• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Starfield - Official Gameplay Trailer Reveal (2023)

Status
Not open for further replies.

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Not sure we disagree. Sure if the gameplay loop is fun, and each of the 1000 planet is is filled with great things to explore that's great.

Im talking about if they end up copy/pasted, dull, and repetitive, which tends to be the case the longer the game is, or when you have 1000 planets to fill rather than say a quarter of that.

Well you just used the word "Dull" which is an opinion. Some people find searching a massive map for some "collectible" dull, others don't for instance... to person who finds it dull, this "repeated' thing feels.. well.."repetitive".. to the other person, that "repeated" thing is fun. Games are constantly throwing objective repetition at us, but each individual still feels a different level of enjoyment depending on what aspects of a game they like.

For some the scale/scope instantly adds something to a game.. as they just enjoy the feeling of exploring something vast, even if the "vast' majority of it is not hand-crafted.

They are probably going to go with a ton of "procedurally generated" alien animals for instance that are different levels of hostile, procedurally generated biomes and whatnot. That does not excite me at all, but it makes my wife's gamer panties wet for instance. Objectively something like that can say it's not "repetition" because there might be 1000 different animal species... to me.. it doesn't matter how many animal species there are, it'll likely feel dull/repetitive to me.
 
Last edited:

Batiman

Banned
Would be awesome if ship fights turn out to be a bit tactical. One of my dream games would be a fully 3D FTL. This is probably the closest I’ll get.
 

Rest

All these years later I still chuckle at what a fucking moron that guy is.
Ancient aliens/prothians trope is done to death, but other than that it looks cool. Will get it as soon as I can get a PS5 or X Series.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
I am even more hyped for this game after the presentation yesterday. I think the game looks amazing for an RPG of this scale, scope and all the variables and choices usually found in a Bethesda RPG. About the only thing I can see that needs improvement is the frame rate and I'm sure that is one of the things that will be worked out over the next year.

I see certain people worrying about the 1000 planets but I'm hoping some of them will offer opportunities for hidden quests and Bethesda's always interesting random encounters.

salt-production-and-processing-4-1159x771.jpg

17 pages and counting.
By the time this thread dies down we'll have a mount everest of salt.

You know it was an awesome presentation by the amount of salt a certain group of people are dumping into this thread. It's both hilarious and pathetic at the same time the desperate lengths some of the Sony Fanboys go to in this and other threads in an effort to criticize and downplay this game.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Comparing linear game to a huge open world game dude you are a troll
Also that GOW pic is not in game and i doubt that TLOU pic is in game also
TLOU pic is a promotional shot. GOW pic is realtime from a cutscene. I played that game recently. It's during his talk with Hephastus right after he bangs his wife Afroditi.

Character models are a big upgrade over Fallout 4 like I pointed out a few pages ago, but comparing a 2010 linear game to a 2023 open world game on a console two gens ahead isnt trolling. you all need to take a deep breath and quit it with the trolling accusations. Thanks to the massive vram upgrade from the PS360 to PS4X1 era, open world games got a massive boost in character rendering even last gen. Some of the best looking games last gen were open world. RDR2, Death Stranding, HFW, Days Gone, Halo Infinite, Ghost of Tsushima, Batman Arkham Knight all have fantastic looking character models despite being last gen and open world. They will have even better looking game character models next gen. Matrix is a massive open world city with advanced traffic, pedestrian and other chaos destruction simulations, and the character models in cutscenes look photorealistic. Gone are the days where open worlds held back games.

This is just a bethesda issue. They have never been a visual powerhouse. Their expertise lie in underlying systems, massive open worlds, and side quests. Looking at the huge upgrade in vistas, it's clear that they are prioritizing the open world visual fidelity over character rendering and there is nothing wrong with that. Plenty of other studios do this. Ass Creed, Watch Dogs, Far Cry, and even Cyberpunk 2077 which is probably the best looking game on PC has some very bad NPC character models relative to its overall world rendering.

5JlaTVg.gif


It would be nice to get an upgrade in ALL aspects of the game including the character models but when the game looks this good im not gonna lose any sleep over it. However, Im not gonna dismiss criticism of character model fidelity either.
 

sankt-Antonio

:^)--?-<
HZD does not have half of the things that Starfield will have
Starfield is a real RPG wile HZD is a more Action Adventure game
Let actually you know compare RPG to actual RPG
They booth open world. The NPC don't look good for a next gen only open world game, deal with it - or don't. Won't change that NPC are not great looking.
 

Sgt.Asher

Member
Don't get too excited about 1000s of planets, temper your expectations. If there are legit that many and fully explorable, expect vast swathes of nothing. On the other hand there are "1000s" but are just small explorable instances of the planet that you load into.
Remember how much area they touted was in Fallout 4, but then a third of it was ocean. Keep that in mind.
 

Fredrik

Member
It would be nice to get an upgrade in ALL aspects of the game including the character models but when the game looks this good im not gonna lose any sleep over it.
That’s my thinking as well. I can see the lifeless expressions but the next second I see a sprawling city or a landscape that completely blows my mind, and I’m just in awe.

Time stamped til after the over one thousand planets to explore comment:

Amazing!
And to think this is a RPG as well. With mods 👌
 

killatopak

Gold Member
With 1000 planets, you just know that one of them is going to be a far future version of Tamriel. No one even knows what planet that is called.

Deep in some cave it'll have The Elder Scroll Vol. XX. Shared universe confirmed.
Nah. There is only a single planet in Elder Scrolls. The other planets, as mortals can see are the realms of oblivions.
 

Fredrik

Member
My only complaint has more to do with the acquisition than anything else.

After Skyrim VR I want a VR version of Starfield as well.

But that won’t ever happen now that MS owns them, right?
 

Kev Kev

Member
My only complaint has more to do with the acquisition than anything else.

After Skyrim VR I want a VR version of Starfield as well.

But that won’t ever happen now that MS owns them, right?
this is the biggest bummer for me. im still hoping MS comes around to VR one day. apple is supposedly about to announce a VR/AR headset and it could change the game we'll see
 
Last edited:

Kenneth Haight

Gold Member
And yet, everyone in this thread bashing the game will be there day. fucking. One. Funny how that works..

You guys try way too hard to convince yourselves of anything else. There isn't one person in this thread who isn't going to play this game the day it releases. Fans and naysayers alike.. it is what it is.
I have enough in my backlog to play probably for the rest of my life. In order for a game to make me purchase it, it needs to seriously impress me and make it worth my hard earned money. This game looks good don’t get me wrong, I’m sure it will be “fine”, but I can truthfully say from what I have seen so far, I will not be there day one 100%. I haven’t even felt the need to buy a Series X yet.
 

Stuart360

Member
My only complaint has more to do with the acquisition than anything else.

After Skyrim VR I want a VR version of Starfield as well.

But that won’t ever happen now that MS owns them, right?
If PSVR2 sells massive, like 30-40% of the PS5 userbase, i think MS would def make a VR headset for Xbox 5. Or at least license one of the PC headsets.
I get the feeling MS are playing the waiting game in regards to VR. Waiting to see if it ever gets semi mainstream, and also waiting to se which headset ends up the most successful.

Of course the other option is to invest into a gaming PC and play on PC.
 
Nah. There is only a single planet in Elder Scrolls. The other planets, as mortals can see are the realms of oblivions.
There's no moon and sun? No other planets? I dunno man.

They don't even know what other continents exist outside Tamriel. I don't think they've mastered space travel yet to confirm it.
 

Fredrik

Member
MS Flight Sim 2020 has a VR mode, so who knows.
True but there is some jankiness, Skyrim VR is a dedicated VR version and it’s phenomenal combined with the modding community, physics on physics and no floating hands etc, it’s awesome. Starfield VR should happen but I doubt it ever will. 😕
 

Men_in_Boxes

Snake Oil Salesman
how is that the combat part that bugs you the most when this happened:


None of the combat looked good, lol.

I'll forgive janky combat over AI that can see through the back of their heads though. And to feature it in a promotional video seems doubly perplexing.
 

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
They booth open world. The NPC don't look good for a next gen only open world game, deal with it - or don't. Won't change that NPC are not great looking.
Correction, one is open world the other is open worlds....with an S.


Graphics dont ake a game great.
The size of Starfield couldnt possibly have that fidelity for every NPC.

Considering HZ isnt even one planet wide, its not even a fair comparison.
 
Last edited:

Stuart360

Member
No but it’s what we should assume until they officially talk about anything else.
People should consider playing this on PC, for mods and visuals and performance.
To be fair there will probably be 'performence' and 'graphics' modes i would of thought.
 

Redneckerz

Those long posts don't cover that red neck boy
Skyrim in Space, times x1000.
Combine that with existing dialogue/world systems and you have Starfield.

Hilariously, despite being more ambitious i find its premise a lot more grounded in reality compared to its first kin, Star Citizen. That game goes all out on every aspect, but Starfield simply reads like a massively scaled up Elder Scrolls/Fallout.

To be honest, i can see that working.

It did look very similar to previous Creation/Gamebryo/Netimmerse games though. And the combat gameplay... Doomy?

The game sells me on the premise of 1000 planets and a way to visit each one of them. If the biomes are varied enough (and moreover, interactive! Some footage looked really barren for a Creation Engine like game), this could be a sleeper hit. Ofcourse, with a bunch of Todd's Bugs.

With 1000 planets, you just know that one of them is going to be a far future version of Tamriel. No one even knows what planet that is called.
Maybe Valerian. It is a City of a 1000 planets after all.

 

killatopak

Gold Member
There's no moon and sun? No other planets? I dunno man.

They don't even know what other continents exist outside Tamriel. I don't think they've mastered space travel yet to confirm it.
The lore is that the sun is a hole in Mundus that was made when one of the gods were escaping the Daedra and the stars in the sky are smaller holes made by that gods servants.

The moons are part of Lorkhan's body. Nirn, the planet Tamriel is part of, is also part of Lorkhan's body.

I don't think technology has a part in this when we know that Daedra and Aedra exists. We know their powers and what they are capable of. It's easy to assume everything else is true when a couple of mortals in Morrowind became gods and said similar things.
 
The lore is that the sun is a hole in Mundus that was made when one of the gods were escaping the Daedra and the stars in the sky are smaller holes made by that gods servants.

The moons are part of Lorkhan's body. Nirn, the planet Tamriel is part of, is also part of Lorkhan's body.

I don't think technology has a part in this when we know that Daedra and Aedra exists. We know their powers and what they are capable of. It's easy to assume everything else is true when a couple of mortals in Morrowind became gods and said similar things.
That is interesting. But it's just as easy to assume the sun isn't a hole in Mundus, and that they don't know what they're talking about. And that they don't exactly have "gods," they just have magic and some beings that are old and powerful. Could really go either way. I don't really care, would just be a fun easter egg at best.
 

RoadHazard

Gold Member
Has it been confirmed to be 30fps only on Series consoles?

There are parts of the trailer that seem to run closer to 60, but then it plummets to sub-30 when actual gameplay starts. So it seems like it's trying to run at 60 but failing miserably.

Edit: I guess the entire trailer is 30, and the parts that looked smoother to me are just where it actually manages to hit that (which it mostly doesn't). Lol.
 
Last edited:
They booth open world. The NPC don't look good for a next gen only open world game, deal with it - or don't. Won't change that NPC are not great looking.
I don't play BGS games solely for the looks of it i play BGS game for the the masterful RPG mechanics
Sure a game looking good is a plus but Anyone playing a game purely base on how it looks is not a real gamer
 

sankt-Antonio

:^)--?-<
Correction, one is open world the other is open worlds....with an S.


Graphics dont ake a game great.
The size of Starfield couldnt possibly have that fidelity for every NPC.

Considering HZ isnt even one planet wide, its not even a fair comparison.
That S doesn't matter, in either case only what's visible is drawn by the gpu, the 999 other world are stored on the ssd to be loaded up when needed.

I never said anything about great - just read what I wrote. NPC in this AAA game don't look next gen enough. That's all I said.

I don't play BGS games solely for the looks of it i play BGS game for the the masterful RPG mechanics
Sure a game looking good is a plus but Anyone playing a game purely base on how it looks is not a real gamer
Real gamerTM.

Dude just accept the fact that this aspect of the game is the way it is. Its not making the game bad, its just the way it is.
 
Last edited:

Razvedka

Banned
And yet, everyone in this thread bashing the game will be there day. fucking. One. Funny how that works..

You guys try way too hard to convince yourselves of anything else. There isn't one person in this thread who isn't going to play this game the day it releases. Fans and naysayers alike.. it is what it is.
No I won't. I give games a "cooling" and "settling" period. I mean if my opinion frustrates you, than alright. But don't go making shots across my bow for purchasing practices you *think* I make.

Relatedly, this opinion piece from TechRadar is pretty much how I felt.


Fingers crossed that Bethesda has bigger things to show us which will impress. It can still be a great game even if it has middling to unfavourable comparisons with other games that came before it. It's just disappointing it took 6 years to get here, and the next TES was sidelined for it.

At least so far.
 
That S doesn't matter, in either case only what's visible is drawn by the gpu, the 999 other world are stored on the ssd to be loaded up when needed.

I never said anything about great - just read what I wrote. NPC in this AAA game don't look next gen enough. That's all I said.


Real gamerTM.

Dude just accept the fact that this aspect of the game is the way it is. Its not making the game bad, its just the way it is.
I don't care im not a graphics whore that all they play is 3rd person cinematic action adventure game wile staring at the NPC faces all day lol
You thinking this is some kind of flex is laughable maybe play more variety of games instead of only movies games
 

RoadHazard

Gold Member
That S doesn't matter, in either case only what's visible is drawn by the gpu, the 999 other world are stored on the ssd to be loaded up when needed.

I never said anything about great - just read what I wrote. NPC in this AAA game don't look next gen enough. That's all I said.


Real gamerTM.

Dude just accept the fact that this aspect of the game is the way it is. Its not making the game bad, its just the way it is.

I doubt they are actually storing 1000+ planets, the storage requirements would be ridiculous. It's much more likely that the planets are procedurally generated when you visit each one, much like NMS, but with more hand placed stuff on at least a bunch of them (which you can absolutely combine with procedural generation, because it generates the same results every time as long as the seed doesn't change). I guess the only question is if the Creation Engine is actually capable of that.
 

sankt-Antonio

:^)--?-<
I don't care im not a graphics whore that all they play is 3rd person cinematic action adventure game wile staring at the NPC faces all day lol
You thinking this is some kind of flex is laughable maybe play more variety of games instead of only movies games
What are you even talking about? lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom