• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE review thread

marrec

Banned
All that online discussion is just from a very vocal minority, 99% of people (which means 99% of reviewers) don't care.

Nobody gives a shit about edits that they'll never see or would have cared about even if they did see.

I'm gunna play the game as it releases in this region tyvm
 

blazeaire

Member
Awesome! just convinced me to order it online right now, between this, SO5 and Odin Sphere, I'm in RPG heaven for the next month <3
 

Rodin

Member
Nice scores, but it wasn't unexpected for me (well, a 9.5 from polygon definitely was). Atlus knows how to make an rpg, and first impressions from Japan were very positive.

I wasn't expecting the game to be bad or anything, but I definitely wasn't expecting reviews to be this positive. At least Wii U will have one well received game in 2016.
I know the fanbase doesn't like that direction but i don't think Paper Mario will get bad scores. Still, these are probably the last two games i'll play on my Wii U, i'll get Zelda too but i'll play the NX version.
 

Jb

Member
Indeed it is! Their only other internally developed HD-era game has been Catherine.

This is so weird to think that the HD era began over 10 years ago and this is the first high rez SMT game. Hopefully we'll get them more frequently from now on.
 

SilentRob

Member
I only played about 2 hours so far but really, really like it.

It just oozes style, just like the Persona games. Every single menu seems to have more work put in that many UIs as a whole. Other than that, it seems to be a fairly traditional JRPG gameplay-wise in a pretty cool, different scenario.

Also, a classic JRPG on a big console. We don't really get that too often.
 

silva1991

Member
Reviewed better than I expected.

Gameplay looks fun, but the story doesn't sound so promising even Gamespot reviewer barely mentioned it or did she? I didn't notice while listening.
 

ZeroX03

Banned
I was always buying this game, figured it'd be decent and it looks like most reviewers more than agree. Kudos, Atlus.
 

Nyoro SF

Member
Reviewed better than I expected.

Gameplay looks fun, but the story doesn't sound so promising even Gamespot reviewer barely mentioned it or did she? I didn't notice while listening.

The story is, well, uh, it has one.
It's pretty basic, the side stories are more fun (when they're not asking you to kill 10 monsters for them or whatever).
In chapter 5 they basically just dump the entire back half of the story on you all at once lol.
 

tebunker

Banned
Actually really glad to hear it getting good reviews.

On the other hand i was hoping this would slide under the radar and end up like W101, and drop in price quickly.

It may still but I think this game will have a much smaller run and will be harder to pick up because rpg gamers tend to hold on to this stuff.
 

dark_haze

Neo Member
Not the least bit surprised at the reviews, but really shocked at Polygon's! I'm curious to what IGN has to say.

Can't wait until Friday!

tumblr_o007i1Amhn1uybfgko2_r1_400.gif
 

kollapse

Neo Member
Great to see these positive scores coming in (but honestly I would have bought it eventually either way lol).

This is sort of off topic, but a lot of people in this thread are saying that they'll hold off on SO5, and pick this up instead, on the basis that SO5 is going to drop in price quickly. What's the rationale behind that? Is it just because SO4 for PS3 dropped relatively quickly?

I ask because I'm in the same situation as many: no way I can afford both right now, but eventually want to play them both.
 

Ridley327

Member
This is pretty crazy when you think about it

I've always speculated that Atlus decided to keep quiet about the hardships of transitioning to HD-level development, to avoid the fan outrage that companies like Squenix and Nintendo have gotten. Sliding release date of P5 aside, they really haven't gotten anything nearly as quotable as "HD towns are hard" to hold against them, which is pretty smart.
 
Great to see these positive scores coming in (but honestly I would have bought it eventually either way lol).

This is sort of off topic, but a lot of people in this thread are saying that they'll hold off on SO5, and pick this up instead, on the basis that SO5 is going to drop in price quickly. What's the rationale behind that? Is it just because SO4 for PS3 dropped relatively quickly?

I ask because I'm in the same situation as many: no way I can afford both right now, but eventually want to play them both.

SO5 tanked in Japan, and is already down to ~1500 yen. This is also more likely to be a small run and hard to obtain new down the road.
 

rhandino

Banned
This is sort of off topic, but a lot of people in this thread are saying that they'll hold off on SO5, and pick this up instead, on the basis that SO5 is going to drop in price quickly. What's the rationale behind that? Is it just because SO4 for PS3 dropped relatively quickly?
SO5 seems to be a little on the short side and the impressions so far are not the best and S-E tend to drop the prices of their games really quick.

Meanwhile this is a Nintendo game and a niche one at that so prices are expected to be more or less stable (Xenoblade X is only 10$ cheaper on amazon since launch and in my country is still at launch price).
 

ZeroX03

Banned
I always enjoy reading your reviews Mike.

Great to see these positive scores coming in (but honestly I would have bought it eventually either way lol).

This is sort of off topic, but a lot of people in this thread are saying that they'll hold off on SO5, and pick this up instead, on the basis that SO5 is going to drop in price quickly. What's the rationale behind that? Is it just because SO4 for PS3 dropped relatively quickly?

I ask because I'm in the same situation as many: no way I can afford both right now, but eventually want to play them both.

Almost every SE game tanks in price. They've been very reliable with swift price drops and delayed PC ports this gen.

Nintendo holds their price longer and ships less discs.
 

Skel1ingt0n

I can't *believe* these lazy developers keep making file sizes so damn large. Btw, how does technology work?
Seems Amazon nor Best Buy have the CE in stock for the 20% discounted.

I just paid full price + tax + shipping for the CE... just shy of $100. Wasn't planning on that; but this game is reviewing way better than I expected, and I suspect this LE will actually be very limited.
 

Ridley327

Member
Great to see these positive scores coming in (but honestly I would have bought it eventually either way lol).

This is sort of off topic, but a lot of people in this thread are saying that they'll hold off on SO5, and pick this up instead, on the basis that SO5 is going to drop in price quickly. What's the rationale behind that? Is it just because SO4 for PS3 dropped relatively quickly?

I ask because I'm in the same situation as many: no way I can afford both right now, but eventually want to play them both.

Squenix games tend to drop in price fairly quickly. Nintendo games historically have not outside of Nintendo Selects, and since this is one of the very last games being released on the Wii U, I anticipate that there won't be many copies to begin with.
 

Mediking

Member
Seems Amazon nor Best Buy have the CE in stock for the 20% discounted.

I just paid full price + tax + shipping for the CE... just shy of $100. Wasn't planning on that; but this game is reviewing way better than I expected, and I suspect this LE will actually be very limited.

NO!!!!!!!!!!!! Please don't be true!!! I don't want my CE to get delayed!!!!!!!!!!! Amazon, ship them out!!!!!!
 
The more of you who buy before the game hits the bargain bin, the more likely we get another game in the series. Playing it smart now may prove to be dumb further down the road.
 

tebunker

Banned
The more of you who buy before the game hits the bargain bin, the more likely we get another game in the series. Playing it smart now may prove to be dumb further down the road.

Well the real issue is that you take a risk with a game like this, not ordering it now, because it may be very hard to get period. As in no bargain bin period.

I just know I won't have time to play it any time soon. Might actually just go digital. Get some cheap credit at BB this week, or during another sale and then pick it up, not to mention any chance of a MyNintendo coupon.
 

Shun

Member
I don't see how that is a bad thing when several of the development team and the voice actors for the characters expressed a desire to continue the IP and game, whether as a sequel or a port.

A lot of the fans have been hoping for it as well, despite it's unlikeliness, after the comments made by the team expressing they want to do more #FE.

So yes if possible you should buy and support the game before it gets slashed in prices, if it gets slashed in price.

Unless I misunderstand what you mean.
 

TheJoRu

Member
Nice reviews, I've heard good things but this is slightly better than I had expected.

The more of you who buy before the game hits the bargain bin, the more likely we get another game in the series. Playing it smart now may prove to be dumb further down the road.

Chances are it might not even hit the bargain bins, and instead ends up being rare and super expensive in a few years.
 

Darth_Caedus

No longer canonical
Do you guys think this game will have limited physical copies? I don't know if I should get it Friday or wait a few weeks...
 

NEO0MJ

Member
This game got a 9.5 from Polygon?! Was not expecting the game to get such a high score, especially not from them.
 
I wasn't ever going to NOT get this game but the Polygon review did bring up something that I knew they would do that will definitely bother me when I play this; wishing they went more in depth, darker or realistic about the bad parts of the idol industry (which is most of it). I know that the game is striving for a more light-hearted and happy tone and I certainly will not fault it for that but it's much the same reason I have issues with Pokemon or...another...series I have suddenly forgotten the name of; I find more in depth explorations of ideas a game brings up fascinating than when it's handled as a side-quest that is over quickly or beaten by friendship. It's more of a frustration at how far they could go or how strongly they could explore it vs how surface level they treat it.

That being said, Imma still play the fuck out of and enjoy this. I just wish games would sometimes go in hard on stuff instead of relegating it to a brief touch on an element before throwing it away.
 

The Boat

Member
My review isn't done because exam season is kicking my ass, but yeah, I've really enjoyed the 6 or so hours I've put in. If J-Pop/Idol stuff doesn't completely turn you off and you like RPGs, this is a good bet. My only point of comparison with the SMT franchise is Persona, but I'm liking both the dungeons and the combat more than Persona's.
 

marrec

Banned
My review isn't done because exam season is kicking my ass, but yeah, I've really enjoyed the 6 or so hours I've put in. If J-Pop/Idol stuff doesn't completely turn you off and you like RPGs, this is a good bet. My only point of comparison with the SMT franchise is Persona, but I'm liking both the dungeons and the combat more than Persona's.

But what if J-Pop/Idol stuff completely turns you on ( &#865;° &#860;&#662; &#865;°)
 
Top Bottom