-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
"Video games need fewer 'sexy' women and more you can actually fancy"
- Thread starter oni-link
- Start date
FunkyDealer
Banned
chromatic9
Member
Philippa Eilhart
Just me then?
...I didn't actually say that though, did I?
We do not use quotation marks when we're misleading via paraphrasing.
I mentioned my personal life because you made a judgement on me personally. My original post implies nothing more than I suspect he wisely ducked a loaded question. If you want to segue that into me seeing all women as little glass princesses that need cosseting at all times, that's on you.
Massive Duck. C.M.
Banned
Nearly 200 posts of poor reading comprehension admissions.
She's not saying sexy women in games are bad or anything, just that they're often created to be nothing but. She also does offer examples of characters will actual personalities for consideration as well.
She's not saying sexy women in games are bad or anything, just that they're often created to be nothing but. She also does offer examples of characters will actual personalities for consideration as well.
Why are people suggesting the boyfriend wasn't being honest?
Had my partner asked me the question I would have answered in similar fashion. I can think of a few female characters I really like, but none I actually fancy.
It's rare a game portrays /any/ characters well enough for this to be an option, and as well rounded female representation is lacking more than male it's even rarer to find.
Had my partner asked me the question I would have answered in similar fashion. I can think of a few female characters I really like, but none I actually fancy.
It's rare a game portrays /any/ characters well enough for this to be an option, and as well rounded female representation is lacking more than male it's even rarer to find.
Dice
Pokémon Parentage Conspiracy Theorist
There are plenty of charming female game characters, including those who were all sexified. This article just makes an assumption because of what her boyfriend said and runs all the way with it? lol.
I agree with these:
I agree with these:
And I'd add Quistis, Lulu, Rikku, Bayonetta, Courtney Collins (MGR, if you talk to her on coms a lot), Vivienne, tons of SMT characters, Faye Lee (Binary Domain), Jessica (Lunar SSS), etc, etc. I'm remembering plenty of cool female characters over all the years and many genres. I mean, personable/likable characters male or female are rare enough in games, but when a game has them, they usually have both.
I can't say he's lying, but I'm not attracted to any videogame characters at all because polygons and sprites don't do it for me... not because of a personality deficiency. Although it is true, so many female characters are written to be little more than showpieces for their male counterparts.
But I also think virtually all videogame writing is abysmal, so.
But I also think virtually all videogame writing is abysmal, so.
Riposte
Member
Ignoring her troubled examples (the demands for what a "personality" is seems to change radically at a whim, from Leon (invulnerable quipper) to a BioWare character (vulnerable husbando/waifu bait) to Link (facial expressions, sometimes), the real fact of the matter is that this girl is being a weirdo geek and expects that to be universal. It's somewhat passable in some situations to say a videogame girl is sexy (because they are representations of something sexy), but to make this about the connection you have with the character and about dating potential and shit is pretty fucking weird. And for men, utterly emasculating and uncool. Nevermind any sort of jealously people are getting mad about being pointed out, what's a man have to gain by revealing he wants to wife a videogame character, to anyone, even himself? Nothing, which is why this only comes out amongst strangers on the internet (unless they are socially fucked up, which apparently includes some of her friends).
As for why there are more men for choices (however you define personality), it's because there are more male characters in central roles. With that pointed out, the rest becomes a bunch of pointless blathering dancing around the main point, probably in order to look like they had something original to say.
As for why there are more men for choices (however you define personality), it's because there are more male characters in central roles. With that pointed out, the rest becomes a bunch of pointless blathering dancing around the main point, probably in order to look like they had something original to say.
ElBoxyBrown
Banned
We must wait for VR to see if humanity is ready to fancy pixels.
Yeah, I feel the exact same way. I just think that the dialogue present in games' media today makes it possible for more of these things to come out of the woodwork. It's a vicious cycle.
I don't recall any engaging story with interaction between the two genders where women are just objects. Stories just flat-out don't work with that dynamic.
No we don't, the sales of many cheesecake games show that plenty of people fancy pixels.
John Kowalski
Banned
I'd go on a date with Cassandra.
I don't think she would like it though.
I don't think she would like it though.
ElBoxyBrown
Banned
I mean REALLY fancy.
When people are going on dates with Love Plus girls and making them birthday cakes and hooking fuck machines up to their computer to "control" hentai games, I'm not sure how much more you can "fancy" a game character.
meltingparappa
Member
You're allowed to laugh and cry and feel every potential swath of emotions at a fictional videogame character, but god forbid you're that fucking weirdo who gets physically attracted to an artistic representation of traits some percentage of human beings find attractive.
So instead it's socially acceptable to say that Link isn't sexy, but he has a really good personality when he stands around blinking and saying nothing, and thus you can stay on your high horse and repeat a blanket statement about gender representation without anything necessarily new or insightful to say, other than the launching point for your thesis comes with someone who maybe just wanted to keep playing Monster Hunter that night.
Here's a bonus image of poor Link unable to find the dozens of female characters who are both subjectively "sexy" and socially "fancy-able" mentioned in this thread.
So instead it's socially acceptable to say that Link isn't sexy, but he has a really good personality when he stands around blinking and saying nothing, and thus you can stay on your high horse and repeat a blanket statement about gender representation without anything necessarily new or insightful to say, other than the launching point for your thesis comes with someone who maybe just wanted to keep playing Monster Hunter that night.
Here's a bonus image of poor Link unable to find the dozens of female characters who are both subjectively "sexy" and socially "fancy-able" mentioned in this thread.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
Okay, since I've apparently grossly misrepresented you, then please explain the difference between "wisely avoided her trap" and "wisely ducked a loaded question [...]".
Ahem:
Uh-huh...
To her credit, she also asked some friends, lol
But seriously, it's a bit of a weird article. There's certainly no shortage of guys who fancy videogame ladies. The only thing I can really gather from it is that we need better written characters. That's not a gender exclusive problem though.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
I'm not sure I agree with that either. Lots of comic book heroines have overcome their initial designs.
Yet the same thing clearly happens with many male characters, and they aren't defined by their looks. The same thing can be done and has been done with women.
Massive Duck. C.M.
Banned
You think many male characters are designed for sex appeal?
Many male characters are designed to look good, yes. Just like many female characters.
In my edit, I was saying how it's possible to have more to the character outside of the designs even if their looks were the foundation.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
...What? You think male characters are designed for sex appeal towards women (or gay men) first? Really now.
1) Many but not necessarily "most", unlike for women
2) "looking good" is different than "having sex appeal". John Marston might be a good looking man but he was clearly not designed to appeal to ladies first. Surely you understand the difference?
Another example would be, say, if we took female side-kicks. Take this vs this. Both are attractive women but you see the difference in design philosophy, yes?
Dice
Pokémon Parentage Conspiracy Theorist
I definitely disagree with that. Lulu for example was the best character in FFX. She was immediately more mature, intelligent, likable, and focused than the others. She was pretty much the leader of the group. I think of all those things, not just her big tits hanging out.
Her point there is also undermined when she says...
...which is basically the game equivalent of Ryan Gosling in Drive.
How about this idea: You aren't attracted to females, so you have no idea how attraction to their personality in dynamic with attraction to their looks works. It's a fool's errand to act like it has magical rules different from the way you stan your boy toy characters and then attempt to define what those rules are by conjecture from what a few guy friends said.
Stallion Dan
Member
So a character with awful one liners as his character...and in a jacket.
...and a mute character with no personality, and the glittered up version especially.
Really, really not good examples.
Ha yeah. I do indeed agree that there aren't many fanciable female characters in games (although I would add Elena!), but I also don't really feel like there need to be for any reason...
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
Unless the article stated that there could be zero existing counter-examples to the trend, I fail to see where you're going with this. Obviously not every single female character is a vapid sex toy, but I don't think the author is saying that, only that it's annoyingly common. No?
Yeah, I understand the difference, but who's to say that Nathan Drake or the entire FFXV cast wasn't designed to have sex appeal and look attractive (chest hair physics for Nathan Drake), and also have more to their characters than just their looks?
Again, as people have pointed out for female characters, Lulu is a big example of a character giving off a suggestive first impression but being remembered as something else entirely.
Shpeshal Nick
aka Collingwood
This.
Because honestly, I could easily just list the entire cast of Dead or Alive as women I wish I could fuck in real life.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
Again, a few counter-examples are not indicative of a trend (or lack thereof).
Dice
Pokémon Parentage Conspiracy Theorist
It's a trend in videogames to have shitty characters. I would completely disagree with any notion that would imply that the ratio of shitty female characters to good female characters is any worse than the ratio of shitty male characters to good male characters. If that is not a point she is trying to make, I don't understand what this article is even on about.
I'm not entirely disagreeing with that statement, but the way it comes off makes it seem like it has to be one or the other. It doesn't.
I kind of agree with the premise. I mean I'd prefer women with meaningful personalities that are decently written over simple pure eye candy. And that hold true even if the sex appeal character is well written since it can detract from the overall impression I get from said person. They can be made to apear good looking if need be, but being attractive doesn't necessarily mean looking sexy.
I think a good example is Tifa from FFVII. I think Tifa while kind of objectified for her big boobs and the whole tank top and mini skirt combo is a good character that's decently written. While visually she appears the sex appeal character, she doesn't remotely act like it and if anything falls into the mother/nurturer archetype. That's why even if they're one and the same character, I much prefer her Advent Children iteration. One of them comes off as a sexy character with skimpy attire and overly large boobs, while the other is pretty without going too far. While both have the same character behind them, the latter is easier to take more seriously.
I think a good example is Tifa from FFVII. I think Tifa while kind of objectified for her big boobs and the whole tank top and mini skirt combo is a good character that's decently written. While visually she appears the sex appeal character, she doesn't remotely act like it and if anything falls into the mother/nurturer archetype. That's why even if they're one and the same character, I much prefer her Advent Children iteration. One of them comes off as a sexy character with skimpy attire and overly large boobs, while the other is pretty without going too far. While both have the same character behind them, the latter is easier to take more seriously.
Funny that the author mentions Thane as he was designed around being a female love interest:
http://www.gameinformer.com/b/featu...ct-the-creation-of-thane.aspx?PostPageIndex=1
http://www.gameinformer.com/b/featu...ct-the-creation-of-thane.aspx?PostPageIndex=1
Retrocore9
Banned
How about Jack from Mass Effect 2?
Loved this character. When I found out she wasn't playable in Mass Effect 3 I was very disappointed.
Loved this character. When I found out she wasn't playable in Mass Effect 3 I was very disappointed.
SuperAngelo64
Banned
Master Yoshi
Member
I'm reminded of this,
And how this looks so much better...
And how this looks so much better...
I think the counter examples were to show that the looks don't have to define the characters which she is clearly stating
...you would run screaming from her wildly disproportionate frame?
I think most people in this thread are assuming a major dodge, but what if he was telling the truth.
I can't say I have any fantasy crushes on fictional characters be it in games, books, etc...
I think this is a more common theme with women(or maybe I'm wrong, based off this thread). The fan-fic scene certainly seems to be skewed toward that direction. Within my circle, my male friends are more likely to discuss women we know in some way (cute waitress at the coffee shop, girl in a class, someone at the gym, etc...) than actresses, media stars, or characters from video games/books while our female counterparts gush on about male celebs, pop stars, or snape slashfic depending on the girl.
I can't say I have any fantasy crushes on fictional characters be it in games, books, etc...
I think this is a more common theme with women(or maybe I'm wrong, based off this thread). The fan-fic scene certainly seems to be skewed toward that direction. Within my circle, my male friends are more likely to discuss women we know in some way (cute waitress at the coffee shop, girl in a class, someone at the gym, etc...) than actresses, media stars, or characters from video games/books while our female counterparts gush on about male celebs, pop stars, or snape slashfic depending on the girl.
Trend for male protagonists is to be (mostly male)power-fantasies, which is generally portrayed to also be sexually attractive to opposite gender(s). At least, it's a rather pervasive theme in all forms of media and general social preconceptions.Morrigan Stark said:
This article sounds like:
Although she has a point, but one thing does not exclude the other.
LMAO XD
That's a risky question even for a girl (＾▽＾
Ganzlinger
Member
Mitsuru Kirijo from Persona
That's a fancy woman for sure.
That's a fancy woman for sure.
Similar threads
- Poll