Not when it's lacking the suite of RDNA 2 features the S has. There are some things the One X could theoretically brute force through, but for a lot of other things it lacks the raw power headroom to brute force them effectively.
The quote is "there is definitely a sense that it (performance) is not stable enough on the One X..... Still, IF performance could be made a bit smoother with more aggressive dynamic resolution, One X WOULD be a clear winner over Series S."
Baiting?
It has been done with relatively few people with the scope of it, I think it's more like lack of resources. It has X|S badge and it looks awesome, I think you can let go few things here and there.
One X looks almost generational better,runs better at 30fps and both drop below 60fps with One X dropping a few fps more.
To be honest, I wouldn't interact with this guy anymore. He obviously has an agenda and is very susceptible to confirmation bias as evident from his takeaways from the video.
I heard him say the low 50's.
That's not from the video riky it's a cherry picked picture with no link or anything.
46fps, pretty sure that's in the forties.
Also I don't "claim" to have played both, I have, in fact I've played all five versions.
So you are getting other sources to make a point about DF's findings?
For that dog shit CPU and with a higher res, One X is doing quite well with Halo.
46fps, pretty sure that's in the forties.
Also I don't "claim" to have played both, I have, in fact I've played all five versions.
I am on a 1080p 27" monitor at the moment
my 4K TV is fucking up, horizontal lines going across it and I can't be arsed opening it and putting tape across some of the things.
So this was said by them in the first comparison?
Regardless
So this was said by them in the first comparison?
Link?
If so
But they aren't saying this in todays/current comparison as I posted above.
Maybe it got tightened up in one of these updates? It's been a few months.
Both times they still chose the One X though right?
Not if it continues to sell well they won't.
And Metro Exodus and Forza Horizon 5 are considerably better on the XSS than the X1X and the XSS version of Halo has a more stable framerate at 60. What is your point? Developers choose how to use the hardware they are provided and it's clear the XSS runs games at higher frames and lower resolutions. Perhaps you should take your own advice.
So you're chosing resolution over framerate now?. Remember that with the next XSX vs PS5 comparison.
I stated what they said in two videos and on twitter.
They clearly say it's better on Xbox One X
Nobody mentioned them but... from DF's comparison a argument could be made that Forza Horizon 5 is better on One X as well.
Unless i watched a different video, the XSS version is near flawless 60fps, with a few dops into the high 50's, while the OneX version is almost constantly in the 50's, and drops way lower in fights.
None of those things your kids would prob care about but it’s your choice
Ya, I don't see what the contention is. The S can look pretty rough on 4k TVs but it's a great system for 1080p TVs.
Exactly and I'd have to rebuy 3-6 disc titles so I'm spending $400 to have the same experience. Then I sell my oneX for $200 and I'm in the same position just waiting for a series x for a new experience. Frame rates are not an issue for the games the oneX is used for, 60fps for the few titles that it matters and I'm good. When there is a definitive online shooter that can keep my attention then I'll get a seriesX. Playing through Sekiro now and it runs great, loads great with an SSD, and the graphics are mint. VRR might help too. I really would like a seriesX for Elden ring but I play games for the gameplay first and it looks like I'll get the full experience with a oneX and ssd. So I'll wait until I can walk into a store and get one when they are easily available. The seriesS is not a smart upgrade for anyone with a oneX and can't get a seriesX.
You called out Halo like it was typical of XSS and X1X comparisons. I simply provided much needed context you apparently were unaware of. No one would say Forza Horizon 5 is better on X1X when it completely lacks a 60 fps mode.
