• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Addicted to tanning: This could be you at age 26... Dead...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vanillalite

Ask me about the GAF Notebook
Yahoo!

A Death by Suntan at Age 26
By Cosmopolitan.com | Work + Money – Tue, Mar 23, 2010 5:41 PM EDT

For years, Glenna Kohl pursued a tan, both in the sun and in tanning beds - which new research shows are far deadlier than once thought. By 22, she was battling the most lethal form of skin cancer.

In April 2005, while working out at her college gym in Rhode Island, 22-year-old Glenna Kohl detected a hard, golf ball-size lump near her groin. She left the gym and went home to put ice on what seemed like a sports injury.

When her roommate, Courtney Caulfield, now 25, returned to their apartment that evening, Glenna asked her to feel the lump. "I told Glenna she probably pulled a muscle," recalls Courtney. "She wasn't overly worried; she seemed more upset about cutting short her workout."

But the lump hadn't gone away by the time she graduated from Salve Regina University the next month. So Glenna, then living at her parents' home in Massachusetts, visited her family doctor. Puzzled, she referred Glenna to a surgeon, who scheduled a biopsy.

A few days later, the surgeon handed Glenna and her family a terrifying diagnosis: The lump was melanoma, the deadliest of the three forms of skin cancer. When caught at an earlier stage, melanoma - which typically begins as an irregular-shaped mole or a bump on the skin - is highly curable. But by the time it reaches stage III, as Glenna's had, the cancer has spread beyond the skin and into the lymph nodes (that's why the lump she felt was in her groin, where there's a cluster of lymph nodes). Only about half the people with her level of stage III melanoma survive for 10 years.

The news came as a total shock. "No one in our family knew what melanoma was," recalls Glenna's mother, Colleen Kohl. "We did a lot of crying."

Mystified about how the cancer had reached stage III without Glenna spotting any suspicious moles on her body, the surgeon eventually pored over her medical records. He found something disturbing: In high school, Glenna did have an irregular mole removed from her leg. A pathology report identified it as benign, but the surgeon tested it again. The lab had made an error: The mole was an early stage melanoma.

"We can't know for sure, but her odds of beating melanoma would have been greater had it been diagnosed earlier," says Donald Lawrence, Glenna's oncologist and clinical director of the Center for Melanoma at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Cancer Center, in Boston.

The misdiagnosis infuriated Glenna's parents. But she didn't share their anger, says her mother. Even when the Kohls' lawyer confirmed they had a case of medical negligence, Glenna - positive thinking and not one to dwell on the what-ifs - agreed to let the lab settle out of court. "She wasn't resentful; she focused on getting better," says her father, Bob. "Back when we all first got the news, it wasn't a matter of if but how soon she'd be cancer-free."

A Deadly Habit

It's hard to imagine a less likely cancer victim than Glenna. Growing up on Cape Cod, she'd always been a stickler for health. A vegetarian, she did yoga, hiked, jogged, and rowed regularly. She was just 5-foot-3 and 105 pounds, yet she was strong enough to work as a beach lifeguard five summers in a row. Health interested her so much that she applied for jobs in nutrition before graduating from college, despite having majored in finance.

But Glenna did indulge in one unhealthy practice: tanning. Like millions of young women, she believed that a bronzed look made her more attractive. While life-guarding, she exposed her naturally pale skin to the sun's rays for 40 hours each week, protected only by sunscreen with an SPF of 4, says her friend and fellow lifeguard Jillian Blumberg. (Dermatologists say that sunscreen with an SPF of 15 is the minimum needed to safeguard skin.)

To maintain that copper glow, Glenna booked time at tanning salons. She began at age 16 and continued through college, baking under a sunlamp as often as once a week.

Though she knew that all that outdoor sun and indoor-tanning time were bad for her skin, she didn't think there was a serious risk. "As health-conscious as Glenna was, she didn't connect tanning with skin cancer," says Colleen.

Yet tanning is connected to skin cancer. Studies have shown that exposure to UV rays can trigger changes to the DNA in skin cells that may lead to cancerous growths. The two most common types of skin cancer, basal cell carcinoma and squamous cell carcinoma, are almost always linked to UV exposure. And 90 percent of cases of the less common but more deadly form, melanoma, also are attributed to UV exposure, says Darrell S. Rigel, MD, a professor of clinical dermatology at New York University.

Sun exposure sans sunscreen is a big culprit. But indoor-tanning beds also can result in cancer. A major report released this past August reclassified tanning beds as "carcinogenic to humans." And a person's melanoma risk rises 75 percent if he or she started using a tanning bed before age 30.

Glenna's diagnosis was, sadly, part of a trend: Melanoma is the second most frequently reported cancer in women in their 20s, and it's third only to breast and thyroid cancers for women in their 30s, reports the National Cancer Institute. "Melanoma is one of the few forms of cancer that's on the rise," says Dr. Rigel. The tan look so desired by young women may explain why 20- and 30-somethings are diagnosed with the disease at alarming rates, he adds.

Focused to Fight

At first, Glenna didn't reflect on what might have caused her cancer. She was determined to beat the disease and then get on with her life.

In August 2005, treatment began. MGH oncologists removed 13 lymph nodes from Glenna's groin, including the one with the golf ball-size lump. Then she began six weeks of radiation and six months of injections of interferon alfa-2b, a drug believed to help the immune system fight melanoma.

It was a grueling summer for Glenna, who endured extreme side effects, like fatigue and flu symptoms. But she told her parents, "Whatever I have to do to fight cancer, I'll do," recalls Bob.

Glenna also tried to maintain a normal life, leaning on friends Courtney and Jillian for support and attending Red Sox games with her new boyfriend, Will Robinson, now 28.

As the effects of the treatments took their toll, Glenna's long blond hair thinned out, and she started wearing a wig. Her strong facade was beginning to show cracks, especially after a night out with Will, during which an acquaintance told Glenna about a friend who was dying of melanoma.

"Up until then, Glenna had never accepted that she might not get well," says Colleen. "Hearing about this other person blew her out of the water. She came home that night, crawled into bed with us, and sobbed."
Find out what to do if you screw up and get a sunburn.

Scary News

By spring, Glenna faced fresh setbacks. Will, a sergeant in the Army Reserve, got orders to go to Iraq for 18 months. Glenna wrote him daily, and they chatted online often.

Then more devastating news arrived: In May 2006, Glenna detected a pea-size lump on her abdomen. A biopsy confirmed the melanoma had returned - now at stage IV, the worst possible stage. But instead of pitying herself, Glenna announced she was going to fight harder.

To battle the tumors that were spreading throughout her body, doctors put her on a different treatment to try to boost her immune system and gave her another round of radiation when they found that the cancer had spread to her brain. Glenna did what she could at home: She drew strength by reading memoirs by cancer patients and books on holistic treatments.

Glenna also began to speak out publicly about the dangers of sun exposure and indoor tanning. She'd come to realize that even though the misdiagnosis by the lab let the cancer develop unchecked, it was her tanning habit - which she gave up the day she was diagnosed - that likely triggered her melanoma in the first place.

One Last Chance

Despite the treatments, Glenna's condition worsened in 2007. But Glenna, ever hopeful, decided to sign up for clinical trials at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), in Maryland.

Glenna lived on the NIH campus for weeks at a time, enduring harsh side effects like crippling nausea and a 20-pound weight gain. During one stay, she dropped her brave front and opened up to Courtney online. "I asked how she was feeling, and she wrote, 'So sick. I can't stop crying,'" recalls Courtney.

When Will returned home from Iraq, the two agreed to just be friends. "Glenna said she didn't want to drag me through her illness," says Will. Adds Courtney: "She was upset, but she didn't have time to mope. She was fighting for her life."

A Legacy of Hope

In January 2008, doctors announced that some of Glenna's tumors were shrinking. But three months later came news that the tumors were growing again. There was nothing doctors could do to stabilize or cure her.

Back home, Glenna's condition went downhill. Lesions in her brain triggered by the cancer slurred her speech, and she wasted away to about 80 pounds. In November, Glenna hit her head in the shower, resulting in brain trauma. A month later, she died of melanoma at home. She was 26.

Her devastated parents launched the Glenna Kohl Fund for Hope, which raises awareness about melanoma and the importance of cancer screenings and UV protection. "Glenna's not here to inform people of the dangers," says Colleen, "so we're going to continue her work for her."

New Regulations on Tanning Beds

Cosmo was recently invited to speak at a government-sponsored hearing to try to persuade the FDA to take on tighter regulation of tanning beds. Right now, tanning beds are considered "class one" medical devices...meaning they get the same FDA oversight as a package of band-aids! Well, we know they warrant a lot more regulation than that.

We're especially thrilled that the FDA Advisory Committee recommended reclassifying them to Class II or possibly even Class III. That's great news because it means that tanning beds and booths would be more closely regulated. If this happens, hopefully less women will go tanning and skin cancer rates might decrease.

The Committee agreed that one of the ways they should be more regulated is by banning people under 18 from indoor tanning or requiring that they have a parent's OK.

PS: PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE WATCH THIS VIDEO AND HEED THE MESSAGE!

Youtube Video!
 
030611finaldestination.jpg


in all seriousness though.
 

Nemesis_

Member
People get spray tans. Are they much better? I realise UV Exposure is dramatically decreased but surely there's some other side effect or something we're not seeing right now?
 

Darklord

Banned
People get spray tans. Are they much better? I realise UV Exposure is dramatically decreased but surely there's some other side effect or something we're not seeing right now?

Spray tan is just like staining your skin. Tanning beds are blasting UV right into your skin creating cancer.
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
The news came as a total shock. "No one in our family knew what melanoma was," recalls Glenna's mother, Colleen Kohl. "We did a lot of crying."

But Glenna did indulge in one unhealthy practice: tanning. Like millions of young women, she believed that a bronzed look made her more attractive. While life-guarding, she exposed her naturally pale skin to the sun's rays for 40 hours each week, protected only by sunscreen with an SPF of 4, says her friend and fellow lifeguard Jillian Blumberg. (Dermatologists say that sunscreen with an SPF of 15 is the minimum needed to safeguard skin.)

To maintain that copper glow, Glenna booked time at tanning salons. She began at age 16 and continued through college, baking under a sunlamp as often as once a week.

Nathan-Fillion-reaction-gif.gif
 
My only experience with this is seeing a clip for the Jersey Shore where an orange guy goes, "I wana do the max. Twice."

I don't understand the fake tanning fad. I think it looks ugly, but now I'm kinda glad that it's also weeding people out.
 
How long before someone makes a "Danger, DANGER WILL ROBINSON!" joke?

I love the way tan women (and men, I guess) look, but it is just not worth the risk to be highly tanned. I convinced my girlfriend to give up the tanning bed, but that was aided by her dad having a couple very small and detected early cancerous moles removed.
 

Vanillalite

Ask me about the GAF Notebook
Even if you aren't a tanning bed person I implore you to watch that video at the end and heed the message. Find a trusted friend, your significant other, a family member, or even just a mirror if you have to. Then strip down and check your body for any skin abnormalities.

A lot of skin stuff is easily handled and treatable if you just take the time every few months to just look and make sure you catch stuff early! A few mins say before or after you get out of the shower to check your body could end up being a life saver!
 
yeah, not doing that. It's sooooooooooooooooo fucking silly to want to have a tan all the time. It just makes me laugh and avoid.

Sad news for this person and family.
 
Even if you aren't a tanning bed person I implore you to watch that video at the end and heed the message. Find a trusted friend, your significant other, a family member, or even just a mirror if you have to. Then strip down and check your body for any skin abnormalities.

A lot of skin stuff is easily handled and treatable if you just take the time every few months to just look and make sure you catch stuff early! A few mins say before or after you get out of the shower to check your body could end up being a life saver!

You sound pretty emotional.
Do you have some personal experience with this?
 

Vanillalite

Ask me about the GAF Notebook
You sound pretty emotional.
Do you have some personal experience with this?

Personally nope, but it's easy to do. It's just something I've learned from an early age. I played outside a ton as a kid, I had a pool in my backyard, went to the beach a lot, and my family has a lake house now. Plus my GF is fair skinned. So it's just something engrained in me to make sure you wear sunscreen and/or a hat + find shade when you can when you are outside! Plus treat tanning bed places like they are the plague.

It's also a recent topic they've gone over in my GF's nursing school class (she originally posted the article to FB), and she just said it's amazing how easy it is to just check so you don't have major issues down the road.
 

marrec

Banned
Holy shit that's never occurred to me.

I never made that connection either. *heh*

The things we do for perceived beauty can be terrible for our health and everyone who thinks they need to burn their skin to look beautiful should to take a good look in the mirror.
 
permanent tan baby - wooo



Seriously though, what a terrible way to go. Tanning def played a part but the error in the mole sample is just inexcusable.
 
And the reason they are ashamed is because our culture make fair skin seem somehow less than tanned skin.

Sad really.

Which is strange cause people in countries with a large population of dark-skinned people see dark-skin as ugly and fair skin as beautiful (see India).
 
And the reason they are ashamed is because our culture make fair skin seem somehow less than tanned skin.

Sad really.

Yet in places like India, pale skin is favoured, with various skin products being sold that will whiten (or bleach) skin, and some people going to dangerous lengths to do so.

Human beings are weird.

Edit: Beaten hard.
 

Shiv47

Member
Though she knew that all that outdoor sun and indoor-tanning time were bad for her skin, she didn't think there was a serious risk. "As health-conscious as Glenna was, she didn't connect tanning with skin cancer," says Colleen.

<smacks head>
 

LuchaShaq

Banned
They probably should make it mandatory to examine people's skin whenever they visit a tanning salon. Gotta protect people from their own ignorance.




:(

As disgusting as the trend is that turns attractive women into traffic cones I don't see why this would be any more valid than McD's not serving fat people.
 

calza

Member
Seriously though, what a terrible way to go. Tanning def played a part but the error in the mole sample is just inexcusable.

This happens a lot when doctors look for what they think is wrong instead of actually looking at all the possible diagnosis.
 
Reading that it seems she had melanoma well before she even started tanning. Sure, the tanning wouldn't have helped, but she'd likely be dying either way right now because of the mistake that was made.
 

Munin

Member
My only experience with this is seeing a clip for the Jersey Shore where an orange guy goes, "I wana do the max. Twice."

I don't understand the fake tanning fad. I think it looks ugly, but now I'm kinda glad that it's also weeding people out.

Did you even read the article? She didn't have a "fake tan" but a real one. A spray tan is just like painting your skin.
 
it's pretty bad that the first lab missed that diagnosis, and definitely justifies some kind of settlement. from a pathology point of view, melanoma can be a really sneaky cancer to diagnose. rare under-diagnoses are an inevitability in the current state of affairs of pathology labs and medicine in general. unfortunately this one shortened or maybe even cost the patient her life.

the problem with melanoma though is that it behaves in sometimes mystifying ways, re-appearing 10 years later as a metastasis after an excision of a low stage tumor. i've seen it myself in residency as a pathologist and seen young people die of it a couple times in medical school. even with a low stage melanoma that was excised with a negative sentinel lymph node, there are still plenty of reports of people with metastases and death from melanoma. in her case she probably at least warranted a wide excision and lymph node biopsy after her original excision though.
 

big_z

Member
Tanning now and then lightly is okay. Girls that go weekly or more tend to look worn out and used up before they hit their late 20's.
 
This happens a lot when doctors look for what they think is wrong instead of actually looking at all the possible diagnosis.

I've had experience with doctors who just seem to base things off of statistics (i.e age, weight, race, smoking or non) as opposed to actually listening to a concern and checking it out.
 
I've had experience with doctors who just seem to base things off of statistics (i.e age, weight, race, smoking or non) as opposed to actually listening to a concern and checking it out.
diagnosing things has to be a balance of the patient's own words and available evidence, the statistics and pre-test probabilities of the various differential diagnoses and a whole bunch of other things. even stupid economic reasons must be considered in the current state of the medical industry. if a given doctor's balance tends to shift towards any one side then it's going to lead to trouble at some point.
 

JB1981

Member
I won't tan in a bed but I love tanning on the beach or by the pool with some sunscreen on. Nothing more therapeutic than being in the sun like that
 

leadbelly

Banned
One of my mother's friends had skin cancer on her nose. She actually got it removed early on but it came back. Unfortunately she was put on a waiting list and by the time they got to her they had to remove most of her nose.

It doesn't look that bad now though with all the surgery she had.
 

Dr.Guru of Peru

played the long game
I've had experience with doctors who just seem to base things off of statistics (i.e age, weight, race, smoking or non) as opposed to actually listening to a concern and checking it out.

As a GP (hell, even as a pathologist), you really have to look at things like demographics to guide you on what to look for. But that doesn't excuse the doctor from not listening to the patient and asking the appropriate questions.
 

Dr.Guru of Peru

played the long game
I won't tan in a bed but I love tanning on the beach or by the pool with some sunscreen on. Nothing more therapeutic than being in the sun like that

If you're being tanned, it means you're not putting on enough sunscreen to protect you. Your skin is being damaged.
 

Vanillalite

Ask me about the GAF Notebook
If you're being tanned, it means you're not putting on enough sunscreen to protect you. Your skin is being damaged.

Basically this! I know it's sort of engrained in our minds from a kid that during the summer going to the pool, beach, or lake and getting a tan is sort of part of the fun. It's just not that good for your body though. You need to use higher sun screen than you probably think honestly. just putting on SPF 15 isn't exactly going to do much.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Why does SP 4 even exist? WTF. I had SP 60 in South America, still got tanned a plenty.
 

Kagari

Crystal Bearer
Never understood people who go weekly to tan. Actually, I don't understand the appeal of tanning to begin with... you're just killing yourself quicker.
 
If you have fair skin, trying to get tanned is incredibly careless and dangerous. Period.

I cringe when people around me don't use sunscreen when outdoors (and real sunscreen not that spf 10 bs) and I get pretty upset when I see parents who forbid their kids to go swimming less than 4 hours after lunch but don't putting any sunscreen on them.

This is a nicely made video, I'll pass it around.

Oh, and girls ? Fair skin is very sexy. Looking like parched leather past 35 is not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom