• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF Throwback: Aloy looks a little off.......

Mister Wolf

Member
main-qimg-1ed33ff8f4f63bfff60fb1e4fd16a40d

d61934a84d24dbe1d2502172eaed5035.jpg



Guerrilla are more than capable of perfectly recreating Hannah Hoekstra's likeness for Horizon. The dissonance has nothing to do with their tech or ability.
 
I am sure the women of the world are super concerned about passing your 'look twice' test.

Unless you look like a fucking rock star.

I literally saw John Stamos (walking with some woman, not RRS) at Disneyland and I LITERALLY had never seen such pretty people in my life. No Photoshop, not lighting. They LITERALLY looked like they do on magazine covers. It was so fucking impressive and unique.

So yeah, if you look like that, you get a pass for your insulting, sexist, super embarrassing statement. I'll give you a public apology AND a 50 PSN gift card.

Please upload your picture to this thread so we can judge you? I'll put a poll on twitter and if your looks rate 9 or above the video apology AND the gift card are yours!

JAFFE
Dude, this is getting into Dyack territory now.
 

Heylon

Member
She’s not a super model no, and that’s just fine.

Would love to see how the wives of many members on NeoGAF look like, it would be an incredibly interesting thread.
People don’t play games expecting them to be a reflection of real life or how most average people actually look. That’s the whole point. Many seek escapism through fictional works with hot characters and awesome worlds - this has been the case in any kind of entertainment since forever.
 

Heylon

Member
You all are killing me with these mockups. Just too funny! Amazing how many talented people there are that can produce such things so quickly too! Now, if we could see a re-do of the game trailer but with THIS character model...THAT would be hilarious and amazing. :)
The fact that it probably won’t be long before this is the beauty standard in AAA-games, saddens me deeply.
 

llien

Member
Am I really the only one who noticed that her... body got quote noticeably wider too?

I don't understand how the taliban and jennifer lawrence are connected to this...yet.

You don't understand, how "tone down female sexuality" is #taliban minded, did I get you right?

But the character is really ugly.
Come on, they did... things to her, but she's not ugly by any metric.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
That's the point. We have for example Control, where the main character isn't a 10/10 either, but is much more believable, well written, perfectly fits the world and surrounding events, whereas Aloy seems out of place since the very day they revealed the game.

Heavenly Sword has been thrown into discussion in the other thread, and again, very believable, likeable character, despite somewhat potato face. And on the other end of spectrum there's Quiet from MGS5, where you just have to ask yourself wtf is wrong with this chatacter, why it's even here.

So the looks is just a tip of the iceberg, it does help obviously, they might tweak Aloy to be more acceptable, acclaimed, just sticking to the actual real life model would be enough, but instead they make her even less likable with that punchable face, the only thing lacking is her yelling "I want to speak with the manager!"...

You had me at the end there. :lollipop_tears_of_joy: I sincerely think she's beautiful, but everyone to his own. Also same with Control character (forgot her name), maybe she has a big jaw but those could be due to capture mistakes. I would happily bang Aloy or even the less-feminine Control protagonist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rea

Mabdia

Member
She’s not really ugly and I doubt you could get a girl who looks half as good as aloy.
How cute. An Ad Hominem attack... Well, at least I laughed after read it. Thanks for that?

Now can we talk as a grow up men?

Come on, they did... things to her, but she's not ugly by any metric.

Well I just can't see Aloy as a beautiful character. Or she is an ordinary character(and to me it is really worse than ugly) or she is ugly. Damn! Even My V at Cyberpunk looks pretier than Eloy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Isa

TGO

Hype Train conductor. Works harder than it steams.
Why weird? Most men don't like playing with female protagonists, most females don't like playing with male protagonists. That's really natural. I play a lot of games with female protagonists, but if I get the option I always choose the male one.
I don't really mind, and given the choice for example.
Jill Vs Chris
Leon Vs Claire
I choose the female
I just don't like shit, unlikeable characters
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
I don't really mind, and given the choice for example.
Jill Vs Chris
Leon Vs Claire
I choose the female
I just don't like shit, unlikeable characters

Seems like personal perspective. I honestly can't take females seriously when they easily take down brutes in a brawl or a sword fight. For Aloy she's mostly a distant fighter that her combat is around being nimble and smart.

For Control it's gunfights, so anyone can handle a gun.
 

Arsic

Loves his juicy stink trail scent
Girl been eating good. She down with the thiccness.

Which is odd since she lives a very active life style and everyone around her is in great shape, but hey Aloy found the last Burger King on Earth and is going ham on whoppers.
 

Sinthor

Gold Member
main-qimg-1ed33ff8f4f63bfff60fb1e4fd16a40d

d61934a84d24dbe1d2502172eaed5035.jpg



Guerrilla are more than capable of perfectly recreating Hannah Hoekstra's likeness for Horizon. The dissonance has nothing to do with their tech or ability.
Oh wow. I hadn't thought of that, but you're dead on. That it obviously a purposeful change to Aloy then. I don't think it's quite as extreme as some of the more hyperbolic posts are making it out to be, but it's definitely there and definitely then a decision NOT to look more like the actress modeling for Aloy. Probably a deliberate change to show that Aloy is not there for "male pleasure" or to be subjected to the "male gaze." If that's true and it's deliberate, that's sad. Wonder what it's like for an actress to portray a character and have that character made to look LESS like her? The actress can't help how she looks and almost guaranteed that she was picked at least partly FOR how she looked.

Well, until or unless we hear something official from GG about it, I'll continue to extend the benefit of the doubt to them. I just really hope this wasn't intentionally done because of "reasons."
 

Mister Wolf

Member
Oh wow. I hadn't thought of that, but you're dead on. That it obviously a purposeful change to Aloy then. I don't think it's quite as extreme as some of the more hyperbolic posts are making it out to be, but it's definitely there and definitely then a decision NOT to look more like the actress modeling for Aloy. Probably a deliberate change to show that Aloy is not there for "male pleasure" or to be subjected to the "male gaze." If that's true and it's deliberate, that's sad. Wonder what it's like for an actress to portray a character and have that character made to look LESS like her? The actress can't help how she looks and almost guaranteed that she was picked at least partly FOR how she looked.

Well, until or unless we hear something official from GG about it, I'll continue to extend the benefit of the doubt to them. I just really hope this wasn't intentionally done because of "reasons."

How do you go from this:
4142492_hannah-hoekstra_1.jpeg

OIP.uEwL-ewns5Mg44KSKAmMUgHaK5


To this:
horizon-forbidden-west-ps5.jpg

OIP.BcR-ADdiQScB-H1U0cyElQHaEK


When we know they clearly had to have improved their facial scanning tech for the sequel title.
 
Last edited:

Fredrik

Member
I don't really mind, and given the choice for example.
Jill Vs Chris
Leon Vs Claire
I choose the female
I just don't like shit, unlikeable characters

Seems like personal perspective. I honestly can't take females seriously when they easily take down brutes in a brawl or a sword fight. For Aloy she's mostly a distant fighter that her combat is around being nimble and smart.

For Control it's gunfights, so anyone can handle a gun.
Pfff unless it’s role-playing I choose the prettiest lady every time, haven’t even tried playing with Leon, I’m playing with Tifa 😎

RV0JpFT.jpg
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Oh wow. I hadn't thought of that, but you're dead on. That it obviously a purposeful change to Aloy then. I don't think it's quite as extreme as some of the more hyperbolic posts are making it out to be, but it's definitely there and definitely then a decision NOT to look more like the actress modeling for Aloy. Probably a deliberate change to show that Aloy is not there for "male pleasure" or to be subjected to the "male gaze." If that's true and it's deliberate, that's sad. Wonder what it's like for an actress to portray a character and have that character made to look LESS like her? The actress can't help how she looks and almost guaranteed that she was picked at least partly FOR how she looked.

Well, until or unless we hear something official from GG about it, I'll continue to extend the benefit of the doubt to them. I just really hope this wasn't intentionally done because of "reasons."

Or maybe they made her skull structure match the voice-over actor? Not sure. But some devs change faces that can somehow "hurt" the feelings of the actress herself, meaning she's not beautiful enough. Happened with Kassandra on AC Odyssey:

maxresdefault.jpg
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Maybe GG should ditch that extremely expensive photogrammetry setup and just use Sony's Xperia 3D modeling app. :lollipop_tears_of_joy:

maxresdefault.jpg


716980-9400f3b50a701772420feee625b8ba5e.jpg


sony-3d-creator-07.png



And that's without the new 3D sensors in the new mobiles ;)

2021-04-14-image-9.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom