• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Is a new PC a better choice than a next gen console?

pc's just aren't for me. i've spent a lot of time on friends high end towers with digital cooling displays and lazer light show going on through a clear wall on the side, pumping out the top games at super framerates,

but even then i just feel cold. hunching over a desk. i know the benefits of pc gaming but console gaming to me is just better feeling.

maybe i'll get into the pc game if consoles in the future fade away, but who knows.
 

StevieP

Banned
pc's just aren't for me. i've spent a lot of time on friends high end towers with digital cooling displays and lazer light show going on through a clear wall on the side, pumping out the top games at super framerates,

but even then i just feel cold. hunching over a desk. i know the benefits of pc gaming but console gaming to me is just better feeling.

maybe i'll get into the pc game if consoles in the future fade away, but who knows.

So plug it into your tv. Consoles are really just smaller weaker PCs with exclusive first party titles and UIs that are geared toward controller navigation. It's all the same HDMI out.
 
So plug it into your tv. Consoles are really just smaller weaker PCs with exclusive first party titles and UIs that are geared toward controller navigation. It's all the same HDMI out.

console OS has a different feel to than a desktop OS. i just can't be swayed.
 
pc's just aren't for me. i've spent a lot of time on friends high end towers with digital cooling displays and lazer light show going on through a clear wall on the side, pumping out the top games at super framerates,

but even then i just feel cold. hunching over a desk. i know the benefits of pc gaming but console gaming to me is just better feeling.

maybe i'll get into the pc game if consoles in the future fade away, but who knows.

I barely play any of my PC games at the desk. All on my couch or bed.
 

Buggy Loop

Member
Hell yea.

tumblr_mcc110Podi1rshs0zo3_500.gif


+

eve-valkyrie.png


+

3-97.JPG


+

DSC_4686_large_verge_medium_landscape.jpg



=

m0XS6.gif


Who would miss out on the return of the PC sim golden age? WHO?

And
Torment: Tides of Numenera
Project eternity
Wasteland 2
Broken age
Routine
and the best versions of multi plat games
 

Cimarron

Member
Hell yea.

tumblr_mcc110Podi1rshs0zo3_500.gif


+

eve-valkyrie.png


+

3-97.JPG


+

DSC_4686_large_verge_medium_landscape.jpg



=

m0XS6.gif


Who would miss out on the return of the PC sim golden age? WHO?

And
Torment: Tides of Numenera
Project eternity
Wasteland 2
Broken age
Routine
and the best versions of multi plat games

Wait! What! Is this real? Whats the name of that game? How much gor the stick? Tell me!!!!!!!!
 

damisa

Member
I went PC only last gen and didn't regret it at all. One thing that's often overlooked is to go back and play older games at higher quality.

Imagine if you can play all PS3 games on the PS4 at 1080p (or higher), 60fps, with lots of AA. Oh and you can get mods and super high quality texture packs for free. This is something you could only do with PC gaming.
 

Tabular

Banned
No. PS4 is a better option. Far more quality exclusives and better support for a controller. PC just doesn't provide bang for the buck or a proper living room experience.
 
Depends on your taste. I can't live without Naughty Dog's or Quantic Dream's exclusives, so I'm forced to buy a PS4 eventually. Multiplatform games I mostly play on PC, because of sales.
 
Its a viable option, especially if you've missed out on PC gaming for the last however many years.

But for me PC gaming has litttle to do with graphics, I'm still rockn' a HD4890. Its about indies, the KB&M, and the types of games for PC that you won't find on consoles.
 

Lingitiz

Member
Is it bad that I don't know any of these games?

Yeah.

Torment: Tides of Numenera - Spiritual successor to Planescape Torment.
Project Eternity - Baldur's gate style CRPG developed by Obsidian.
Wasteland 2 - Successor to the game that inspired Fallout.
Broken age - Double Fine developed adventure game.
Routine - Amazing looking sci-fi horror first person adventure.
 

Skelter

Banned
Yeah.

Torment: Tides of Numenera - Spiritual successor to Planescape Torment.
Project Eternity - Baldur's gate style CRPG developed by Obsidian.
Wasteland 2 - Successor to the game that inspired Fallout.
Broken age - Double Fine developed adventure game.
Routine - Amazing looking sci-fi horror first person adventure.

Wow I actually haven't heard of Routine.

I'll add Spaceshock. I think it's been turned into a turn based game too!
 

Brofist

Member
You can control it with a controller.

Just have Windows start Steam at launch and set it to launch directly in BPM and all should be good.

Or just have Steam open in normal mode at startup and press the 360 guide button to open BPM as well. I still like having it initially open in normal desktop mode myself for some reason.
 

erick

Banned
Still doesn't completely free you from archaic, non living room compatible input methods like a keyboard.

Not to get into the typical argument here, but by playing on a couch you sacrifice a considerable amount of button functionality as well as precision. Couch gamers are pretty much responsible for re-introducing varying degrees of auto-aim to first person shooters, which is an insult to the genre unless you're like 7 years old or have a disability.
 

Seanspeed

Banned
You can control it with a controller.

Just have Windows start Steam at launch and set it to launch directly in BPM and all should be good.
Lots of games aren't very viable with a controller.

I think a lot of PC gamers need to accept that comfy couch gaming on a PC is simply *not* practical for a lot of people and just move on.

As far as being hunched over at a computer, I used to have the same complaint, but since getting a new chair(Ikea Markus), I'm quite happy to sit for long periods of time at my desk. I can recline in it, be nice and comfortable and still use the keyboard and mouse just fine.

Also, I thought of another reason to wait for a next-gen console:

 

petran79

Banned
It depends on your budget and what types of games you enjoy. If you're expecting 3D platforming games on the PC, as an example, you'll have trouble finding many to play besides the occasional indie title (like a Hat in Time).

If you jRPGs you might find the occasional niche one or classic hitting the PC, but for the most part you'll have to resort to emulators for your jRPG needs.

If you like rhythm games, you'll have slim pickings on the PC.

If you like fighting games your mileage will vary rather randomly, but you will miss out on some excellent titles by not having a console.

If you like arcade racers, other than Need for Speed or some classic games you won't find many there.

If you're looking for something like Journey, Ico or Shadow of the Colossus, you won't find many of those on the PC. Those types of games only exist and with the quality they have because a publisher invested in them.

If you like weird quirky japanese games you'll have a hard time finding any for the PC.

However if you like F2P games, MOBAs (like League of Legends or Dota 2), MMORPGs, and most of your game library consists of third-party publisher titles (like Assassin's Creed, Mass Effect, etc.) you will have a great time with a PC. But I think the ideal choice is to pick a console which has the most exclusives you like and pair it with a PC to get the best of both worlds.

I think a PS4/Xbox1 and a PC or a Wii U and a PC (depending on what types of games you appreciate the most) are solid choices.

I agree more or less with that as well.

Regarding fighters and 2D fighters especially, the PC has quite a lot of variety.
If you include GGPO, Arclive and Supercade and the newest additions of USF4, Skullgirls, KOF13, Melty Blood etc in some cases it is even better than consoles.
Some console exclusive Japanese fighters are a little....specific, regarding their audience, hence they might wear off pretty quickly.

Also large TVs suffer mostly from input lag due to post-processing, unlike computer monitors.
PC lacks only 3D fighters, a weird decision by console developers, since if properly developed, they'd look great on PC.

Jrpgs unfortunately will fare even worse this gen, due to increased developing costs. Excluding FF, most are low budget productions. A 3DS or Vita would be a better choice for this.

Games like Ico, Journey and SOTC exist also on PC but apparently with lower budget and length. Such as the forthcoming Ghost of a Tale
 

coldfoot

Banned
Lots of games aren't very viable with a controller.
I think a lot of PC gamers need to accept that comfy couch gaming on a PC is simply *not* practical for a lot of people and just move on.
Thank you, that's all I wanted to stress here before. Doesn't matter if SOME games on PC are playable with a controller (without MP of course, you'd get destroyed) or that you can hook it up to your big screen TV. Unless every single piece of software and the operating system feature on a PC is accessible via a controller, and controller only, it simply will never be as practical as a console.

This is an absolute dealbreaker for me and many people. If you're not bothered by it though, a PC is most likely a better choice. I personally cannot stand a game that prompts me to press "E" or "Space" to open a door or pick up a weapon. Completely breaks the immersion for me, feel like I'm using a computer at work rather than playing a game. A keyboard has no business in gaming for me and should not be relied upon.

But then again, that's me.
 

Seanspeed

Banned
Thank you, that's all I wanted to stress here before. Doesn't matter if SOME games on PC are playable with a controller (without MP of course, you'd get destroyed) or that you can hook it up to your big screen TV. Unless every single piece of software and the operating system feature on a PC is accessible via a controller, and controller only, it simply will never be as practical as a console.

This is an absolute dealbreaker for me and many people. If you're not bothered by it though, a PC is most likely a better choice. I personally cannot stand a game that prompts me to press "E" or "Space" to open a door or pick up a weapon. Completely breaks the immersion for me, feel like I'm using a computer at work rather than playing a game. A keyboard has no business in gaming for me and should not be relied upon.

But then again, that's me.

I don't see how whether the buttom prompt saying 'A', 'E', 'Space' or 'X' or whatever really makes any difference. If you hate keyboards, fine, but that's a weird criticism to make in particular. Button prompts are hardly some PC-specific mechanism.

I was mainly speaking of the practical problems of wiring a computer to the living room, of using a controller for competitive shooters, RTS games and lots of other games without good controller support, and of space.
 

pixlexic

Banned
I don't see how whether the buttom prompt saying 'A', 'E', 'Space' or 'X' or whatever really makes any difference. If you hate keyboards, fine, but that's a weird criticism to make in particular. Button prompts are hardly some PC-specific mechanism.

I was mainly speaking of the practical problems of wiring a computer to the living room, of using a controller for competitive shooters, RTS games and lots of other games without good controller support, and of space.

I play some of the m/k specific games with just my mouse on the arm of my recline on a mouse pad. works great.

The key issue here is the set up of getting USB wires from your PC to the chair.

I went the USB extension rout which was expensive because the only ones I could findin store were $35 a piece for 12ft and I needed 4 of them. I just strapped them all together neatly. it's worked great.
 

Seanspeed

Banned
I play some of the m/k specific games with just my mouse on the arm of my recline on a mouse pad. works great.

The key issue here is the set up of getting USB wires from your PC to the chair.

I went the USB extension rout which was expensive because the only ones I could findin store were $35 a piece for 12ft and I needed 4 of them. I just strapped them all together neatly. it's worked great.
Damn. How far away are you sitting?
 

pixlexic

Banned
Damn. How far away are you sitting?

more than six feet from my PC which most USB cables are not even that. With the 12 ft I also can push the cables to the side so I do not have a wierd tether running across the room.

I probably wouldn't need 4 but I have a razer keyboard that has two USB connections. one just for back lighting power.
 

w00zey

Member
PC is always a better choice.

Especially when you have driver issues and configuring every game to the settings that work best for you. I especially love when I find out that my game plays differently than someone else because the video card I chose isn't the one that it was optimized for.

Just because something is technically superior doesn't always make it a better overall experience.
 
There are still some advantages to dedicated consoles, but at this point they are very minor when compared to say, twenty years ago, and even those little points of contention are slowly going away.

I am fully going to attempt to be PC and Wii U this generation.

I would really like to never support Sony or Microsoft with money ever again (for video games, at least).
 

Sub_Level

wants to fuck an Asian grill.
There are still some advantages to dedicated consoles, but at this point they are very minor when compared to say, twenty years ago, and even those little points of contention are slowly going away.

I am fully going to attempt to be PC and Wii U this generation.

I would really like to never support Sony or Microsoft with money ever again (for video games, at least).

PC + Nintendo actually seems like a good combo. I think you may have something here.
 
If you're looking for something like Journey, Ico or Shadow of the Colossus, you won't find many of those on the PC. Those types of games only exist and with the quality they have because a publisher invested in them.

You're quite right on the other fronts but this particular line is nonsense. The PC has far greater number of experimental and artistic titles than comparable console counterparts due to its more open nature.
 
If you want to spend three times the money, sure.

PC's will always be ahead of the game, but you need to spend the time and money for it to be worth your while. I can't be arsed with the messing around, tweaking and updating, fuck that!

Plug and play all the way.

you will spend 50 dollars for every years you want to play online, 20 dollars more(at least) for every game you decide to buy. So...tell me more about spending money, please.
 

Shambles

Member
You're quite right on the other fronts but this particular line is nonsense. The PC has far greater number of experimental and artistic titles than comparable console counterparts.

Not to mention I happen to have both Ico and Shadow of the Colossus on my PC. Does the PS4 even play PS1/2 titles?
 

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
Especially when you have driver issues and configuring every game to the settings that work best for you. I especially love when I find out that my game plays differently than someone else because the video card I chose isn't the one that it was optimized for.

Just because something is technically superior doesn't always make it a better overall experience.

I agree. I love it and am more than set up to run anything I want how I want but there is downfalls as well. I will take those downs with the ups any day.

That doesn't exactly discredit the ease of use that consoles bring for the mass market. We, as enthusiasts, are a fraction of the gaming market. Most people just want to turn device on and easily navigate to a game or music or video. And they want it to be accesible for their children as well. I don't want my 11 year old sifting through my PC looking for a game and play something he shouldn't on accident or get on the internet and look at things inappropriate for his age. I find this control easier to manage on a console than a PC.

You can list plenty of great reasons for PC like Star Citizen with Oculus support at amazing resolutions but that's really a niche crowd in the grand scheme of things. When most see what it costs to make that a possibility, the bubble bursts fast.

Some might not have the maturity to admit it but consoles are more convenient in a lot of ways. I can get my friends and family to buy the console version of Minecraft before they ever consider it on PC. The ease of use alone almost makes it better for most people despite things like mods and other PC benefits.

We can find reason and reason to go back and forth with this. It's best to at least respect what some consoles will bring to the table not just in terms of functionality/OS but the games. This is why I buy consoles to compliment my PC. I will always run the best games at their best as long as it comes to PC but I'm the only one I know who can do that. For the rest, I buy a PS4 and enjoy a tight next gen experience and the awesome exclusives or even PC ports/indies which none of my friends have ever played because they were only on PC.
 

Stallion Free

Cock Encumbered
I find using controllers to do anything beyond starting/playing a game to be awful. Doing anything in either console OS would take me like a tenth of the time on a normal OS with a mouse and keyboard.
 

Shane

Member
I got back into PC gaming this year (last time was when Far Cry 1 came out) and I've fallen back in love with it. My setup cost £800 and runs most games on ultra; high for the more intensive if I want to maintain 60FPS (Metro: Last Light for example).

It's now at the point where I'm close to cancelling my PS4/XB1 preorder to save the money for a graphics card update next year.

There is something for everyone on this platform. Add in decent digital distribution platforms and you're onto a winner.

That's excluding everything else a PC can do.
 

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
Was this post made in 2009? Because cards that blow the next0gen consoles out of the water have been out since 2010-2011.

On paper they do but people always under estimate consoles with their tight and well thought out architectures which often work much better in unison than putting a PC together with 5 difference parts. That's why we're seeing games that look as good as Killzone and Infamous and this is just the beginning.
 

erick

Banned
On paper they do but people always under estimate consoles with their tight and well thought out architectures which often work much better in unison than putting a PC together with 5 difference parts. That's why we're seeing games that look as good as Killzone and Infamous and this is just the beginning.

I had a long rant written but in the end I decided just to post this: http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=679&card2=675

It compares the HD7970 GHz Edition and the HD7770, the equivalent of which will appear in XO. You have to literally be unable to comprehend numbers to think, after seeing this, that the XO can ever approach the performance of the HD7970 GHz Ed., available since, oh, the summer of last year.
 
Top Bottom