• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Yoko Taro (Nier Automata) Addresses the 2B butt controversy

Bold One

Member
The reaction in this thread is quite telling, a western dev would have been drawn and quartered for pulling this sort of stunt.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
Can't unsee muzzle flash appearing one second after the shot lol
Hate it.

SSM was called out again because of the sequence in GoW:A where Kratos starts curb stomping one of the Furies. And it wasn't just because of the "Bros before Hos" trophy, it was because the level of violence toward women made some reviewers feel uncomfortable, even though Ascension is by far the least violent entry in the series.
Things like the Bros before Hos trophy definitely amplify the issue.

What does Yoko Taro have to do with God of War?
Someone brought up GoW 3's poseidon princess scene.

I'm not gonna lie, I would have found this hilarious
I doubt it'd be titilating. Perhaps I should've specified erect.

That's a hilarious response. I'm glad he's not letting the faux-outrage get to him.
It's literally a faux-outrage created by a GG amplified by other GGs.
 

Azuran

Banned
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.
 

killatopak

Gold Member
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.

Links or it didn't happen.
 

Izuna

Banned
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.

PM me

--

and I agree, I love this character
 

QisTopTier

XisBannedTier
I doubt it'd be titilating. Perhaps I should've specified erect.
.

Would still be funny, dude's about to die and he's turned on? We all know what that prince did with his servants now. LOL I'm pretty open when it comes to sexual stuff on both sides. I was mad when they tonned down that ff phone game
 

Ray Down

Banned
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.
The new Morrigan, people love her design and draws her, no one buys the game
 
Still can't figure out what your point is beyond some sort of whataboutism. Sorry.

I'm glad you specified that it is "some sort of" whataboutism. Some "sorts" can enrich a discussion, some "sorts" are intended to limit or prevent discussion. I intended it to be the former sort, you perceive it to be the latter sort.
 
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.

She's weird looking. Her waist to hip ratio is insane.
 

Audioboxer

Member
The new Morrigan, people love her design and draws her, no one buys the game

It's cool my friend, there will be dozens of us on GAF.

R1fdEt3.gif
 

Weiss

Banned
I googled the game, and unfortunately all the characters had butts. Although one chick with a blindfold had the most pics, so I'm guessing it's her people have a problem with.

Someone made a photoshop of the main character of this game (aforementioned blindfold girl who is named 2B and is the protagonist) with a visible butthole.

The director, Yoko Taro, is asking people to collect pictures of 2B's butt.
 

Akibared

Member
2B is the best character design to have come out in years. To think it took until more than 5000 years for a human to design perfection.

My Twitter is full of art of her. Truly the goddess we deserved.

I retweet all art I find of her everyone must experience the love!
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
Would still be funny, dude's about to die and he's turned on? We all know what that prince did with his servants now. LOL I'm pretty open when it comes to sexual stuff on both sides. I was mad when they tonned down that ff phone game
I was annoyed about that since my issue wasn't the sexualization it was more so the ridiculous looking armor that literally was clipping with itself on the model. And they made him less sexy instead. Square pls. Ծ_Ծ

Would still be funny, dude's about to die and he's turned on? We all know what that prince did with his servants now. LOL I'm pretty open when it comes to sexual stuff on both sides. I was mad when they tonned down that ff phone game
It's just a weird scene in general.
 

Ran rp

Member
I googled the game, and unfortunately all the characters had butts. Although one chick with a blindfold had the most pics, so I'm guessing it's her people have a problem with.

KLoWn
I googled the game
and unfortunately all
the characters had butts.
(Today, 05:45 PM)
 

Audioboxer

Member
Man that's a depressing thought.

I'm willing to bet it will be their best game yet in terms of sales though.

Probably, but the production values have gone up at least a bit from the shoestring budget of Nier. Sales have to be better! Most importantly let us just hope the game is good. Platinum will bring about better gameplay, Taro just has to try and top Nier. Which will be hard.

I don't doubt though GAF will have the best and busiest OT on the whole internet for this game lol. I'm sure the devs will be reading.
 

Zolo

Member
Probably, but the production values have gone up at least a bit from the shoestring budget of Nier. Sales have to be better!

I'd assume the sales will be better if only between Platinum and Nier actually getting somewhat of a reputation in the years since it's been released compared to where it seemed completely unknown at release.
 

sonicmj1

Member
It's literally a faux-outrage created by a GG amplified by other GGs.

I really don't think this is about the photoshopped butthole image, considering that whole controversy came and went two weeks ago, and that the original tweet talks about "many... drawings being uploaded," which has nothing to do with the photoshop job.

It's much more likely to be about the explosion of fanart of the character online, much of it sexually charged. There's probably an interesting conversation to have about the relationship between character designers/game creators and sexy fanart, but it's not going to be in this thread.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
The reactions in this thread are a total 180 from what I expected from GAF before clicking this thread O_O
Gaming side can be pretty terrible with diversity issues sometimes. Something something artistic integrity is the most important aspect of any game especially involving sexualized character design, but suspiciously not things like gameplay, other characters, or any other sort of criticism that doesn't involve sexualization whatsoever.

I really don't think this is about the photoshopped butthole image, considering that whole controversy came and went two weeks ago, and that the original tweet talks about "many... drawings being uploaded," which has nothing to do with the photoshop job.

It's much more likely to be about the explosion of fanart of the character online, much of it sexually charged. There's probably an interesting conversation to have about the relationship between character designers/game creators and sexy fanart, but it's not going to be in this thread.
The last time I brought that up someone attributed Overwatch's success to the excess amount of pornography that it spawned. So yea, definitely not a discussion people are willing to have unless creators are a-ok with sexy fanart as you can see with this thread.
 

Audioboxer

Member
I'd assume the sales will be better if only between Platinum and Nier actually getting somewhat of a reputation in the years since it's been released compared to where it seemed completely unknown at release.

If it can manage to knock up some better reviews, then that always helps.

2017 has some good Japanese releases due, and 2016 finished with FF15, so in general there should be cravings for Japanese content lingering throughout the year as well. With Ni No Kuni 2 and Persona 5 inbound, this could be the year of Japan. Not to mention FF15 will probably actually be finished this year ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) So really it is a 2017 game.
 

QisTopTier

XisBannedTier
It's just a weird scene in general.

As I said Kratos is an asshole he did similar things in games before 3. The only thing truly wrong with it all was the trophy as far as things go.

No trophy = yeah kratos did shit like this in other games to dudes just happens to be a woman this time.

Trophy title is like a dev note saying " it was a waste to kill her right away and I would have rather fucked her first. "
 

yurinka

Member
It's disgusting to see people asking to censor videogames.

Specially something that stupid that is hidden and 99.999% of the players won't notice.

We are in 2017, not in the middleage. Your head won't explode and you won't go to hell if you see this. If you don't like this, just ignore it and don't buy the game. Avoid wasting efforts creating hate campaigns and let the artists do whatever they want.
 

Dio

Banned
It's disgusting to see people asking to censor videogames.

Specially something that stupid that is hidden and 99.999% of the players won't notice.

We are in 2017, not in the middleage. Your head won't explode and you won't go to hell if you see this. If you don't like this, just ignore it and don't buy the game. Avoid wasting efforts creating hate campaigns.

It's not even real, people fell for a photoshop.
 

LionPride

Banned
It's disgusting to see people asking to censor videogames.

Specially something that stupid that is hidden and 99.999% of the players won't notice.

We are in 2017, not in the middleage. Your head won't explode and you won't go to hell if you see this. If you don't like this, just ignore it and don't buy the game. Avoid wasting efforts creating hate campaigns and let the artists do whatever they want.

Who is asking for this game to be censored?
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
As I said Kratos is an asshole he did similar things in games before 3. The only thing truly wrong with it all was the trophy as far as things go.

No trophy = yeah kratos did shit like this in other games to dudes just happens to be a woman this time.

Trophy title is like a dev note saying " it was a waste to kill her right away and I would have rather fucked her first. "
Kratos does horrible shit but that was the time where it felt like the horrible shit was happening because of the gender of the character. And yes the trophy absolutely did not help in that regard. So it's less that I take issue with Krato's brutality in using her as a holdup for a device, because he's the type to do that to a male as well, it's the dragging and screaming of a woman with exposed breasts that I take issue with. It's really offputting.

I still don't get this.
It's a shitpost taking note at the fact that I took issue with one of Alloy's armor choices in Horizon have a completely exposed midriff despite having more armor pretty much everywhere than her default. The midriff itself contradicts that idea of wearing more armor than the default outfit.
 
It's a shitpost taking note at the fact that I took issue with one of Alloy's armor choices in Horizon have a completely exposed midriff despite having more armor pretty much everywhere than her default. The midriff itself contradicts that idea of wearing more armor than the default outfit.

It's nothing personal, just fooling around.
 
Top Bottom