• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of the Year goes to ELDEN RING

Guilty_AI

Guilty_AI

Gold Member
image0.jpg
 
Kenneth Haight

Kenneth Haight

Gold Member
Thread is full of deluded fools. The only other option was Ragnarok and as many have said it was too “safe” but a solid performance.

Elden Ring is limited by its engine/performance but in terms of gameplay and atmosphere it’s nearly unparalleled….at least this year.
 
AtomicStarving

AtomicStarving

Member
Not my GOTY. I love souls series but if you pick the games since demon's souls it's the fucking same. Sekiro is the most original game created by From Software, period. I don't know wtf is goin on here lol.
 
Guilty_AI

Guilty_AI

Gold Member
DragonNCM

DragonNCM

Member
After finishing GoW:R I can safely say that ER was a better gaming experience. With GoW:R I didn't had feeling that I play new game. For me was like very god crafted DLC experiance......
 
levyjl1988

levyjl1988

Banned
Elden Ring won GOTY because it is multi platform. God of War is restricted only on PlayStation. I didn’t play God of War, so my vote goes to Elden Ring, a game I did play. When you restrict your games you restrict your reach.
 
FoxMcChief

FoxMcChief

Gold Member
levyjl1988 said:
Elden Ring won GOTY because it is multi platform. God of War is restricted only on PlayStation. I didn’t play God of War, so my vote goes to Elden Ring, a game I did play. When you restrict your games you restrict your reach.
Click to expand...
Exclusives have won this award before.
 
SmokedMeat

SmokedMeat

Gamer™
Loxus said:
This year's GOTY Awards had to be rigged.
GOW Ragnarök has:
Better Graphics
Better Story
Better Combat
Better Music/Audio
Better Performance
Innovation in Accessibility
Little to no bugs
List goes on.
Click to expand...

It probably won the first time it came out in 2018.
 
Last edited:
T

TitusTroy

Member
Ragnarok is a very good game but ER deserves GOTY...well deserved win...I really wanted some expansion/DLC news at the Game Awards...I was hoping for a Feb 2023 release
 
Last edited:
yamaci17

yamaci17

Member
Fully deserved. ER is one of a kind game. Ragnarök has a rushed and mediocre ending phase. That alone kills the vibe about any chance of it being "GOTY".

also, just because elden ring does not have fully fledged narrative cutscenes, it still conveys a great story about duality of a person and how it can lead to catastrophic consequences.
 
Represent.

Represent.

Represent(ative) of bad opinions
Loxus said:
This year's GOTY Awards had to be rigged.
GOW Ragnarök has:
Better Graphics
Better Story
Better Combat
Better Music/Audio
Better Performance
Innovation in Accessibility
Little to no bugs
List goes on.
Click to expand...
Dont know how any of this is even deniable.

Not to mention

Better production values
Better acting performances
Better writing
Most polished game since TLOU 2
Better feeling weapons
Better feeling hit reactions
 
AtomicStarving

AtomicStarving

Member
nani17 said:
I personally thought GOW was better by a mile but can't complain about Elden Ring winning its not a terrible game
Click to expand...
It's the nature of hyping up games that are fucking the same. If you play ds1, ds2, bloodborne, ds3 and ER <<<< ALL OF THEM is the same. Same items with different names etc. What FS do best is games that controls really good that's all, but their games are fucking the same, beside Sekiro.

BTW my favorite FS games is DS1 and Sekiro > masterpieces.
 
Last edited:
SteelCurtain 59

SteelCurtain 59

Member
Correction: "The Game Awards GOTY award goes to Elden Ring". They're award is no more prestigious (if anything it's less prestigious) than any other person's opinion of what their game of the year was. Sucks that we're no longer going to get another Soulsborne caliber game and instead get more bland uninspired open worlds
 
fart town usa

fart town usa

Member
Northeastmonk said:
Yeah! a billion times agree with GOTY 2022. It brought me closer to enjoying a game with “friends”. I didn’t get that from any other game this year. I felt like it was a collaboration, a journey, and appreciation of guidance. It was the ultimate adventure for me.
Click to expand...
Yea dude, ER got me into contact again with 2 of my closest friends from childhood. We'd text every few months to say hi but now we have a group chat and play coop every weekend.

It's awesome. Nice to reconnect with old friends and enjoy some HD gaming.
 
nightmare-slain

nightmare-slain

Member
SteelCurtain 59 said:
Correction: "The Game Awards GOTY award goes to Elden Ring". They're award is no more prestigious (if anything it's less prestigious) than any other person's opinion of what their game of the year was. Sucks that we're no longer going to get another Soulsborne caliber game and instead get more bland uninspired open worlds
Click to expand...
of course everyone has their own thoughts of what GOTY is but TGA asked people to vote and it turns out more people liked Elden Ring than God of War or any of the other nominations.
 
fart town usa

fart town usa

Member
Twinblade said:
Elden Ring is overrated as shit.
Click to expand...
It's really not though. It's 100% fine if it's not your thing but the game is a straight up masterpiece. That much should at least be accepted. There's plenty of games that I completely recognize as masterpieces but at the same time, I don't like them or want to play them (GOW reboot, GOW: R, TLOU, etc).
 
Last edited:
FoxMcChief

FoxMcChief

Gold Member
fart town usa said:
It's really not though. It's 100% fine if it's not your thing but the game is a straight up masterpiece. That much should at least be accepted. There's plenty of games that I completely recognize as masterpieces but at the same time, I don't like them or want to play them (GOW reboot, GOW: R, TLOU, etc).
Click to expand...
I wouldn’t use the M-word, but it’s fucking awesome.
 
ResurrectedContrarian

ResurrectedContrarian

Suffers with mild autism
“Cinematic” / movie-like games are a terrible thing so I’m happy to see Elden Ring take the win. If you want to watch a fully-acted story, even the greatest games only make for mid-tier movies. Just watch an actual film. Let games be games, kill all that cutscene trash.
 
Twinblade

Twinblade

Member
fart town usa said:
It's really not though. It's 100% fine if it's not your thing but the game is a straight up masterpiece. That much should at least be accepted. There's plenty of games that I completely recognize as masterpieces but at the same time, I don't like them or want to play them (GOW reboot, GOW: R, TLOU, etc).
Click to expand...

As somebody already mentioned, it's basically Dark Souls.
 
sendit

sendit

Member
fart town usa said:
It's really not though. It's 100% fine if it's not your thing but the game is a straight up masterpiece. That much should at least be accepted. There's plenty of games that I completely recognize as masterpieces but at the same time, I don't like them or want to play them (GOW reboot, GOW: R, TLOU, etc).
Click to expand...
They removed way points and added an open world aspect to a game with a combat system that hasn't changed since Demon Souls. Give me an open world Sekiro.
 
Last edited:
fart town usa

fart town usa

Member
Jesb said:
If blood borne and dark souls was too hard for you should you stay away from this?
Click to expand...
Not at all. I haven't been able to even make it to the first boss in Bloodborne. I was pretty good at Dark Souls after a while.

Elden Ring is honestly pretty easy if you take your time and just explore. There's so many QOL type things to make it so you aren't ever set back too far when it comes to grace points (check points). There's also coop which is really easy to do and Spirit Summons which are like AI partners and you can level them up, etc.
 
Last edited:
Aenima

Aenima

Member
Not my GOTY, not even my favorite souls game, but its deserved. Only GoW Ragnarok and Elden Ring was GOTY material this year.

Happy for Gran Turismo 7 for geting its deserved best racing/ sports game award, after so many ppl trying to downplay how good the game is, and happy for Stray for the best indie game, was a short but very cool experience.

I think most awards was well deserved.
 
Aenima

Aenima

Member
Jesb said:
If blood borne and dark souls was too hard for you should you stay away from this?
Click to expand...
Yes. Elden Ring dificulty is all over the place. Some bosses are too easy, some are too hard. Having a open world just makes it more confusing for u to know where u should go next to find bosses to ur level. Dark Souls and Bloodborne while challenging they are more well balanced games.
 
semiconscious

semiconscious

Gold Member
metaverse said:
They removed way points and added an open world aspect to a game with a combat system that hasn't changed since Demon Souls. Give me an open world Sekiro.
Click to expand...
well, wait a sec. open world sekiro = good, but open world demon's souls = not good? what's that all about?...
 
Musashipan

Musashipan

Member
Is anyone even surprised?
It's clear that ER is superior in every aspect.
Well deserved. And I'm not a fan of souls series.
 
sendit

sendit

Member
semiconscious said:
well, wait a sec. open world sekiro = good, but open world demon's souls = not good? what's that all about?...
Click to expand...
Sekiro's combat >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Demon's Souls/Dark Souls/Elden Ring
 
Last edited:
nkarafo

nkarafo

Member
I was expecting something more casual and safe for the average joe. like GoW or Horizon.

Guess even they couldn't ignore how much better Elden Ring is, as a game. Good for them but i still don't really care.


Loxus said:
This year's GOTY Awards had to be rigged.
GOW Ragnarök has:
Better Graphics
Better Story
Better Combat
Better Music/Audio
Better Performance
Innovation in Accessibility
Little to no bugs
List goes on.
Click to expand...

Better combat? As in, better than Elden Ring? I mean, Elden Ring is not Sekiro, nothing is Sekiro, but it's still Dark Souls quality.

Also, apparently, extreme hand holding and a side character explaining how to solve a bunch of playskool puzzles is "innovation in accessibility"?.



metaverse said:
Sekiro's combat >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Demon's Souls/Dark Souls/Elden Ring >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Every other game in the awards lists.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Elden Ring balance patch 1.12
2 3 4
173
12K
The Cockatrice replied
Elden Ring Shadow of Erdtree Drop on June 18th
Review Hype
9
1K
Gideon replied
  • Poll
Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree | Review Thread
Analysis Review 4 5 6 7 8
353
29K
bargeparty replied
"Xbox players need to get good" - Elden Ring completion rate on Xbox is 1/2 that of Steam and PS
Analysis Hardware Platform 2 3
121
6K
MacReady13 replied
Gamespot: "Hidetaka Miyazaki On Bringing Elden Ring To A Close And The Future Of From Software"
25
2K
Gojiira replied
Top Bottom