. You can't argue with direct quotes from the show. It's child's play to work out.
Click to expand...

plz-stop-post.jpg


This is starting to get sad. Come on.
 
Moff

Moff

Member
Jackpot said:
Which was the only life around when Saturn captured Phoebe. Unless you're demanding the show spoon-feed you which is just bad writing. The opening episode from S2 explicitly states that the protomolecule was sent eons ago to hijack life on Earth. You can't argue with direct quotes from the show. It's child's play to work out.
Click to expand...

You are assuming that whoever sent the protomolecule here, knew there would be no sentients around and we don't have any evidence that that's the case. We have no evidence that it was only supposed to hijack single cell organisms from the show.
 
J

jelly

Member
Korey said:
I've been trying to get into this show but I'm having trouble following and it's not super compelling so far.

Some of the scenes and dialogue are confusing and I have no idea what's going on other than some broad strokes.

Does it get better or should I stop?

I'm on season 1 episode 6.
Click to expand...

Stick with it, I felt a bit unengaged and lost until I got use to the factions and characters. It ends great and season 2 is sweet so far.
 
N

nOoblet16

Member
Backlogger said:
Bobby is my favorite character that isn't part of the main "crew". When it comes to character building I feel at least from the book perspective that maybe outside of Miller they did the best job with her character. Hopefully it translates well into the show.
Click to expand...
I bet she'll end up with the team, no other reason to introduce her like than and have her squad be killed. The Rocinate team is pretty small right now with only 4 people and with Miller gone there isn't enough dynamics in there. Plus everyone gets along well so having a Martian who was fed Martian propaganda all her life would shake things up a bit.


danm999 said:
She basically went around Errinwright on the Eros Incident and now the Secretary General seems to trust her judgement more than his.
Click to expand...
Yea but even before that incident she basically told Errinwright to get his shit together when she told him she knows he is working with Mao. That sort of behaviour from a subordinate is odd. It feels like she is the one with real power and what she says and do matters more than anyone else.
 
C

Cornballer

Member
- Salt Lake Tribune: Syfy’s ‘Expanse’ goes by the books (interview with Abraham and Franck about the tv show & book series)
Readers will find the Syfy series instantly recognizable.

"It's been faithful in some ways," Abraham said. "We've made a lot of changes to the plot. Things happen in different orders. There are characters who don't exist. There are characters we've added.

"The thing that we've tried not to compromise is the spirit of the story."
Click to expand...
Franck said Shankar's "attitude is — if you buy something that's popular, there's a reason. Messing with it just screws that up. Some Hollywood writers have this attitude that they're going to buy a property and then they're going to fix it. And what they generally wind up doing is breaking all the things that made it popular to begin with."

Which is not to say that "The Expanse" looks the same onscreen as what Abraham and Franck imagined when they wrote the books.

"Of course not," Franck said. " I'm not a spaceship designer or a costume designer or a set builder."

When he conceived this solar system for a role-playing game and when he and Abraham were writing the books, he had a "pretty minimalist version of what things look like in my head. And the professional designers took those ideas and "added their flair to them."

"So of course it's going to be different. But in nearly every case, it's also better."
Click to expand...
 
K

Killthee

helped a brotha out on multiple separate occasions!
Freeza Under The Shower said:
Well, it's trajectory was towards the sun, so theoretically that's where the Navoo should still be going right now. It's kind of weird that they didn't mention briefly what happened to it at the ending montage of episode 6.

However, I do love that it was immediately missing from Tycho station in the opening of episode 7 and 8. Seriously, that opening with its "passing of time" deserves more love.
Click to expand...
Had no idea they were doing that cause SyFy doesn't air it. The full intro has only popped up twice during the SyFy broadcast, once last season and again at the start of this season. Every other episode just has a short 4 second title screen.
 
T

tearsintherain

Member
For any fans of the show I recommend the podcast The Churn, cast and crew from the show appear on it regularly and its pretty interesting. They had Thomas Jane on for an interview last week, and the creators of the show for the Home episode podcast and Ty/Daniel said something that I always thought was weird about the show but didn't really connect the dots.

The final thing Julie Mao said to Miller :)"you belong with me") is something he had mentioned to Naomi in episode 1 as something the imaginary Julie said to him. The scenes of the bird that always lead Miller to Julie, plus the scene in season 1 where Julie imagines the bird and Miller approaching as she dies. Well, its all apparently hints that the protomolecule can somehow also have minor impacts on the past....

I download the podcast automatically via my phone podcast manager, but its on itunes, google play, etc or on the syfy website
http://www.blastr.com/2017-2-22/churn-episode-4-emotional-reunion-takes-center-stage-home
 
T

Tunesmith

formerly "chigiri"
Freeza Under The Shower said:
Well, it's trajectory was towards the sun, so theoretically that's where the Navoo should still be going right now. It's kind of weird that they didn't mention briefly what happened to it at the ending montage of episode 6.

However, I do love that it was immediately missing from Tycho station in the opening of episode 7 and 8. Seriously, that opening with its "passing of time" deserves more love.
Click to expand...

Killthee said:
Had no idea they were doing that cause SyFy doesn't air it. The full intro has only popped up twice during the SyFy broadcast, once last season and again at the start of this season. Every other episode just has a short 4 second title screen.
Click to expand...

Mars' moon Deimos is also a debris field in the opening sequence now.
 
G

geestack

Member
so i'm behind on this, but i started watching s1 yesterday and i'm hooked. trying to get all caught up for s2, but man i hope this show has a long life.

i'm legit shocked at how decent the production is for syfy? i mean, ep4 in season 1 was a nail biter.
 
C

Cornballer

Member
tearsintherain said:
For any fans of the show I recommend the podcast The Churn, cast and crew from the show appear on it regularly and its pretty interesting. They had Thomas Jane on for an interview last week, and the creators of the show for the Home episode podcast and Ty/Daniel said something that I always thought was weird about the show but didn't really connect the dots.

The final thing Julie Mao said to Miller :)"you belong with me") is something he had mentioned to Naomi in episode 1 as something the imaginary Julie said to him. The scenes of the bird that always lead Miller to Julie, plus the scene in season 1 where Julie imagines the bird and Miller approaching as she dies. Well, its all apparently hints that the protomolecule can somehow also have minor impacts on the past....

I download the podcast automatically via my phone podcast manager, but its on itunes, google play, etc or on the syfy website
http://www.blastr.com/2017-2-22/churn-episode-4-emotional-reunion-takes-center-stage-home
Click to expand...
I like the podcast. They have good guests (typically actors) along with the writers on every week, and it's informative. The Thomas Jane interview was highly entertaining - he's an odd guy. My only complaint about this, and other 'official' podcasts is that there's no criticism at all. It makes sense since they're talking with people that work on it, but they are unrelentingly positive about the material. The flipside is that they do have access to interesting people that probably wouldn't talk to a fan or critic run podcast. The special effects talk last week was quite good.
 
C

Cornballer

Member
New episode tonight:
Pyre

As Naomi tracks down signs of the protomolecule in unexpected corners of the solar system, Fred Johnson's control over the OPA begins to collapse. A traumatized refugee from Ganymede may hold the key to finding a new threat.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Sweet Tooth Renewed for Third and Final Season
2
1K
sono replied
Stellar Blade - Launch Trailer
Trailer
42
2K
Ma-Yuan replied
Coming to Xbox Game Pass in February: Bluey: The Videogame, Tales of Arise, Warhammer 40,000: Boltgun, and More
Hype Platform 2
69
4K
Magic Carpet replied
The Expanse, followed by the shrinking..
43
8K
The Sum of Zero replied
Starfield Devs Q&A Session
37
3K
Hendrick's replied
Top Bottom