Mochilador
Member
That fucking poll. 
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Cyberpunk 2077 - Review Thread
- Thread starter JORMBO
- Start date
Kuranghi
Member
This can also be used as a pixel refresher for OLEDs.
Stuart360
Member
So from skimming over the reviews, it seems that the concensous is that its an amazing game, but riddled with bugs, and some reviews are marking it down because of those bugs, while some reviews are basically ignoring the bugs and marking it for the game it is, or will be after the bugs are fixed?.
Dont know which angle i prefer, but anyway the game seems to be great overall.
Dont know which angle i prefer, but anyway the game seems to be great overall.
AutumnLeaves
Member
Apparently no one cares about performance on consoles.
sgstein
Neo Member
Hey guys! Am new here bc the other forum kinda annoyed me af and that says much bc im mostly just a lurker but sheeesh. Tf. Cant even read some nice posts in peace without getting bashed by random avatars that want to make everyone feel bad abt playing this game.
Anyway!
Gamestar (german) posted a nice rewiew and gave it a 91 since some gamplay features may not be for everyone but overall they think its one of the best.
One guy who self admittedly doesnt like "hype games" and didnt play TLOU 2 or even RDR2 yet had this to say:
Cyberpunk 2077 couldn't have had a harder time capturing my heart. And now I'll have a closer look: As soon as this test ends, I'll sleep through the day for a day - and then start a second round of the game. Because I love Cyberpunk 2077. So. I said it. CD Projekt Cyberpunk-Epos gets the highest rating from me that I have personally ever given in my GameStar career. Because I actually only pull out the platinum award if I can really recommend a game without reservation.
And I can. Yes, Cyberpunk 2077 sometimes plays bumpy, the loot system is annoying, stealth has been smoother - but I am absolutely convinced that if you embark on this adventure, you will sit there after the credits and whisper a "wow" into you . So not World of Warcraft, the other "Wow". Cyberpunk 2077 burns itself into your head like a biochip, it echoes in your memory, in your imagination, you want to talk about it all the time.
For me, video games are always the most magical when they tear people out of their routine, move them, surprise them, take them on a virtual trip that they can't get anywhere in the real world. Cyberpunk doesn't give a damn about open world stuff, storytelling off the shelf, soulless popcorn spectacle - it exceeds my expectations in every second quest, surprises me, provokes me, doesn't care about comfort. It shows how games can be too.
For anyone interested to read it via a translator, here you go!
Gamestar Review 91
Anyway!
Gamestar (german) posted a nice rewiew and gave it a 91 since some gamplay features may not be for everyone but overall they think its one of the best.
One guy who self admittedly doesnt like "hype games" and didnt play TLOU 2 or even RDR2 yet had this to say:
Cyberpunk 2077 couldn't have had a harder time capturing my heart. And now I'll have a closer look: As soon as this test ends, I'll sleep through the day for a day - and then start a second round of the game. Because I love Cyberpunk 2077. So. I said it. CD Projekt Cyberpunk-Epos gets the highest rating from me that I have personally ever given in my GameStar career. Because I actually only pull out the platinum award if I can really recommend a game without reservation.
And I can. Yes, Cyberpunk 2077 sometimes plays bumpy, the loot system is annoying, stealth has been smoother - but I am absolutely convinced that if you embark on this adventure, you will sit there after the credits and whisper a "wow" into you . So not World of Warcraft, the other "Wow". Cyberpunk 2077 burns itself into your head like a biochip, it echoes in your memory, in your imagination, you want to talk about it all the time.
For me, video games are always the most magical when they tear people out of their routine, move them, surprise them, take them on a virtual trip that they can't get anywhere in the real world. Cyberpunk doesn't give a damn about open world stuff, storytelling off the shelf, soulless popcorn spectacle - it exceeds my expectations in every second quest, surprises me, provokes me, doesn't care about comfort. It shows how games can be too.
For anyone interested to read it via a translator, here you go!
Gamestar Review 91
Bryank75
Banned
LectureMaster
Member
Fuck the mods on Reset Era, are they really play games? I remember someone got banned by literally saying "I just want to discuss games here".
Soapy Wooder
Member
I voted yes. I hate all this happiness and gaming interestThat fucking poll.
Yong Yea mentioned that there will be one more patch on release in his review.
Kuranghi
Member
I don't expect "perfect lighting" ofc but it looks like tons of graphics are missing to me, its not just a few items, basically everything in the whole scene looks lifeless and flat in a way that other open world games with RTX don't. I'd like to see more footage before I make a final decision but thats not good imo.
DonJorginho
Banned
Multiple reviewers have said they only have part of the day one patch.
Stop spreading your fake news.
Pakoe
Member
Airbus Jr
Banned
Cyberpunk 2077 reviews that highlight the transphobia issues
Cyberpunk 2077 Kallie Plagge at Gamespot: Carolyn Petite at Polygon: Gene Park at The Washington Post: Rob Zacny at Waypoint: Metacritic: think for yourself and engage critically with your entertainment instead of caring about an arbitrary aggregate score for once in your life Please...
www.resetera.com
Transphob!
Transphobia!
Transphob!
Transphobia!
Transphob !
Transphobia !
Last edited:
sobaka770
Banned
I am not sure even reviewers know what a day 1 patch is. Apparently there was a 43Gb patch but it may not be the last one before the game officially is available on the 10th.
It's a bit crazy that the game is in such a state but also they had almost a year of delay - the ambition is clearly huge from the studio.
I'm happy to see good reviews, I hope that the team that crunched so hard made a product of a lifetime and gets deserved rest and bonuses they were promised. Took 2 days off, will have to make a pause in my AC Valhalla playthrough but oh-so-ready!
ALSO: So there's no official review thread on ERA to continue watchting the meltdown? Only the one with trans-issues? I guess that'll do. (trans rights are important, just not the reee kind of insanity)
Last edited:
Kuranghi
Member
Yup, its back to Ghost of TemTem for me.
CaptainConlock
Member
I think the criticisms of representation are valid, be it gender or race, but I don't think it should be the deciding factor in the game's review. People aren't buying this game to see how certain groups are represented, they just want to know how the RPG experience is. I think the game is pretty juvenile and immature when it comes to the representation, but maybe that was the intention. It's difficult to know with CDPR. Aside from that, this looks like a solid game overall.
Marcus Aurelius
Banned
Resetera is that way sir/madame/mam/xir or whatever the fck you want to be called.
That's what i thought, but what about this:
There are 2 patches and much confusion.
ethomaz
Banned
The review thread there is like the one here... 10/10 first... 7-6/10 bottom.
I really didn't see any issue there.
I don't believe it is real.
Cyberpunk 2077 reviews/impressions thread
Windows Central: 10/10 M3: 10/10 The Gamer: 10/10 VG274: 10/10 VGC: 10/10 GameSpew: 10/10 Stevior: 9.5/10 Press Start: 9/10 GameInformer: 9/10 RPG Site: 9/10 Screenrant: 8/10 Trusted Reviews: 8/10 PCGamer: 7.8/10 Gamespot: 7/10 Gamesbeat: 6/10 GiantBomb: Unscored...
www.resetera.com
Last edited:
Coolwhhip
Neophyte
Good job on leaving the 'woke' suicide cult.
Leyasu
Banned
I don't have a PC that can run this... I am not a Playstation owner. Reading various forums over the years, it seems that they are the only console gamers that do.
Saber
Member
Rikkori
Member
Kinda looks like shit tbh, did they forget to turn on AO in the off picture? Ffs we've had HBAO+ for years, it's way better than that. No GI either?? Fookin' 'ell, gonna have to reshade this bitch won't I at least until the patch hits and I can turn on that RTDI. These fuckers...
Kuranghi
Member
I think the way to counter that is to say "okay lets talk seriously about gender for hours" and you start bringing out all these scientific journals and data sets to back up what you're going to say and they just have a postit note with "CIS BAHD, TRANS GUD" written on it.
Astorian
Member
There are still +70 reviews to come after launch btw so the current score can and will change.
The point is, reviewers didn’t shy away from calling the game out for being a buggy mess, the quality of the game shouldn’t dictate it.
Thanks for the info.
Thaedolus
Gold Member
From what the Jeffs said:
-interesting merging of a Deux Ex/GTA/Fallout style game, right down to every mission seeming to have an option for whatever your spec is
-still quite janky and Gerstmann avoids cars because the FPS takes a huge hit
-dialogue is a little unnatural, almost like auto-translated at some point
-story is good enough to keep them interested
-lots of dildos everywhere for some reason
Sounds like it's a good idea to manage expectations but it's fun. My preload just started.
-interesting merging of a Deux Ex/GTA/Fallout style game, right down to every mission seeming to have an option for whatever your spec is
-still quite janky and Gerstmann avoids cars because the FPS takes a huge hit
-dialogue is a little unnatural, almost like auto-translated at some point
-story is good enough to keep them interested
-lots of dildos everywhere for some reason
Sounds like it's a good idea to manage expectations but it's fun. My preload just started.
Coolwhhip
Neophyte
"Are you winning son?"
"Yes dad, I'm am a transgender activist on a videogame forum."
"Son..."
"No dad, it's daughter now, I finally figured out why girls don't want me."
"..."
Last edited:
BertleTheTurtle
Member
What's pretty funny is reviewers whining about sexualizing in a cyberpunk game.
Dampf
Member
Nah, the game has nice AO and GI, it is evident in many screenshots without RTX and even in the console footage. It's just that its hard to have perfect GI and AO everywhere in a giant open world, that's the negative of pre-baking light. It happens automatically with RTX so every possible scene is perfectly lit.Kinda looks like shit tbh, did they forget to turn on AO in the off picture? Ffs we've had HBAO+ for years, it's way better than that. No GI either?? Fookin' 'ell, gonna have to reshade this bitch won't I at least until the patch hits and I can turn on that RTDI. These fuckers...
GaviotaGrande
Banned
Add 5/6 pointes that were lost due to transphobia and not enough woke shite in the game and you'll get the full picture. Game will be a masterpiece.
TintoConCasera
I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
That Resetera thread... Holy shit.
It's like a modern version of the nazis burning books which they didn't find suitable to their tastes.
It's like a modern version of the nazis burning books which they didn't find suitable to their tastes.
ethomaz
Banned
Now I see but that is not the review thread.Cyberpunk 2077 reviews that highlight the transphobia issues
Cyberpunk 2077 Kallie Plagge at Gamespot: Carolyn Petite at Polygon: Gene Park at The Washington Post: Rob Zacny at Waypoint: Metacritic: think for yourself and engage critically with your entertainment instead of caring about an arbitrary aggregate score for once in your life Please...
Transphob!
Transphobia!
Transphob!
Transphobia!
Transphob !
Transphobia !
The review thread there is like the one here.
Last edited:
ruvikx
Banned
It's like the only AAA video game I've ever seen which allows the player to create chicks-with-dicks. Yet we're in a weird alternate reality where there see this as a product of "transphobes".
Okay.
ThisIsMyDog
Member
When CDP delivered another great polish game
inb4. polish but unpolished.
inb4. polish but unpolished.
Coolwhhip
Neophyte
Nazis had actual men, men that weren't too scared to leave their parents house. So we don't have to worry.