• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

nush

Member
Actually I've never posted in Meta once.
bN3Dtcn.jpg
 
S

SLoWMoTIoN

Unconfirmed Member
I still feel bad about Bar

I try to defuse aggression with comedy or routing the conversation into the person being positive

:( I didn't mean to antagonize him; he was cheeky and fun

Though, in the words of Marshall Mathers, "Bitches, they come, they go"

Dicks out for the rebels

Idk why he'd bitch about a certain member (u) when the worst member on gaf, the mod/mista asslicker has been around for a quite a while. Constantly stalking meta gaf and genuinely being a twat that lies about everything and just screaming for constant attention like his life depended on it. But then again lying comes natural to some of you guys so eh. Comment still stands though, Bar, do not be so trusting of your friends. They thrive on hatred and autism. Not a good combo!

edit : forgot a few words :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

prag16

Banned
Barsinister Barsinister was the guy who made those ultra cringe boomerish doodles right? Haha, yea, someone like that wasn't long for the boards with the new rules in the politics board and attempt for more civility. I'm surprised he lasted more than a few days honestly.
I don't think we need to be dancing on peoples' graves in this thread. Especially those who self-requested the perms. Poor form.
 

haxan7

Volunteered as Tribute
No, rather than add to political discussion in a constructive way he would have rather made personal attacks dressed up as cartoons against people that he disagreed with (or sometimes outright insults). I never responded in kind, but I'll have my laugh at his final temper tantrum.
Careful gentlemen. This is how totalitarian regimes are born.
 

Tschumi

Member
Bar was clearly on his way out.

Sad to see a member from 2008 going ape and flaming out in the fallout of something that's only really been at the forefront of discussion in the last year or two
 

Papa

Banned
Barsinister Barsinister was the guy who made those ultra cringe boomerish doodles right? Haha, yea, someone like that wasn't long for the boards with the new rules in the politics board and attempt for more civility. I'm surprised he lasted more than a few days honestly.

Prime example of mistaking politeness for civility. The raucous dwarves in the tavern swearing their heads off but ultimately getting along are more civil than the sewing circle pretending to like each other while discreetly stabbing each other in the back. By all means, celebrate the dwarves being kicked out of the tavern for getting a bit too tipsy (and their sober mates too on suspicion). Just know that they were the social glue preventing you harpies from eating each other alive.
 
S

SLoWMoTIoN

Unconfirmed Member
The raucous dwarves in the tavern swearing their heads off but ultimately getting along are more civil than the sewing circle pretending to like each other while discreetly stabbing each other in the back. By all means, celebrate the dwarves being kicked out of the tavern for getting a bit too tipsy (and their sober mates too on suspicion). Just know that they were the social glue preventing you harpies from eating each other alive.
See I used to think this of the old crew, was bummed out as they left one by one. Since I enjoyed interacting with them, but that was before I saw discord. Apparently some people just can't tell a person how they feel about one another even thru a computer screen.







VIDEOGAMES
 

ThatGamingDude

I am a virgin
Prime example of mistaking politeness for civility. The raucous dwarves in the tavern swearing their heads off but ultimately getting along are more civil than the sewing circle pretending to like each other while discreetly stabbing each other in the back. By all means, celebrate the dwarves being kicked out of the tavern for getting a bit too tipsy (and their sober mates too on suspicion). Just know that they were the social glue preventing you harpies from eating each other alive.
Where do us chaotic neutral Tieflings stand in this tavern?
I'd also like to go down the route of discussing why harpies are running a bar; folklore wise that's a bit out of character for them. They're more known for abducting people
 
See I used to think this of the old crew, was bummed out as they left one by one. Since I enjoyed interacting with them, but that was before I saw discord. Apparently some people just can't tell a person how they feel about one another even thru a computer screen.







VIDEOGAMES
I hope I made the list of people bitching on Discord.

Terms like flavourless, unambitious and plain are all welcomed.
 

Bernkastel

Ask me about my fanboy energy!
I may have missed it, I haven't seen anything mentioned or discussed, but what happened with -Arcadia- -Arcadia- Did she get banned for something, request a perm or did she just leave without saying anything? I haven't seen her around in ages.
Not interested. The familiar direction this forum is starting down is not what I signed up for.

Some of us don’t need to post porn, burn everything down to the ground, and reeee at Evilore. More time for the real world was something I was needing anyway.

I’ll always love the year+ I spent here and remember it fondly. The sheer idea that I got to become one of the most notable members in a legendary forum is mind-boggling to me, and I will never stop being grateful for it. Likewise to all the friendships made, and conversations had — literal magic. I’m thankful to everyone who made that possible.

I’ll check from time to time, as I never shut the door completely, but this is largely goodbye. Thanks for being amazing.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Thank you for the explanation, Bernkastel Bernkastel .

It's sad so many members have opted out of GAF. I think maybe the last year of the plague magnifies issues people have with GAF. I think since the forced isolation and limited social contact, GAF and other sites have become a more important method of social interaction and some people take it too seriously.
 
Last edited:

oagboghi2

Member
Barsinister Barsinister was the guy who made those ultra cringe boomerish doodles right? Haha, yea, someone like that wasn't long for the boards with the new rules in the politics board and attempt for more civility. I'm surprised he lasted more than a few days honestly.
Why didn't you say this when he was around? Now that he is gone, you found the stones to bother us with your opinion?
 
S

SLoWMoTIoN

Unconfirmed Member
Thank you for the explanation, Bernkastel Bernkastel .

It's sad so many members have opted out of GAF. I think maybe the last year of the plague magnifies issues people have with GAF. I think since the forced isolation and limited social contact, GAF and other sites have become a more important method of social interaction and some people take it too seriously.
I think forced isolation just revealed (some) people's true nature if anything.
 

e&e

Banned
That's fair enough I guess. It's a hot topic I get. I'm just not used to the new rules regarding insults yet I guess. I'm still used to the wild west of the old section.


Cunt, retard, and bitch were mainstays in recent years. I didn't realize "intentionally stupid" crossed the line now. I will adjust my posting. Sorry for the trouble.
I think the problem is there is no transparency to know who also got removed from a thread. I see personal attacks at me in the David Jaffe thread but I don’t even know if those people were reprimanded like I was (even though I didn’t post any personal attacks at people). Maybe there should be “Removed From Thread” type warning message? I think something like this would alleviate some concern (and could show if there is bias from the mods).
 
Last edited:
I think the problem is there is no transparency to know who also got removed from a thread. I see personal attacks at me in the David Jaffe thread but I don’t even know if those people were reprimanded like I was (even though I didn’t post any personal attacks at people). Maybe there should be “Removed From Thread” type warning message? I think something like this would alleviate some concern (and could show if there is bias from the mods).

This is not a bad idea. Flagging a post with a message can make it easier to know if the modes took care of someone that was reported and deserved the reply ban.
 
Yes, it was because it might encourage a dogpiling feedback loop or something along those lines.

That’s fair, it’s just impossible to actually see if the mods took care of someone that’s being problematic in a thread. If feedback isn’t given to those who report it, then it seems like they just moved on to their next target thread.
 

Redneckerz

Those long posts don't cover that red neck boy
Bar and his art will be missed.
You could say he was a valueable member, Bar none.

I see myself out after handing over that terrible Friday night joke that wouldn't even make Gilbert Gottfried squint.
See I used to think this of the old crew, was bummed out as they left one by one. Since I enjoyed interacting with them, but that was before I saw discord. Apparently some people just can't tell a person how they feel about one another even thru a computer screen.
It is a bit loopsided. I find it regrettable that many of the mainline rockstars are hitting the deck primarily of a policy change that essentially boils down to ''be reasonable, be decent, and ultimately - don't be a dick.''

Maybe this is a difficulty given before the changes, doing rather stark callouts was a daily letter from the rockstar's mailbox. That seems to be cut off now - The ''fun'', for lack of a better word, is gone, perhaps.
A lot of vitriol, huh.
I don't know. One thing is for sure - The old guard, or whatever-survived-2017-and-became-top-dawg is silently putting the blinds back in front of their windows (XP, safest OS.) because of the recent policy changes.

Now that impresses me. Before those changes, they were top dawgs with a cause. Greenhorns had to be put in their place, and Nobody_Important Nobody_Important was made more important than the actual Nobody's of GAF.

But now?

They are now lost dawgs without their paws. They can't claw back, because the policy tells them that what once was open, is now closed. Closed being the ability to put greenhorns in their place and Nobody_Important to feel important.

Alas, that seems to be the case here. A silent retreat.

Perhaps a discussion should be had there. Perhaps the once known top-dawgs rather not in potential violation of that policy.

One of the top-dawgs being Papa and perhaps Cunth, that is. Papa's post of today says it in more delicate wording than i could muster - But obviously there is something.

Just my 2 cent's. In today's currency, that amount would be equal to 2 cent's. Just saying.
 

Bitmap Frogs

Mr. Community
You could say he was a valueable member, Bar none.

I see myself out after handing over that terrible Friday night joke that wouldn't even make Gilbert Gottfried squint.

It is a bit loopsided. I find it regrettable that many of the mainline rockstars are hitting the deck primarily of a policy change that essentially boils down to ''be reasonable, be decent, and ultimately - don't be a dick.''

Maybe this is a difficulty given before the changes, doing rather stark callouts was a daily letter from the rockstar's mailbox. That seems to be cut off now - The ''fun'', for lack of a better word, is gone, perhaps.

I don't know. One thing is for sure - The old guard, or whatever-survived-2017-and-became-top-dawg is silently putting the blinds back in front of their windows (XP, safest OS.) because of the recent policy changes.

Now that impresses me. Before those changes, they were top dawgs with a cause. Greenhorns had to be put in their place, and Nobody_Important Nobody_Important was made more important than the actual Nobody's of GAF.

But now?

They are now lost dawgs without their paws. They can't claw back, because the policy tells them that what once was open, is now closed. Closed being the ability to put greenhorns in their place and Nobody_Important to feel important.

Alas, that seems to be the case here. A silent retreat.

Perhaps a discussion should be had there. Perhaps the once known top-dawgs rather not in potential violation of that policy.

One of the top-dawgs being Papa and perhaps Cunth, that is. Papa's post of today says it in more delicate wording than i could muster - But obviously there is something.

Just my 2 cent's. In today's currency, that amount would be equal to 2 cent's. Just saying.

The only thing that matters is that gaf survives and stays economically viable for ownership to keep dealing with us than selling to a clickfarmer. The internet is becoming a hostile place after the big boys took over most of it and it’s become a corporate hellscape.

I went off the rocker in the politics subforum, fine I’m staying out, mostly. I’m going to keep trying to get a community thread stick around for good to help people lay roots here (and yes the promised OT is coming, I took an unexpected 12h shift up the ass today and it derailed my plans, it’ll go up tomorrow instead).

Honestly I think retreating to discords is defeatist and not very productive but what do I know, I’m just a shitposting IT drone that’s way too tired atm.

This entire thing reminds me of the time the last bar in town that allowed people to smoke weed inside back when tobacco was already verboten indoors let all customers know they couldn’t keep letting customers light it up inside. Bunch of people stopped going because they couldn’t smoke inside anymore but they forgot why that bar was the last place that risked it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom