lightskintwin
Banned
Emma got Mulan on lock.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Aladdin controversy Disney can't escape
- Thread starter lightskintwin
- Start date
Emma got Mulan on lock.
D
Deleted member 465307
Unconfirmed Member
If the meaaure of "castability" were only based on performance, I would say that I feel that Emma Watson unfortunately set a low bar for their future films. So I agree with you there. That said, Emma Watson is obviously quite famous and popular in major markets, so that was on her side.
If they're casting an actor who is relatively unknown when compared to Emma Watson, they'll definitely need someone whose performance carries the role. That said, I find it ridiculous they haven't been able to find someone.
Man Cumberbatch playing Khan made me so sad. Cause on one hand he is a good actor but on the other he's like one of the whitest actors out there. Can't even pass him up as a half white dude because of that.And introducing Tilda Swinton, as Aladdin
No, let's not do that again...
The fact that this is called "Aladdin" will carry them to a big box-office.
They don't need a star, they can make one.
DarkJediKnight
Member
That thoroughly pissed me off! Especially since they establish right at the begining of the movie what an INDIAN person looks like. WTF!
Fancyarcher
Member
I'm sure Guy Ritchie will just listen to what Disney says, otherwise he'll probably get fired. I doubt he has free reign anyway.
Do they? I can't remember Into Darkness properly, who are you talking about?
As if Hollywood gives a shit
By that definition Sylvester Stallone Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jackie Chan still wouldn't get work. Its an unreasonable standard. Its fairly easy to teach an athletic person to dance and a charismatic person to act.
With over 1 billion people in eastern Asia its highly unlikely that thousands of people don't fit that description.
Nostremitus
Member
Is the dude from the Best Exotic Merigold Hotel too old?
Hell, the love interest from that movie could easily play Jasmine...
... Unless they are too old now...
Aladdin was set in Asia... So... They should be Indian, not middle Eastern anyway.
Hell, the love interest from that movie could easily play Jasmine...
... Unless they are too old now...
Aladdin was set in Asia... So... They should be Indian, not middle Eastern anyway.
John Dunbar
correct about everything
still surprised disney got away with whitewashing dr. strange to please the chinese, but that's marvel fans for you. aladdin i suppose would be a bridge too far even for them so they can't go down that route.
hodayathink
Member
From the last thread about this, a combination of him possibly being too old and maybe, just maybe, that he and/or Riz Ahmed don't actually want to do it?
And that's ignoring the fact that maybe they want to find someone they can pay a lot less than those two.
DiipuSurotu
Banned
Shraddha Kapoor. Great choice for Jasmine. She reminds me of an Indian Daenarys Targaryan. lol
Do it, Disney!
What about the dude from Life of Pi? Suraj Sharma?
That's what I'm wondering, why he wasn't picked.
He must've been a consideration surely as he is a well known actor.
Dev Patel? He's 27.
That's what I'm wondering, why he wasn't picked.
He must've been a consideration surely as he is a well known actor.
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
Aladdin, the movie that opens with a song called Arabian Nights and borrows heavily from Arab culture, should have its leads played by Indian actors rather than Middle Eastern. Of course.
Then it was odd choice to quote that post
If Disney is looking to cast a famous person Bruno Mars is the obvious choice.
Sure he's philipino but (being cynical) the majority of the internet/society isn't going to complain about a famous minority singer/dancer with the right look being cast as a middle eastern character.
Mars is a young looking 31 and considering that Disney cast an almost 40 year old Luke Evans to play Gaston (early 20s) in Beauty and the Beast thats a non issue.
Sure he's philipino but (being cynical) the majority of the internet/society isn't going to complain about a famous minority singer/dancer with the right look being cast as a middle eastern character.
Mars is a young looking 31 and considering that Disney cast an almost 40 year old Luke Evans to play Gaston (early 20s) in Beauty and the Beast thats a non issue.
He's 27 though, unless they want someone 18-20 he isn't really old for this. But yea he would be expensive as he is a proven name so I doubt Disney can get away with paying him a low salary and have him take bonus from earnings instead like they did for Star Wars characters.
lightskintwin
Banned
But he looks the part.
A lot of mixed races can pass as Arab/Middle Eastern/North African/Hispanic/Latino/Polynesian/Native American even light skinned African Americans.
Hell, The Rock could fit right in Agribah.
Well Agribah is a desert surely it'll have rocks around.
Discotheque
Banned
That mediocre crap is striking gold now?
King Arthur was pretty bad but I still think Ritchie is inspired choice for aladdin considering the whole street thief backstory. Lock stock the shit out of that script I hope.
But yeah to hell with Disney if they go white with this.
The first thing they went wrong on is getting Guy Ritchie to be the one to pull this all together.
King Arthur bombing should have been enough to get Disney worried about his take on a "historical fantasy" (doesn't accurately describe Aladdin, but I think historical accuracy will end up having to play some roll) franchise, but, yeah, even without that, I have no idea why Guy Ritchie of all people would sound like a good idea to handle a film that they need a sensitive cultural reevaluation of the original film for Disney to pull off in live action.
King Arthur bombing should have been enough to get Disney worried about his take on a "historical fantasy" (doesn't accurately describe Aladdin, but I think historical accuracy will end up having to play some roll) franchise, but, yeah, even without that, I have no idea why Guy Ritchie of all people would sound like a good idea to handle a film that they need a sensitive cultural reevaluation of the original film for Disney to pull off in live action.
OG Shaka Zulu
Member
Have Hugh Jackman get a bronze tan and give him the role already.
DarkJediKnight
Member
It feels increasingly like this is exactly what they are going to do.
Easier said than done, given Hollywood's history of whitewashing.
Discotheque
Banned
Wut? Point out one thing she said that was objectionable in her comments in the OP
Poor GRIMES
Banned
It grossed $966M, 5th highest gross of the year, had an opening weekend of over $100M when predictions were in the $70M range, and has a 95% on RT.
Yes....they struck gold with it lol
Discotheque
Banned
Oh right haha. Taken literally yeah they definitely struck gold with that one
Sunster
Member
The same news that said that Disney is struggling to find an actor also said that they're eyeing newcomers so her whole argument doesn't really apply here
They must not have changed that lyric on all home video releases. Because I know I never saw the movie in theaters, but I definitely remember the original lyric on my copy growing up.
I mean, just direct them like the human beings they are. Doesn't seem like an innate obstacle.
She's in the movie for all of five seconds. Her husband is a British black dude who actually has more than a bit part, so we can be forgiven for forgetting who you were referring to.
Probably more expensive than they want. Disney's hit paydirt recently snapping up young and cheap actors, and I doubt they want to break with that.
I mean, just direct them like the human beings they are. Doesn't seem like an innate obstacle.
You don't remember this scene with the indian family and the girl dying?
She's in the movie for all of five seconds. Her husband is a British black dude who actually has more than a bit part, so we can be forgiven for forgetting who you were referring to.
Probably more expensive than they want. Disney's hit paydirt recently snapping up young and cheap actors, and I doubt they want to break with that.
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
I just have this feeling that the Disney Mulan will be all Chinese cast, but the Sony Pictures one is going to pepper some White folks in there. The Sony version is a Chinese co-production, so I'm sure they'll push their hottest Chinese talent for the lead, but they're going to be chasing that Hollywood legitimacy ala The Great Wall.
Zvonimir Boban
Banned
I quoted a post that talked about accents in a thread full of people bringing up Bollywood.
Is it really that odd?
Come on bruv.
lightskintwin
Banned
I did not know Sony was making their own version. I'm curious who's is going to finish and release first, because it'll consequently push back the other film the way Disney's Jungle Book release has pushed back Warner Brother's Jungle Book, despite it already being filmed, to next year.
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
"Can't teach an old dog new tricks." I genuinely don't think he's capable of approaching it that way. It's not like he's some hot new writer/director, we have two decades worth of material from him. Women get raped and brutalized, the guys are macho gangsters. That's all he does.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
Neither is the acting.
DrForester
Kills Photobucket
Meh why not. Are we gonna exclude persians from playing arabs too.
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
How do you think the Persian community would feel about an Arab playing a Persian?
Goes the other way too.
Kingpin Rogers
Member
Can they speak good english though? I personally have no idea.
