Alright folks, I've tabulated the results and passed them back to Sadist for posting in a new thread.
Having seen the overall rankings, I can't say I'm too surprised at how very, very close some of the top-ranked games wound up being. The games ranked 4 and 5 received the exact same number of points, so the game at rank 4 took it by the tiebreaker stat of having a higher average rank. The game at rank 3 beat those two games by a mere one point.
It's not for a lack of sample size, either: there were 335 ballots counted.