I love arkane but deathloop didnt click with me so I'm trepidatious
DEATHLOOP was a puzzle game with a single solution that people tried to play as an immersive sim first-person-murder-shooter. It just wasn't that at all (there are no boss battles and you can kill everything without firing a single bullet) which is a far cry from DH or even PREY (but definitely DH). Which makes sense given that DL was produced by a different internal studio.
DL for me, other than a kind of cop-out ending, was one of the best games I've played in a while and I'm still slowly working through figuring out the rest of the games mysteries and "side stories." But yes, at the end of the day it's a puzzle game and I imagine a lot of folks playing either didn't clock that or figured "That's okay so long as I can make chaos."
REDFALL looks like you are making chaos.
. . .also roflcopter at the fella tossing "Thoughtful" tags on anything remotely negative about this game no matter how benign the comment. "Consoling" is serious internet-bidness.