• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Rottenwatch: The Marvels (2023)

NeoGiffer

Member
White women are uplifted all the time.

You really need to lay off Blacked bro

cat-cute.gif
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
I think Wish is tracking at 50-60 mill, around Coco levels. I know my wife is dragging all the girlfolk to see it during Thanksgiving. I'm gonna watch James Bond instead.

Which would be great, except it too cost 200 million. Not sure WTF is going on with budgets, but now that the writers and actors want more pie it's only gonna get worse.
 

Days like these...

Have a Blessed Day
The "magical negro" trope is completely different.

The magical negro is a trope in cinema (and TV, books, and radio) where he or she is a supporting character (who may or may not have magical powers, though usually they do) whose sole purpose in the story is to help or aid the white protagonist to become a better person or win at an event or whatever good outcome for the protagonist. The magical negro has no plot or story independent of the protagonist... If he or she has any story, it's in service to the white main character. They never have a life outside of a job... They just exist to help the main character.

The Legend of Baggar Vance, The Green Mile, Ghost, What Dreams May Come, etc. These are examples of the Magical Negro trope off the top of the head. None of those characters have a love interest, a hobby of their own or any of the hallmarks of having a fulfilling life. And at the end of the movie, they either leave or die (rarely are they just still there like Oda Mae in Ghost) ... One could argue that in Bruce Almighty Morgan Freeman is a magical negro as God.
Finn in the Star wars sequels
 
There are enough idiots in Hollywood and the media who blame men for their own failures.


My wife and daughter hated both those movie so women can smell a shit movie a mile away! 😄
 

Ownage

Member
I'm not sure that's the correct term here because it just appears to be shit, like really shit, the Director just outright upped and outed after the job was done, no promo, interviews or anything, it's like Marvels heavy handed interfering is crushing things more than usual.
Possible, but audiences like myself don't know those facts. If the director left like that so quickly, it could be due to script or mgmt issues as much as their own negligence. All audiences hear is the DEI agenda and force-fed politik that Disney keeps pushing. Hence the "get woke, go broke" slogan.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
Brain damaging reading this on wikipedia.
First is:
"Best openning box for black female director"

Followed by this:
"Worst MCU opening ever"

Autism is real.
For maximize a soft landing, youre supposed to tell the bad news first then hit them with good news at the end!
 

YCoCg

Member
Possible, but audiences like myself don't know those facts. If the director left like that so quickly, it could be due to script or mgmt issues as much as their own negligence. All audiences hear is the DEI agenda and force-fed politik that Disney keeps pushing. Hence the "get woke, go broke" slogan.
I just find the whole Go Woke, Go Broke thing dumb since there's plenty of stuff doing extremely well that's considered woke, like Barbie earned over a billion and there was plenty here saying that's woke.

It just comes down to the age old is it shit? It can be woke and shit, that's why it failed, it can be woke and not shit and do great. Just right now Marvel is on this see saw of shit to good.
 

ManaByte

Member
Ha. I was wondering the same thing.
I think it will as I've seen very little marketing and it looks like a Disney+ quality project with zero buzz whatsoever.

If the rumors of the plot are true, Disney should shelve it for a tax write off as the resulting backlash and boycott will kill them dead.

It's apparently about the diverse girl trying to defeat the white man villain, who is basically God.

The "villain" is a white guy who hears wishes (prayers) and grants them and just wants his people to be happy and only answers the prayers of those that will improve society. The main character is a Hispanic girl and she's the only one who can save the world from the white man God.

Again, Iger should throw it in the vault with Song of the South. It's going to be as controversial as releasing that would be.
 
Last edited:

Fake

Member
I just find the whole Go Woke, Go Broke thing dumb since there's plenty of stuff doing extremely well that's considered woke, like Barbie earned over a billion and there was plenty here saying that's woke.

If you ignore the context, pretty much ignore all the reason. Barbie would do well anyway even if was male/sexist focused, in fact would be even better, because Barbie as an IP is damn powerful in the world. Mario movie is mid, but was a sucess because Mario IP is powerful.
Spider-Man 2 game is full of woke as far as I can tell, but is Spider-Man franchise dude, would be a sucesss no matter what. CoD III is a mess, but the game is selling like cupcakes because the CoD IP is huge.
Hell, Pokemon Scarlet/Violet is one of the worst Pokemon games I had played and by far one the most selling games around.
I can't even believe people are still using Barbie to any counterpoint.

You should use better example before saying what is or what isn't.
 

YCoCg

Member
You should use better example before saying what is or what isn't.
It's still true though, you're trying to bank on franchises being powerful enough to NOT fail but look at Marvel now, if you go back five years and suggested that a Marvel movie would bomb this badly and people would've called you a hater.

But Marvel has had a string of bad choices lately and this is one of them due to it being just a shit movie that they couldn't market for shit and there was no outrage bandwagon to attach it to this time.
 

Scotty W

Member
Isn't that what most people want about GOD? And the point that he makes in the movie? Sorry but that example is just...
Will Smith in The Legend of Bagger Vance is also playing God- the film is a retelling of the Bhagavad Gita. In any case, it doesn’t matter, the faux offense over the magical negro trope and the beyond absurd cope that black girl magic is somehow different is too much.
 
Opening weekend less than the flash 😂

God the MCU is dead.
Nah, GotG: Volume 3, Thor: Love and Thunder, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, Doctor Strange: Multiverse of Madness, Spiderman: No Way Home all did very well and each came close to $1Billion in the box office, No Way Home raked in close to $2 Billion alone.

Black Widow, The Marvels, Shang Chi, Antman: Quantumania, and Eternals shit the bed and are under $500 Million at box office.

Deadpool 3, Captain America 4, Fantastic 4, The Avengers: Kang Dynasty and Secret Wars will do just fine.

They need to take note of those that did well and make future movies better. Loki was a god tier series and I think they are realizing we want more of that. But keep in mind, it's not doom and gloom for the MCU when you're still making profit.
 
Last edited:

NickFire

Member
It's still true though, you're trying to bank on franchises being powerful enough to NOT fail but look at Marvel now, if you go back five years and suggested that a Marvel movie would bomb this badly and people would've called you a hater.

But Marvel has had a string of bad choices lately and this is one of them due to it being just a shit movie that they couldn't market for shit and there was no outrage bandwagon to attach it to this time.
Yeah, it's definitely more than just people being sick of the whole woke shtick. I think there's two other obvious reasons. One of them is the multiverse itself. As great as it made Spiderman's last movie, it is a convoluted mess for a lot of people and I will dare say an incredibly cheap storytelling device. Just because the comics needed it to let them continue using the same characters for 50-100 years does not mean it's the best thing to keep the fans of the movies interested. And the second reason is their choice of characters to focus on just sucks since phase 3 ended. The second they acquired Fox they should have immediately pivoted to bringing in the X-Men.
 
Nah, GotG: Volume 3, Thor: Love and Thunder, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, Doctor Strange: Multiverse of Madness, Spiderman: No Way Home all did very well and each came close to $1Billion in the box office, No Way Home raked in close to $2 Billion alone.

Black Widow, The Marvels, Shang Chi, Antman: Quantumania, and Eternals shit the bed and are under $500 Million at box office.

Deadpool 3, Captain America 4, Fantastic 4, The Avengers: Kang Dynasty and Secret Wars will do just fine.

They need to take note of those that did well and make future movies better. Loki was a god tier series and I think they are realizing we want more of that. But keep in mind, it's not doom and gloom for the MCU when you're still making profit.
GOTG3 did less box office than the previous installment (even without accounting for inflation) on a bigger budget. Same is true for Thor, Antman, and BP, all cost more (and in some cases, a lot more) and made less. Spiderman is a Sony property and wasn't done by Disney Marvel. The only one that did more than the previous installment was Doctor Strange. And if you included the Marvels' losses, it probably wiped out any profit they made on all the other phase 4 movies combined. And this doesn't even take into account the massive losses they are taking on the the Disney+ side, the She-Hulk show cost a reported 25 million per episode to make. There is no way it increased enough subs to justify that kind of cost.

And if you don't think they are panicking, Captain America just got delayed a year to basically reshoot the whole movie, and Kang Dynasty is reportedly being cancelled.
 
Last edited:

Dural

Member
Yeah, it's definitely more than just people being sick of the whole woke shtick. I think there's two other obvious reasons. One of them is the multiverse itself. As great as it made Spiderman's last movie, it is a convoluted mess for a lot of people and I will dare say an incredibly cheap storytelling device. Just because the comics needed it to let them continue using the same characters for 50-100 years does not mean it's the best thing to keep the fans of the movies interested. And the second reason is their choice of characters to focus on just sucks since phase 3 ended. The second they acquired Fox they should have immediately pivoted to bringing in the X-Men.

Absolutely! And as much as I liked Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, I feel like it's a mistake having him in Deadpool 3. I don't know the storyline for why he's there (Deadpool kills the Fox X-Men universe?), but if it is to kill the Fox X-Men universe why does that even need to be done? Can't they just make an X-Men universe that isn't connected to the fucking MCU? So sick of this BS, it ruins good storytelling having to think about how it connects to everything else.
 

NickFire

Member
Absolutely! And as much as I liked Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, I feel like it's a mistake having him in Deadpool 3. I don't know the storyline for why he's there (Deadpool kills the Fox X-Men universe?), but if it is to kill the Fox X-Men universe why does that even need to be done? Can't they just make an X-Men universe that isn't connected to the fucking MCU? So sick of this BS, it ruins good storytelling having to think about how it connects to everything else.
I am definitely looking forward to Deadpool 3 with HJ returning as Wolverine, but I am hoping it is completely separate from the MCU stuff. The two leads played their roles so well, I just want to see them do it together one time the right way and then turn the page. HJ was awesome as Wolverine, but he's just too old to assume the role in the ongoing MCU.
 
GOTG3 did less box office than the previous installment (even without accounting for inflation) on a bigger budget. Same is true for Thor, Antman, and BP, all cost more (and in some cases, a lot more) and made less. Spiderman is a Sony property and wasn't done by Disney Marvel. The only one that did more than the previous installment was Doctor Strange. And if you included the Marvels' losses, it probably wiped out any profit they made on all the other phase 4 movies combined. And this doesn't even take into account the massive losses they are taking on the the Disney+ side, the She-Hulk show cost a reported 25 million per episode to make. There is no way it increased enough subs to justify that kind of cost.

And if you don't think they are panicking, Captain America just got delayed a year to basically reshoot the whole movie, and Kang Dynasty is reportedly being cancelled.
Kang Dynasty is most likely being cancelled, not because of anything other then Majors fuck ups.

Wanda/Vision, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, and Loki were great shows.

Hawkeye, Moon Knight, and Secret Invasion were decent shows.

She Hulk, and Ms. Marvel sucked and performed poorly.

Sure, Disney is readjusting their plans for sure, but I'm sure they're not panicking. It's not like they're on the brink of extinction. There's a small chance that they will slowly stop pandering. It's not panning out.
 
Last edited:
Nah, GotG: Volume 3, Thor: Love and Thunder, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, Doctor Strange: Multiverse of Madness, Spiderman: No Way Home all did very well and each came close to $1Billion in the box office, No Way Home raked in close to $2 Billion alone.

Black Widow, The Marvels, Shang Chi, Antman: Quantumania, and Eternals shit the bed and are under $500 Million at box office.

Deadpool 3, Captain America 4, Fantastic 4, The Avengers: Kang Dynasty and Secret Wars will do just fine.

They need to take note of those that did well and make future movies better. Loki was a god tier series and I think they are realizing we want more of that. But keep in mind, it's not doom and gloom for the MCU when you're still making profit.
Because of Disney's uncontrolled spending, these movies have to make at least 1 billion at the box office just to break even, because the theaters take a 50% cut. Add in other expenses like marketing which usually another 100-200 million on top of their claimed production costs. Basically only spiderman makes any real profits but sony owns the film rights so they get a cut too. All the rest are either just above even or outright losing money.
 

bitbydeath

Member
Absolutely! And as much as I liked Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, I feel like it's a mistake having him in Deadpool 3. I don't know the storyline for why he's there (Deadpool kills the Fox X-Men universe?), but if it is to kill the Fox X-Men universe why does that even need to be done? Can't they just make an X-Men universe that isn't connected to the fucking MCU? So sick of this BS, it ruins good storytelling having to think about how it connects to everything else.
Deadpool was never listed by Marvel as an MCU movie either.

Image_from_iOS.0.jpg


I think Ryan’s just doing his own thing which they’ll try shoehorn in somehow.
 

MrA

Member
Deadpool was never listed by Marvel as an MCU movie either.

Image_from_iOS.0.jpg


I think Ryan’s just doing his own thing which they’ll try shoehorn in somehow.
why are daredevil born again without you know all the lead-in that goes to justifying the story, you know with x men they're going to go right to the Dark Phoenix Saga without the Pheonix saga
 

SJRB

Gold Member
The sooner they dump Kang, the better. The guy got dunked on by fucking Ant-Man, dude is like a D-tier level threat.
 

FunkMiller

Member
I guarantee you they are going to pivot the whole thing with Fantastic Four, and Doom will become the big bad of a renamed Avengers 5. That'll then lead into Secret Wars with Avengers 6.
 

OmegaSupreme

advanced basic bitch
I figured dp3 was just going to be some fun one off movie. It's now apparently very important and setting up big things lol. It's pretty bad when you need a Deadpool movie as a cornerstone in your cinematic universe.
 

Alcibiades

Member
Saw it yesterday in IMAX Dual Laser. It was pretty bad. Dumb story, weak villain, annoying supporting characters, confusing set-up. Mobius was worse for sure though. Ant-Man 3 (which I thought was so-so) was much better. Also the first Captain Marvel movie was A LOT better.

This would have worked a lot better as a sequel to the first movie with a focused Carol vs. Kree storyline, maybe even taking place before Endgame. I think the retconning of Captain Marvel into being around since the 90's is forcing some weird moments, like dumb explanations for why she wouldn't visit the little kid after she left.
 

FunkMiller

Member
This movie is now seriously on track to be one of the biggest box office disasters of all time. Its weekday performance has been horrendous. It barely cracked 1 million dollars on Thursday - a week out from release. It's now tracking for a sub X2 multiplier. Good chance it won't crack 100 million total domestic.

Utter rejection by the audience. Not down to the marketing, the strike or anything else, other than absolute audience apathy with this shit.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom