-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Cyberpunk 2077 - Review Thread
- Thread starter JORMBO
- Start date
captainnapalm
Member
So, we were discussing that specific aspect of the review. Most of the reviews absolutely praise the world building and side quests, by the way.
bender
What time is it?
It conclusively needed more time in the oven.
Kadayi
Banned
Overall very good marred by some bugginess but reviews it seems were done prior to the day 1 patch so there may be updates to scores. 91 now, so they didn't seem to bother most reviewers all that much. Read, watch, digest yourself though.
Last edited:
Kuranghi
Member
Cyberpunk 2077 PC Benchmarks, Settings, and Performance Analysis
We've tested Cyberpunk 2077 on a bunch of GPUs to see how it runs. Spoiler: It's very demanding.www.tomshardware.com
Nothing then. 11.4 fps on a 3 month old, £700 GPU.
Maybe the 3090 can get to 30 with a small settings reduction.
I'm still thinking there is someone weird going on though, figures are too low for the total package presented imo.
YuLY
Member
In my opinion, yes my opinion, that shouldnt be there in the first place. I dont care if its mentioned only 1 time or 10, it shouldnt be there. Also fun how you leave out exactly the Polygon review which talks about that the most. But hey you need to defend them so you chose the parts that help your view.
What does an ad with a female/android with a dildo or a guy who was even fired from their twitter making a stupid joke, has anything to do with the actual game?? How does that talk about the quality of the game, why does it need to even be in the review? Huh ? Maybe I'm too stupid to understand and I need your progressive ascended mind to englighten me.
Infested Goblin
Member
It looks like this game will be a masterpiece but in a month or two after some patches because now the greatness is covered by a mess of a bugs
Bboy AJ
My dog was murdered by a 3.5mm audio port and I will not rest until the standard is dead
Oh wow. Thanks for this. Well, in a way, I'm happy there's a game pushing systems this hard. But, at the same time, it doesn't look mind blowingly amazing. Gonna dig through these benchmarks a little more.
Kadayi
Banned
I'd wait until the games out, the inevitable New Drivers for it have landed and other sites have benched it
captainnapalm
Member
You know, you could easily see that ad as a positive for representation, because in a sense the game is saying that in the future even trans people are happily exploited on billboards, just like men and women are today. In other words, they've become so commonplace and accepted in the culture, that you can use them to sell a soft drink.
So what I'm saying is the scenario you created is a total false equivalency.
Dampf
Member
Yeah, almost certainly some bugs cause performance issues.
Nothing then. 11.4 fps on a 3 month old, £700 GPU.
Maybe the 3090 can get to 30 with a small settings reduction.
I'm still thinking there is someone weird going on though, figures are too low for the total package presented imo.
Performance might see a big improvement with the Day 1 patch and drivers.
Chris Walken
Neo Member
Looks like the game delivers A LOT.
Main problems are about glitches all around and performance issues.
I'm not going to talk about trans or crunch fuckshit, those resetera bastards can lick my dick.
Main problems are about glitches all around and performance issues.
I'm not going to talk about trans or crunch fuckshit, those resetera bastards can lick my dick.
Infested Goblin
Member
CloudNull
Banned
People just need to read the first paragraph:
However, there's a major disclaimer: This is near-final code, but CDPR has been working on bug fixes, tuning, and optimization for the past couple of weeks. AMD and Nvidia are also working on driver improvements, and the preview copy includes Denuvo protection. That could impact CPU performance in particular, which is why this is a preview of how the game runs. The final release code should perform at least this well, and hopefully a bit better.
It is running Denuvo which has always tanked performance and not even the optimized builds. I bet the benchmarks will be much better.
If someone disagrees with your criticism will you eventually fuck off and leave them be, or will you do all you can to destroy their life for defying you?
Bydimension
Member
Well, count me as another one of the many users who has come here from Resetera just because I wanna discuss about videogames on a goddamn videogame forum, and especially to chat about one of the most hyped games of this generation alongside its mechanics, peacefully, without harassment, labellings and bullies to people who just wanna fucking play videogames and inmerse themselves, some even do it to just get a chance to forget about their real life problems for a moment..
As side note: i got tired of the all "offensiveness" coming from Resetera, It's become a total mess full of hypocrisy on every corner.; And I can totally say this as a person who basically "Hates Trump", and who's had a serious relationship with a transgender woman in the past, a woman who has all my respect as a person, including any member of the trans community.
You see, I just cannot relate with the transphobia issue claims ( I'm pretty sure, some trans membera cannot either; including trans members known to be working on the game at CDPR). We are talking about a world that was created in the 80s which pretty much tales about the dark future. Obviously, fuck up shit is being displayed all over the place. violence, sexualized ads for all genders, augmentations of all types, decadence, oppression, drugs, inequality, smuggling etc, etc. WTF were some offended expecting to see in this game??
Anyway, I'm looking forward to play this game at launch. Although I will be playing Cyberpunk my on base PS4, and I'm a bit worried about its actual state after the day one patch.
As side note: i got tired of the all "offensiveness" coming from Resetera, It's become a total mess full of hypocrisy on every corner.; And I can totally say this as a person who basically "Hates Trump", and who's had a serious relationship with a transgender woman in the past, a woman who has all my respect as a person, including any member of the trans community.
You see, I just cannot relate with the transphobia issue claims ( I'm pretty sure, some trans membera cannot either; including trans members known to be working on the game at CDPR). We are talking about a world that was created in the 80s which pretty much tales about the dark future. Obviously, fuck up shit is being displayed all over the place. violence, sexualized ads for all genders, augmentations of all types, decadence, oppression, drugs, inequality, smuggling etc, etc. WTF were some offended expecting to see in this game??
Anyway, I'm looking forward to play this game at launch. Although I will be playing Cyberpunk my on base PS4, and I'm a bit worried about its actual state after the day one patch.
Thanatoskaras
Neo Member
The reviewer's name is Shōhei Fujita,he's a writer.
藤田祥平「世界のデザインに対する誹謗」 | ÉKRITS / エクリ
世界を語るための言葉を、文学として極限までデザインする試み。そこで紡がれる言葉は、あらゆる事象を語り尽くすことの不可能性に抗いながら、わたしたちを魅了する。
ekrits.jp
Windom Earle
Member
Nothing then. 11.4 fps on a 3 month old, £700 GPU.
Maybe the 3090 can get to 30 with a small settings reduction.
I'm still thinking there is someone weird going on though, figures are too low for the total package presented imo.
Close to 60fps with Ultra RT and DLSS at 1440p on a 3080 seams "ok" to me. The RT is pretty insane and will be crazy in motion. Lots of sceptics when it comes to RT but I'm a believer since WD: Legion. Only RT reflections but it changes so much. Fucking breakthrough tech IMO.
Last edited:
TheDuskwalker
Member
So basically the same as Witcher 3 again. Great game, but launch performance and glitches hold it back until all major performance patches are out.
SoggyBiscuit
Banned
The book isn't even worth your time, don't bother with the movie.
ethomaz
Banned
I don't think reviewers are removing points due bugs.
MightySquirrel
Banned
Last edited:
B-universe
Banned
IGN Japan doesn't represent Asian people precisely in the same way self-appointed Trans activists on Era do not represent the whole so-called Trans community. IGN Japan review binds no one but their editorial staff. A statement by a member of GAF, a member of ResetEra, binds no one but themselves. Asian people did not elect IGN Japan as their representative. Same applies to activists on Era.
Furthermore, arguments are not automatically right or wrong according to the person who makes them. A Trans person can be wrong about Trans issues, Italians can be right about what's best for Iran, a tall person can potentially know more about the reality short people face than any specific short individual themselves .
But If anyone insists only Trans are allowed or qualified to talk about relevant issues, show them the IGN Japan review. By their own logic, they'll have to concede and dismiss the allegations of racism and Cyberpunk 2077. Or they'll realize their logic is flawed.
Collectivism is a profoundly flawed way of looking at the world.
Furthermore, arguments are not automatically right or wrong according to the person who makes them. A Trans person can be wrong about Trans issues, Italians can be right about what's best for Iran, a tall person can potentially know more about the reality short people face than any specific short individual themselves .
But If anyone insists only Trans are allowed or qualified to talk about relevant issues, show them the IGN Japan review. By their own logic, they'll have to concede and dismiss the allegations of racism and Cyberpunk 2077. Or they'll realize their logic is flawed.
Collectivism is a profoundly flawed way of looking at the world.
Md Ray
Member
So GOG is DRM-free, but what about Steam and Epic versions?
I left Polygon out because it's the only one that actually matched the criticism you were leveraging against the three publications.
. . .and I don't need to defend anyone - I have no stake or stock in the company. Just commenting on obviously kneejerk posts that haven't actually read what they are complaining about.
ChuckeRearmed
Member
Then it makes that he is able quite a literary review. Wish other reviewers could write.
Last edited:
Kiraly
Member
All DRM-free, although GOG is the only one you'll be able to actually run without the need to have the storefront installed on your PC.
Md Ray
Member
Precisely.
captainraincoat
Banned
Hmm I have not browsed reee in a little bit but that post I would not be surprised if it was copy pasted from a mod sticky over there
Windom Earle
Member
Witcher 3 had great performance at launch and not many bugs, at least on PC.
D
Deleted member 801069
Unconfirmed Member
Anyone review this on the xsx? Link?
MiguelItUp
Member
I had a completely opposite experience. Experienced a number of bugs. One of the worst issues I frequently experienced involved me falling through the environment. It happened to me more than it ever did in ANY other open world game I've ever played. Hell, or any other game period. It was so bad that I gave up on it because it was so frustrating.
This was on PC.
Performance was good though, so there's that. But I'm sure we'll see various CP:2077 improvements come launch.
Last edited:
MastAndo
Member
From the Tom's Hardware article;
Nothing then. 11.4 fps on a 3 month old, £700 GPU.
Maybe the 3090 can get to 30 with a small settings reduction.
I'm still thinking there is someone weird going on though, figures are too low for the total package presented imo.
"If you're after smooth 60 fps performance, you're going to need to aim quite a bit higher on the hardware specs (unless the day-0 launch patch provides an unprecedented boost to performance). "
So it sounds like they didn't have any sort of patch applied? A couple of reviewers said that day-0 patch that they applied midway through their playthrough gave noticeable performance improvements. I'm still confused as to the day-0 vs day-1 patch, if they're the same thing, and which of the reviewers/publications had it, and which didn't.
I'm hoping to get 60 fps at 1440p High/Ultra with RT High/Ultra and DLSS on a 2080 Super, so hopefully whatever patch is applied for us on launch will help reach that.
Last edited:
BEATORICHEEEEEE
Neo Member
So, 91 on metacritic for a game full of bugs and some outlets giving the game a bad score because of "trans issues" ?
Must be a masterpiece if it managed to score that high in this situation.
Can't wait.
Must be a masterpiece if it managed to score that high in this situation.
Can't wait.
Last edited:
That is basically why people hate tearing.
It makes games unplayable if happens regularly.
I take bad framerate over these.
Sorry it was a typo... I meant PS4
What? That is not tearing, is a bug
Puncheur
Member
Anyone who has a skidmark next to their name on twitter/twitch is safe to ignore. it used to be that you had to have to actually be someone to get the holy blue skidmark, nowadays any grifter with a couple of thousand followers gets one. It's totally devalued and anyone that treats it as some sign of status signifier is best ignored.
Superkewl
Member
I watched a leaked video where the guy kept getting killed, so he lowered the difficulty and there were 4 levels. It appears to be easy, normal, hard and very hard.
kikonawa
Member
why not? people should stop thinking they "have ' to play at ultra settings..no shame in playing in medium -high mix
ethomaz
Banned
Yeap I know.
It is the same effect as tearing... it cut part of the image making it doesn't fit with the overall scene.
Last edited:
THEAP99
Banned
Here are some games that I've played in recent memory that are bugs galore, hurting the immersive experience games are supposed to provide. It's unacceptable:
- Days Gone
- Witcher 3
- Miles Morales
- FF7R
- Outer Worlds
- Black Ops 4
- Dying Light
It's time to get real.
Especially with the rising price in AAA games, constant immersive breaking bugs are unacceptable and should be factored into all reviews. The fact Cyberpunk is in a near unplayable state and is rated as high as it is pathetic. The fact that Miles Morales & Days Gone launched the way they did is pathetic. It's even more pathetic that 5 years later, I experienced numerous bugs in witcher 3 when I played through it this year. Don't hold your breath for the Cyberpunk bugs to be completely fixed for a while if at all.
This is highly anti-consumer as people with bad wifi or live in a poor country are getting a butchered game right out of the box.
STOP NORMALIZING SLOPPY GAMES
Dusktildawn48
Member
I'll be playing on my TV while sitting on my couch. So I think I'll lock it at max settings 4k30. I need the prettyness and I'm not sure I can get it to 4k60 with my rtx 3080.
Twitter doesn't give out Blue Checkmarks in general anymore certainly not to non-essential folks like journalist/influencers.
