Support NeoGAF

[Sir_Crocodile]

So is this legit? How does it compare to the lukewarm (imho) The Cave and Broken Age?

While not perfect, it's far better then both those games imo.

I'm still thinking about my opinion of the story (hard to talk about without spoilers), but there's no doubt the puzzles are top notch. I didn't need a single hint to complete it, but at the same time I didn't find it easy, and all the puzzles were logical, which is pretty much the perfect balance for me.

Also Ransome is great

Have just downloaded the backer gog version (although seem to have a steam key as well?). Excited to relive my youth.

Does anybody know how far into the storyline the phone book answerphone recordings become available?

If you do the right stuff, around 15 mins in. Could take much longer depending on how you play I guess.

 

[Boem]

Voice Overs - Broken Age had pretty great voice overs. Thimbleweed almost makes me want to disable them. NPC's are often better then the cast though.

To add to this (and yes, I agree that Double Fine obviously had access to a higher class of voice actors due to their connections, like getting Elijah Wood and Jack Black to work for them for peanuts), I agree that some of the voice actors...aren't great. I haven't played too much of it so far - about 1 hour/1,5 hours. Some of the characters sound a bit too much like amateurs doing a voice - I'm pretty sure getting a speaking part wasn't a backer reward but it almost sounds like that. Especially the first character you meet and the male detective (Rey?).

On the other hand, I really like the female detective (Reyes), to the point of me playing almost exclusively as her when I need to choose between the two of them, and Ransome is just perfection. But yeah, the voices are a mixed bag so far, although I haven't seen the majority of the game yet.

Really loving it though! Some good old school fun, and I'm enjoying the writing a lot more than some of Ron's other projects like Deathspank, which wasn't to my tastes at all.

Compared to those other two games: The Cave was a very special experience for me. I can see it not being satisfying to people who wanted another Monkey Island, but as a multiplayer adventure game (I don't agree that it's a platformer) it was just excellent, and some of the most fun I had in years at that point. Really satisfying to explore the world with 2 friends and work on those puzzles together. The big drawback for me there was that the multiple character/replay stuff wasn't entirely satisfying, with having to replay many of the same sections if you wanted to see all the stories (especially since the characters didn't add up to a perfect 9, and you were forced to replay some of the characters you had already used if you wanted to see it all). But apart from that, a great experience. Thimbleweed definitely works better as a solo experience though, and it's closer to what many fans (including me) have been waiting for for years.

Too early for me to compare it to Broken Age. I personally really loved it, even though the story beats in the second part didn't entirely hit it for me. Juuust a bit too much repetition in environments and characters, and I didn't like how the game world was more a collection of set pieces rather than a cohesive whole. But I loved the look and feel of that game, and the puzzles in the second part are some of my favorites in the entire genre. But I need to finish Thimbleweed to be able to compare them. But it's very good so far.

 

[IlGialloMondadori]

Really impressed so far. This really feels like a lost adventure game classic so far. Not far in yet, but still, very impressed.

 

[halfbeast]

I'm not that far yet.
Have to look for the map. And some other stuff.


Any tips of what all to do?
Should I start combining stuff? (can you even do that?)
Or trying to give everything I have to everyone?

But I pretty sure I missed an item or a way you can go.

not sure where you're stuck, best to just exhaust every dialogue with every NPC, that should at least trigger some of the flashbacks (which is more for story than progression). maybe you're overthinking things, many times I had an "oh, OF COURSE!"-moment when figuring out the solution after many failed attempts.

It's better then The Cave, in the sense that Ron Gilbert is obviously more comfortable with this type of gameplay, then platforming.

I'm still not that far into Thimbleweed, those who have played it longer and even beat it might correct me, But based on what I played:

Graphics: Well, that depends of what you like the most. Both games excel with their own styles, with Thimbleweeds great pixel graphics, and Broken Age's great handdrawn paintings.

Puzzles: Broken Age easies you into it, and gradually gets more difficult, and as such ended up being a too easy to begin with. Thimbleweed lets you loose with lots of objectives, characters and inventory items from the get go.

Voice Overs - Broken Age had pretty great voice overs. Thimbleweed almost makes me want to disable them. NPC's are often better then the cast though.

Dialogues - So far, Broken Age wins this, with really funny dialogues with a great flow. Thimbleweed has a lot of great dialogues, but also a lot of very cringe worthy, and takes references to other adventure games too far. I hope it easies up on this.

Story: Haven't beaten Thimbleweed, but I think it will win this. So far att pretty great mystery, that creates a great atmosphere. Broken Age started well, but got a bit messy towards the end.

Interface: Well, pretty self explanatory from pics from the games. I'm one of those who feels like the verb interface is a bit unneccessary and just adds extra clicks, but the game delivered what it promised here.

I agree with this, although I liked The Cave with its narrative and some of the puzzles/humor, the gameplay got tedious especially with those non-character-specific sections, which were more busywork than puzzles.

Thimbleweed Park is rough at the beginning, but gets much better as you work your way through the game. I do love some of the kevin sorbo "disappointed"-voice over quirks, where everyone got the same line (a satisfying "ah" after a drink) but one of them howled like they just dropped some very potent acid.

 

[Corpekata]

The only thing I'm disliking is that there's really no reason for these characters to be "working together" with some exceptions. Some puzzles require you get an item with Character X and give it to Character Y who could have either no connection at all to each other or even directly antagonistic ones.

I mean, I like the actual puzzle design, but it feels kind of odd story wise. It made sense in scenarios like Maniac Mansion, but here Ransome has no reason to help Ray and Reyes.

 

[Bookman]

Hey guys I'm kind of stuck (in the beginning embarrassley enough)

Spoiler

how do I get past the water so I can get to A street. I understand that I have to get the tool and maybe get a tube from the police office and change it but how do I obtain the tool

 

[halfbeast]

Hey guys I'm kind of stuck (in the beginning embarrassley enough)

Spoiler

how do I get past the water so I can get to A street. I understand that I have to get the tool and maybe get a tube from the police office and change it but how do I obtain the tool

let me put it that way, to solve it, you probably

Spoiler

don't want to get a cupcake.

 

[Offline]

I love it so far, the artstyle, the humor, everything!

 

[Bookman]

let me put it that way, to solve it, you probably

Spoiler

don't want to get a cupcake.

Thanks man. I had missed that you could go there

 

[Deleted member 30609]

I've been looking for 5c for like two hours

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

I've been looking for 5c for like two hours

Click for hint

Spoiler

Going into the Quickie Pal would help.

 

[mcwizardry]

Great game so far, made it to part 3.

Spoiler

Can you get a second map for the other agent to fast-travel?

 

[Deleted member 30609]

Click for hint

Spoiler

Going into the Quickie Pal would help.

Ah. I'd trashed an important item. It feels so good to be able to play the rest of the game now haha

 

[BluWacky]

Great game so far, made it to part 3.

Spoiler

Can you get a second map for the other agent to fast-travel?

Spoiler

Yes - as per the ending cutscene of chapter 2, the Sheriff returns all the maps to the Quickie Pal as there's no longer any point in hiding them from you.

 

[mcwizardry]

Spoiler

Yes - as per the ending cutscene of chapter 2, the Sheriff returns all the maps to the Quickie Pal as there's no longer any point in hiding them from you.

Thanks a lot!

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Ah. I'd trashed an important item. It feels so good to be able to play the rest of the game now haha

Yeah, I read somewhere that all important items regenerate or something, but I've not seen it as I've only ever tossed one item as a test (the plastic six pack holder), and it was a useless item anyway.

Spoiler

Yes - as per the ending cutscene of chapter 2, the Sheriff returns all the maps to the Quickie Pal as there's no longer any point in hiding them from you.

That's interesting as

Spoiler

I'd already made copies of the map in the newspaper building. Guess there are a few alternative solutions.

 

[Erekiddo]

My biggest problem with this game, and games like it, is how muddled the pacing becomes once you introduce more characters. There's many simultaneous puzzles going on right now for me with no clear indication of which one I should knock out first.

At the moment:

- I have a dead

Spoiler

battery which I need to charge

, but haven't seen anywhere I can do so.

- I need a tube to put into the

Spoiler

clock-in machine outside the factory

, yet haven't seen one that size.

- I managed to get the

Spoiler

watch

and

Spoiler

tools

, and even though I know how to stop the

Spoiler

radio in the jail cell via the radio station shut off, I have no music to replace.

- No idea how to find the missing

Spoiler

joke book page.

- No idea how to get into the

Spoiler

safe with a fingerprint scanner on it. I thought I was clever in refilling the fingerprint powder with soot, as I was going to use it on something Chuck had touched and use another piece of sticky tape on it, then put that on the scanner, but I haven't found anything else for me to dust

. I feel my thought process on this one is correct.

- No idea how to get through the

Spoiler

woods. I was thinking it had something to do with the muddy water, and following footprints, but no leads just yet.

- No leads on how to get a

Spoiler

voided check to the lawyer.

. I showed him the

Spoiler

stub

, but it wasn't good enough.

- I found a

Spoiler

pizza flyer

but have no idea where that location it references is.

I feel pretty smart having solved everything up to this point on my own, but goddamn there's a lot going on.

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Right now you should be able to do 2, 4, 6 and 7.

7 should be obvious, but maybe that's because I'm old. Have you ever used a

Spoiler

cheque

in real life?

 

[The perfect Dark]

This is probably going to be my favorite P&C adventure game. I've not finished it though.
The puzzles are amazing, the dialogue is great, the graphics are charming, the soundtrack is wonderful, I love the characters, this game is long and the story is so interesting.
It's Twin Peaks + X-Files.
This is a classic.

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Fate of Atlantis is still my favourite. This is defo a top ten game though. Puzzle wise it is the best P&C game ever. The balance of difficulty while maintaining clear logic is super difficult, and this game does it better then any I've played in the last thirty years.

 

[Erekiddo]

Right now you should be able to do 2, 4, 6 and 7.

7 should be obvious, but maybe that's because I'm old. Have you ever used a

Spoiler

cheque

in real life?

It dawned on me when I stepped away. Yep, pretty obvious.

Which now unlocks three more puzzles! Haha.

 

[mekakitsune]

question i'm stuck

Spoiler

i have blood from the corpse on toilet paper but I can't put it in the BloodTron 3000, is there something i'm missing? The thimblecon hasn't started yet either i'm not at a loss what to do to progress the story

 

[Erekiddo]

question i'm stuck

Spoiler

i have blood from the corpse on toilet paper but I can't put it in the BloodTron 3000, is there something i'm missing? The thimblecon hasn't started yet either i'm not at a loss what to do to progress the story

It can't be wet.

 

[Conezays]

Around 9 hours in and my impression of the game has definitely improved a lot from the (IMO) rough opening. Reyes' VO in the beginning just doesn't come across great; it does improve though. The puzzles, animation, and setting are strong though. I think it is a little confusing how you can access items/areas/conversations that you cannot see to completion until later acts; I was scratching my head for awhile at a few puzzles only to finish an act and realise I couldn't complete that puzzle yet, etc. Maybe that's partially due to Hard mode? Not sure. Regardless, quite enjoying it.

 

[mattiewheels]

Man. I'm really starting to love how ambitious this game is. You can tell he's had a lot of interesting ideas about adventure design piling up since the 90s. I like how big and realized the world feels, and how intricate things start to get around the third part. The last game I thought really did some different stuff was Dropsy, I guess it had a similar open world feel, but this feels so ambitious, and I hope the investigation stuff turns out to be more involved than I fear it'll be.

 

[Maxpacker]

With Reshade crt shader: (click for full size or it doesnt look right)

 

[mekakitsune]

It can't be wet.

Edit: GOT IT! Thanks!

 

[Corpekata]

Sorry... still can't figure it out, stronger hint?

Spoiler

After you wash your hands how might you dry them out?

 

[mattiewheels]

 

[BorkBork]

Super tempting, but I have no time right now...

 

[Erekiddo]

Does the end of the spooky forest path have anything to do with the main storyline quests? It felt optional.

 

[mekakitsune]

EDIT: never mind found it, oops!

 

[Erekiddo]

last question

Spoiler

whats the darn phone number of the radio station!?

Check the phone book. I think its in the Ks. Important numbers are highlighted in red.

 

[Sloane]

Every Adventure Gamer who still lives and breathes should be buying this

I agree!

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Does the end of the spooky forest path have anything to do with the main storyline quests? It felt optional.

There are three "routes" through the forest path. There's one goes to the

Spoiler

thimbleberries

that you've no doubt already found and is story progression related, one that uses the

Spoiler

navigators head

that is just an optional easter egg for MI fans, and a third one that leads somewhere else and is also story progression related.

From your earlier list post I think you should have easy access to what you need to be able to get to the end of that third route.

 

[IlGialloMondadori]

Fate of Atlantis is still my favourite. This is defo a top ten game though. Puzzle wise it is the best P&C game ever. The balance of difficulty while maintaining clear logic is super difficult, and this game does it better then any I've played in the last thirty years.

Agreed. Pacing is super good, logic is good. It's a certified classic.

 

[Nitty_Grimes]

Spoiler

When you're in the sewer and it says on the wall in emergency call Rempler, do you literally call that number or?

Thanks in advance.

 

[Dee Dah Dave]

This game is great. I don't think point n clicks have the same weight these days but if this released back in the prime days it would be a 9+/10 game.

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Spoiler

When you're in the sewer and it says on the wall in emergency call Rempler, do you literally call that number or?

Thanks in advance.

I don't remember seeing that at all, so it might be nothing or it might be an alternate puzzle solution.

Spoiler

What happens when you call the number?

 

[Randam]

Spoiler

When you're in the sewer and it says on the wall in emergency call Rempler, do you literally call that number or?

Thanks in advance.

why not try it?

 

[Nitty_Grimes]

why not try it?

It just leaves a message nothing else happened.

Edit: durr, what an idiot I am.

 

[Randam]

The only thing I'm disliking is that there's really no reason for these characters to be "working together" with some exceptions. Some puzzles require you get an item with Character X and give it to Character Y who could have either no connection at all to each other or even directly antagonistic ones.

I mean, I like the actual puzzle design, but it feels kind of odd story wise. It made sense in scenarios like Maniac Mansion, but here Ransome has no reason to help Ray and Reyes.

qft.

starting to notice it more and more.
put a tube into a maschine with Dolores, so Ray could use it.
walked right across the area, just to do that.
why whould Delores do that?

and you can't even talk to the other characters, when you are at the same place.

 

[Dandy Lyin]

Loving it so far, though I've been stuck where I am for a while now...

Right now I feel like I need to do one of the following to progress:

Spoiler

-Find Chuck's finger prints to get into his safe, presumably to get the design for the tube needed to get into the factory

Spoiler

-Decode the will. Tried Delores computer, but she says she needs a more powerful programming language. In Chuck's journal it mentions a programming language book in his library, but Delores refuses to use the BookTron 3000("I don't need a book right now.")

Spoiler

-Find a theremin record to play on the radio so Willie can fix Reyes' watch.

A vague hint to one of these would be helpful.

 

[DiipuSurotu]

Are there deadends in this game? I've always prefered the LucasArts adventures where you can't get stuck or die (except for Indy 3 and 4 since those were pretty much adventure/action hybrids).

 

[Boem]

Are there deadends in this game? I've always prefered the LucasArts adventures where you can't get stuck or die (except for Indy 3 and 4 since those were pretty much adventure/action hybrids).

No. Ron Gilbert has always spoken out about his preference for the 'no dead ends' approach (which I agree with a lot), and this game has the same approach. They even joke about it at one point in the game.

So you can freely explore and try whatever you want without having to worry about screwing it all up for yourself or having to manage a million save games.

 

[Isotropy]

No. Ron Gilbert has always spoken out about his preference for the 'no dead ends' approach (which I agree with a lot), and this game has the same approach. They even joke about it at one point in the game.

So you can freely explore and try whatever you want without having to worry about screwing it all up for yourself or having to manage a million save games.

Spoilers for early game, which I've watched a bit of and have a question about:

Spoiler

Early on, it looks to be possible for Ray to be killed? Which contradicts the game's line about no failure states. I'm guessing she reappears later somehow, but does that mean playing through a big chunk of the game as Reyes instead if you screw up with Ray? Her voice acting is so much better...

 

[Sir_Crocodile]

Loving it so far, though I've been stuck where I am for a while now...

Right now I feel like I need to do one of the following to progress:

Spoiler

-Find Chuck's finger prints to get into his safe, presumably to get the design for the tube needed to get into the factory

Spoiler

-Decode the will. Tried Delores computer, but she says she needs a more powerful programming language. In Chuck's journal it mentions a programming language book in his library, but Delores refuses to use the BookTron 3000("I don't need a book right now.")

Spoiler

-Find a theremin record to play on the radio so Willie can fix Reyes' watch.

A vague hint to one of these would be helpful.

2 is doable right now, and is deceptively easy. You're not on the right track with where you're looking.

Are there deadends in this game? I've always prefered the LucasArts adventures where you can't get stuck or die (except for Indy 3 and 4 since those were pretty much adventure/action hybrids).

No deadends by design (always possible there's a bug though).

Interesting to note that maniac mansion and zak mckracken didn't have deadends by design, but because lucasfilm had very few people testing the games back then. This was less of an issue by the time Monkey Island came out.

Spoilers for early game, which I've watched a bit of and have a question about:

Spoiler

Early on, it looks to be possible for Ray to be killed? Which contradicts the game's line about no failure states. I'm guessing she reappears later somehow, but does that mean playing through a big chunk of the game as Reyes instead if you screw up with Ray? Her voice acting is so much better...

Spoiler

There is a point in the game where an agent gets kidnapped if that's what you're talking about. I think it's random which one it happens to. I tend to play as much of the game as is possible as Ransome or Delores anyway

 

[Harmen]

Surprised so many people dislike Broken Age (or found it average). I played it inbetween Grim Fandango, the original Broken Sword, and Days of the Tentacle and Broken Age was probably my second favourite after Grim Fandango (mostly missed out on adventure games when I was young).

Anyways, good to see people are liking this one, totally unexpected game I really want to play. Is there a release date for android?

 

[Joe Shlabotnik]

Spoilers for early game, which I've watched a bit of and have a question about:

Spoiler

Early on, it looks to be possible for Ray to be killed? Which contradicts the game's line about no failure states. I'm guessing she reappears later somehow, but does that mean playing through a big chunk of the game as Reyes instead if you screw up with Ray? Her voice acting is so much better...

That is quickly resolved and is only a very short bit in the game (and is not character-exclusive).

I'm in Act Four now and both the game and production quality really opens up in Act Three. It does get off to a shaky start voice-acting-wise, as I think both Ray and Reyes' voices are pretty terrible. But most of the rest of the cast is fine to great.

 

[Boem]

Spoilers for early game, which I've watched a bit of and have a question about:

Spoiler

Early on, it looks to be possible for Ray to be killed? Which contradicts the game's line about no failure states. I'm guessing she reappears later somehow, but does that mean playing through a big chunk of the game as Reyes instead if you screw up with Ray? Her voice acting is so much better...

Don't worry about it. That's all part of it and it's not screwing up, it's supposed to happen. If you continue on from that point everything will become clear.

Slight spoiler:

Spoiler

She returns later in the game (pretty quickly for me actually), and you can play as her again.

Edit: Yeah what Joe said.