brandonh83
Banned
That scene, btw, is not in the movie
Good. Didn't like the POWAH line delivery at all.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rogue One Reviews & Impressions (Spoiler Tags Required)
- Thread starter Cross-Section
- Start date
- Status
Good. Didn't like the POWAH line delivery at all.
That scene, btw, is not in the movie
lol what the hell actually made it into this movie
Again as far as I understand the leaks didn't happen because of its popularity but rather because fired employee(s?) leaked info.
CloudyTuba
Member
That scene, btw, is not in the movie
...THE FUCK
But....but I loved his delivery so much. Like, I just knew that was going to be an awesome scene.
DeathoftheEndless
Crashing this plane... with no survivors!
scorcher59
Member
Man, this thread has me mildly hyped, still considering if it's worth going to the midnight opener this Thursday at midnight
WadiumArcadium
Member
Fuck I love that scene.
It was probably my favourite scene in the final trailer. That was a perfect POWAH.
That scene, btw, is not in the movie
Craziness. Is it the same scene just with that line cut, or the whole scene is gone? Because if it's the whole scene, that's less Vader.
BrokenFiction
Member
90-21. 81%
7.5
7.5
Rogue One compares nicely with the Hoth battle from ESB and the Endor space battle from ROTJ.
Only here
they're both happening simultaneously.
BronsonLee
Member
The First Avenger? No shit that's a Marvel movie
OH SHADDAP
CloudyTuba
Member
God damn, I just took a wrong turn on the intertubes and read a pretty large spoiler. Hold me, gaf.
I guess I should know better. If you want to stay spoiler free you just have to shut the internet off and watch the fireplace until release.
I guess I should know better. If you want to stay spoiler free you just have to shut the internet off and watch the fireplace until release.
That's just too epic man, can't wait to see how it unfolds!Rogue One compares nicely with the Hoth battle from ESB and the Endor space battle from ROTJ.
Only herethey're both happening simultaneously.
Not Spaceghost
Spaceghost
That review really hyped me up
The First Avenger? No shit that's a Marvel movie
hey, don't you diss HAM-master Hugo Weaving
vinnygambini
Why are strippers at the U.N. bad when they're great at strip clubs???
You should read his BvS review if you haven't already.
Haloid1177
Banned
How bout this one lol?
Pretty sure that was confirmed out back on Saturday.
AbsolutelyDisgusting.jpgThat scene, btw, is not in the movie
Into the Light
Banned
So am in this one or not. lol.
The Hermit
Member
that reply!
btw, how does this movie stand on his own?
I mean, TFA clearly doesn't and references the Episode VIII and has a lot of unanswered questions.
Does Rogue One needs ANH, or all information/dialogue is self-contained?
His conversation with Vader is in, but it's pretty short.
There is quite a lot missing from the trailers, so I figured I'd write up a list so you know what not to look forward to or be afraid of
Mind you, it's entirely possible I simply forgot about one or two of those scenes, so no guarantee.From Teaser Trailer
0:32 "I rebel"
1:09 Forest Whitaker's whole monologue (he's also wearing a wig in the finished movie as in the later trailers)
1:21 That one action scene with them running (plays out completely different in the finished movie, these characters are never at this place in this configuration)
1:28 MC looking past camera (not 100% sure)
1:09 Forest Whitaker's whole monologue (he's also wearing a wig in the finished movie as in the later trailers)
1:21 That one action scene with them running (plays out completely different in the finished movie, these characters are never at this place in this configuration)
1:28 MC looking past camera (not 100% sure)
From Official Trailer #1
0:38 - "Good?" Good."
0:48 "You destroyed our hope!" (not 100% sure)
0:59 "I will not kill you"
1:23 "There is a 97.6 chance of failure"
1:28 "He means well"
1:35 "This is our chance to make a real difference" (not 100% sure)
1:43 Walk on the catwalk, Fighter rising up (scene play out completely different in the movie)
1:56 Vader (seems hard to imagine this awesome shot is missing, so I'm not 100% confident, but I don't remember it from the movie at all and I wouldn't imagine I'd forget it)
0:48 "You destroyed our hope!" (not 100% sure)
0:59 "I will not kill you"
1:23 "There is a 97.6 chance of failure"
1:28 "He means well"
1:35 "This is our chance to make a real difference" (not 100% sure)
1:43 Walk on the catwalk, Fighter rising up (scene play out completely different in the movie)
1:56 Vader (seems hard to imagine this awesome shot is missing, so I'm not 100% confident, but I don't remember it from the movie at all and I wouldn't imagine I'd forget it)
From Official Trailer #2
1:15 Vader (see my last point above)
1:16 "The POWAAAH we are dealing with here..."
1:16 "The POWAAAH we are dealing with here..."
WadiumArcadium
Member
I'm not surprised they cut that one. It always seemed like a shot designed for the trailer to tease Vader.
I think you only need to know the empire is building the death star, which is shown at the end of III
SuperEpicMan
Banned
Should these kinda things not be in spoiler tags?
Same. I met him at Celebration this year and I'm still grinning like a fool.
Since those are scenes that are not in the movie I figured they weren't spoilers but I updated the post just to be sure.
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
Same here, just as much as Harrison Ford.
Hamill was right in front of me at the TFA London premiere and that was the first time I've been genuinely star struck (and I've seen my share of actors). Was grinning like an idiot.
Haloid1177
Banned
Yeah yeah person who met a bunch of people for TFA we get it shut up.
I need to meet Daisy at Celebration next year something fierce.
BronsonLee
Member
ViewtifulJC
Banned
gon be real upset if "the POWAH we're dealing with is unmeasurable", such a pulpy line of dialog declared with such rigorous confidence by one of our best current actors
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
Y'all jelly
Didn't interact with him tho because I was too dazed by his presence
Into the Light
Banned
The guy is one of a kind.
evilromero
Member
Was there any doubt? I mean regardless of whether you think Disney's output is landmark cinema or not, to think it would end up bad goes against their factory-like method of producing at bare-minimum well-produced studio films.
Into the Light
Banned
Never forget how he ate this scene up, such a pro
I welled up inside.
I welled up inside.
LucidMomentum
Member
Rogue One compares nicely with the Hoth battle from ESB and the Endor space battle from ROTJ.
Only herethey're both happening simultaneously.
MFW:
SO HYPE RIGHT NOW.
Yup and the score during that scene was incredible.
Exactly, you are never going to get a singular vision of something like the prequels ever again. These are movies by committee, and I'm okay with that. The best Star Wars films were collaborative efforts - Lucas was nothing without Gary Kurtz producing and Marcia Lucas editing.
Cross-Section
Member
And there it is.
Yup the dictatorship is over. At least in SW..
HammerOfThor
Member
For those who have seen or or have been reading spoilers, I got a question for ya.
As a Vader fan, will I be satisfied by his role in the movie? I read an interview where they said he doesn't have much of a role and I got a little bummed.
As a Vader fan, will I be satisfied by his role in the movie? I read an interview where they said he doesn't have much of a role and I got a little bummed.
Haloid1177
Banned
See a better man like Bronson or me wouldn't have froze like that. Stealth brag backfire.
BronsonLee
Member
Yeah, I would've chop blocked the shit out of him!
- Status