I don't doubt there is some value here, to upgrade from normal Plus to Extra to get some of these games that are still quite decent price to buy on their own is very good. But the delivery and execution of this service is so messy. The lists have games that double up, we are uncertain of how this is going to work, how long some of these titles will remain on there before being taken off and substituted with crappy ones like we get in free monthly Plus games. You're also locked in for a year. It's just not as attractive as gamepass except for the fact that you have some really good 1st party bangers. But for the average PlayStation gamer that has already played most of these titles, its a little average. Also, Sony are not doing this for the consumer, it's purely because they are trying to compete with gamepass because it has gained big momentum, otherwise Sony would not give a fuck.