Not really the same, bayonetta2 and 3 were truly funded by Nintendo, without them the games wouldn't exist.
This was not the same for stellar blade the game already existed and was announced as multiplatform before Sony came with a bag of money.
And yes part of that money was used for further development but it's not the same as bayonetta.
I also would agree with second party but calling it first party is laughable
The man said it was not the same. Bayonetta 2 and 3 lived because Nintendo paid for them. Without Nintendo they would have died in the dark.
He was right about that part.
But he said Stellar Blade was different. The game already existed, he said. It had been announced for many platforms. Then Sony came with money. A bag of money. Part went to more work. Still not the same, he said.
I looked at the years.
Bayonetta 2 began under Sega. A prototype. Men worked on it. Then Sega stopped. The money was gone. The project sat cold. Nintendo walked in. They gave all the money. They published it. They kept it on their machine. Without them the thing never leaves the drawer.
Bayonetta 3 was simpler. Nintendo paid from the first day. No other hand touched it. No other promise broke. It was born on their coin.Stellar Blade had a name once. Project Eve. Announced in 2019 for PlayStation, Xbox, PC. A demo played at a show. People clapped. Then silence. Two years. No money came. The studio was small. The demo was small. It waited.
Sony played it in 2021. They liked it. They signed papers. They changed the name. They made it theirs for a time. They gave money. Much money. They gave tools. They gave people to test it. They gave words in twenty-two languages. The small thing grew large. It shipped. It sold.
The prototype had lived before Sony. Like the Bayonetta prototype lived before Nintendo. Both waited. Both needed someone to pay the rest. Both would have stayed small or disappeared.
He said it was not the same.
I say the wind moves the same way in different trees.
He said second party was fair. First party was laughable.
Nintendo calls Bayonetta 2 and 3 their own. They show them in their big rooms. They own the finished games.
Sony calls Stellar Blade second party. They paid. They publish. They do not own the name forever.
The words matter less than the act. A company opens its wallet. A game breathes. Without the wallet the game sleeps. Both slept once. Both woke to the same sound. Coins falling.
That is all there is to say. The rest is noise.